Israeli border police officer pushing a wheelchair-bound Palestinian man to the ground

[Shusha]

Naw the evil jewish immigrant wanted the child to bleed out before help could get to her, by the way Palestinians are semites too, are they not?

So how can you tell when a claim or post is antisemitism as opposed to valid criticism of Israel?

1. Is the incident reported factually?
2. Is the incident given context?
3. Are portions of the incident removed or ignored or not presented?
4. Is the motive or intent of the actors assumed or assigned, particularly a negative intent?
5. Is the language used designed to appeal to emotions?
6. Is one of the actors, or the group that the actor belongs, to dehumanized?
7. Is one of the actors labelled broadly and negatively, especially with "hot button" terms?

So let's take a look at your comments in this thread:

Bystanders near the West Bank town of Hebron filmed an Israeli border police officer pushing a wheelchair-bound Palestinian man to the ground on Sunday,
The video footage shows the unidentified officer tipping the Palestinian man out of his wheelchair near the city’s historic Tomb of the Patriarchs. ...

No context. Portions removed.

even disabled people are not safe from these thugs

Appeal to emotion. Assigning intent. Labelling actors (and groups) broadly and negatively (dangerous thugs).

Majed al-Fakhouri, The man in the Wheelchair, had Human instinct to help a bleeding child, unlike the Izzy thug

Dehumanizing Israelis/Jews by comparing the man as having human instinct while the "Izzy thug" does not. Appeal to emotion. Lack of context. Portions removed. Name-calling (Izzy). Labelling actors negatively (thug).

Naw the evil jewish immigrant wanted the child to bleed out before help could get to her

Appeal to emotion. Assigning evil intent. Labelling actors, and group actor belongs to, broadly and negatively.



Yep. Definitely not a valid criticism of Israel. Just plain ol' antisemitism.

 

[fanger]

If Semitism is invading People´s land and stealing it, killing anyone who asks for equal rights and justice, then who would not be proud of the label ¨Anti-semite¨?

 

[Shusha]

If Semitism is invading People´s land and stealing it, killing anyone who asks for equal rights and justice, then who would not be proud of the label ¨Anti-semite¨?

Ah, see? Now there you go again. Since when do moral people "ask" for equal rights and justice with a knife?

 

[fanger]

If Semitism is invading People´s land and stealing it, killing anyone who asks for equal rights and justice, then who would not be proud of the label ¨Anti-semite¨?

Ah, see? Now there you go again. Since when do moral people "ask" for equal rights and justice with a knife?

When they are oppressed and dont have access to firearms?

 

[ForeverYoung436]

If Semitism is invading People´s land and stealing it, killing anyone who asks for equal rights and justice, then who would not be proud of the label ¨Anti-semite¨?

Ah, see? Now there you go again. Since when do moral people "ask" for equal rights and justice with a knife?

When they are oppressed and dont have access to firearms?

And what if those people elect officials who reject every peace proposal put forth to them since the year 2000, so their "oppressors" have no choice but to continue with an occupation, so that the cycle never ends? (Kind of a long sentence there.)

 

[Phoenall]

Majed al-Fakhouri, The man in the Wheelchair, had Human instinct to help a bleeding child, unlike the Izzy thug

I would have shot his brains out but he doesn't have one.

Of course you would have, from behind your computer, pussy you´d have probably missed and shot Israel´s reputation in the foot, as do the IDF time and time again

Aw! Jews winning!

Whining, the word is spelt WHINING

you think jews dont win ?
they controlling everything in your country.
media-politic-bussiness

Proven to be islamonazi propaganda and LIES to cover up for the Islamic control of the media and governments

 

[Phoenall]

I would have shot his brains out but he doesn't have one.

Of course you would have, from behind your computer, pussy you´d have probably missed and shot Israel´s reputation in the foot, as do the IDF time and time again

Aw! Jews winning!

