Tilly
Platinum Member
I think Lucy was suggesting something along the lines of 'your disgusting beliefs are not compatible with those of the West so if you wish to cling to them, do so among like minded people'. But that's just a guess. She certainly did not suggest genocide.Those are questions you should be asking of the person who wrote them.Then Where in that post did Lucy say genocide Muslims?Yes ISLAM (ideas) Muslims (people). See the difference?
No. When you want to exterminate the people who hold those so called "ideas" that is what I define as genocide. When you kill all of them, the idea dies with them.
That is what I base my reasoning off of. For an idea to exist it must be formed in the mind of an individual.
Even if Islam were an "idea" it would still be wrong to exterminate each and every last one of them who holds it. To kill the idea you have to kill the people who support it. And you have to do a thorough job, or the idea will persist.
In this case you would need to systematically wipe out nearly 1.3 billion Muslims.
This is not something I will stand for.
Surely you aren't serious:
"Islam itself needs exterminating, if you don't take Islam down then it'll keep breeding new generations of Islamist Terrorists, they are getting their philosophy from The Qur'an as preached by Mohammed and as preached in turn his words from the Imans in the Mosques."
And by what method would one go about exterminating Islam? Oppression? Genocide? What would be the most effective method?
However, Lucy STILL DID NOT SAY GENOCIDE MUSLIMS, did she now?
How do you exterminate a religion without exterminating its followers? Can you answer me that? You seem to think this is so cut and dry. It's not, really.