Whining, the word is spelt WHINING

you think jews dont win ?
they controlling everything in your country.
media-politic-bussiness

Not in my country, they were kicked out in 1492- 1492, the expulsion of the jew

So you live in a backward, intolerant and racist country do you

 

[Phoenall]

Yasmin Rashad al-Zarou
Zarou was with her sister, had not attempted to attack anyone, and was walking away from a military checkpoint when she was fired upon six times.

And those assholes are too stupid to figure out why people throw rocks at them.

And of course the islamonazi propagandist source is telling the truth and the video was in no way doctored to cut out the criminal behaviour if the Palestinian. You try walking down the street in your neighbourhood making threats of violence and see how quickly the local police have you surrounded and with drawn weapons. Then see how quickly they shoot when you refuse to comply with their requests to lie face down with your arms stretched out.


Guess the Palestinian assholes are too stupid to realise that they will be shot if they show the smallest amount of aggressive behaviour like throwing stones ( illegal and carries the death penalty under Jordanian law which is in force in Palestine ) will get you shot. Guess the Palestinians will have to bring some more illegal immigrants in to make up the losses.

 

[Phoenall]

If Semitism is invading People´s land and stealing it, killing anyone who asks for equal rights and justice, then who would not be proud of the label ¨Anti-semite¨?

Ah, see? Now there you go again. Since when do moral people "ask" for equal rights and justice with a knife?

When they are oppressed and dont have access to firearms?

Why do they need firearms when talking like an adult would bring the result they want ? Would you give a pyromaniac a box of matches and a bottle of kerosene, so why give a psychopathic mass murderer a gun ?

 

[Shusha]

If Semitism is invading People´s land and stealing it, killing anyone who asks for equal rights and justice, then who would not be proud of the label ¨Anti-semite¨?

Ah, see? Now there you go again. Since when do moral people "ask" for equal rights and justice with a knife?

When they are oppressed and dont have access to firearms?

Oh please. I'm not buying your "poor oppressed people" routine which claims that the poor helpless Palestinians have no choice but to send their children out to the streets to stab random women, children and elderly. The Arab citizens of Israel do have full equal rights (including the right to gun ownership, btw). So, you are just seeking justification for killing Jews.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Yasmin Rashad al-Zarou
Zarou was with her sister, had not attempted to attack anyone, and was walking away from a military checkpoint when she was fired upon six times.

And those assholes are too stupid to figure out why people throw rocks at them.

And of course the islamonazi propagandist source is telling the truth and the video was in no way doctored to cut out the criminal behaviour if the Palestinian. You try walking down the street in your neighbourhood making threats of violence and see how quickly the local police have you surrounded and with drawn weapons. Then see how quickly they shoot when you refuse to comply with their requests to lie face down with your arms stretched out.


Guess the Palestinian assholes are too stupid to realise that they will be shot if they show the smallest amount of aggressive behaviour like throwing stones ( illegal and carries the death penalty under Jordanian law which is in force in Palestine ) will get you shot. Guess the Palestinians will have to bring some more illegal immigrants in to make up the losses.

...the local police...​

They are not local police. They are foreign troops.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Yasmin Rashad al-Zarou
Zarou was with her sister, had not attempted to attack anyone, and was walking away from a military checkpoint when she was fired upon six times.

And those assholes are too stupid to figure out why people throw rocks at them.

And of course the islamonazi propagandist source is telling the truth and the video was in no way doctored to cut out the criminal behaviour if the Palestinian. You try walking down the street in your neighbourhood making threats of violence and see how quickly the local police have you surrounded and with drawn weapons. Then see how quickly they shoot when you refuse to comply with their requests to lie face down with your arms stretched out.


Guess the Palestinian assholes are too stupid to realise that they will be shot if they show the smallest amount of aggressive behaviour like throwing stones ( illegal and carries the death penalty under Jordanian law which is in force in Palestine ) will get you shot. Guess the Palestinians will have to bring some more illegal immigrants in to make up the losses.

...the local police...​

They are not local police. They are foreign troops.

Foreign troops versus foreign Arabs.