PoliticalChic
Diamond Member
And? The guy punched him in the face. Did the guy who got punched have any way of knowing that the guy who did the punching wasn't going to beat him to a bloody pulp, or stab him, or shoot him? Nope. The guy did what anyone would do when attacked, he defended himself. If someone decides to attack another individual the individual being attacked has every right to defend himself ... be it with their fists, a pipe, a knife, a gun, etc. Don't want to get punched, or whacked with a pipe, or stabbed or shot? Don't attack other people with your body or anything else.
"The guy did what anyone would do when attacked..."
I don't believe so.
1. The station was closed....he could have ignored the customer
2. The opened the locked door, and engaged in in the verbal dispute
3. The punch had very limited effect
4. If the attack had continued, or a deadly weapon used, the use of the gun would have been appropriate. Not here.
5. "anyone" would not have behave so....and I can prove it.
Licensed gun owners try to avoid the use of the gun....
"In 91.7% of these incidents the defensive use of a gun did not wound or kill the criminal attacker."
Source: "Armed Resistance to Crime: The Prevalence and Nature of Self-Defense with a Gun," by Gary Kleck and Marc Gertz, in The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, Northwestern University School of Law, Volume 86, Number 1, Fall, 1995
and
But violent crimes have been rare among carrying a concealed weapon license holders. Only 2% of license holders have been sanctioned for any kind of misbehavior, State Police records show.
Guns Don?t Kill People; Dangerous Minorities Do ? The Detroit Edition | Stuff Black People Don't Like 2.0
So...if you and I were on a jury and the charges were based on the vid, our votes would, it seems, be very different.
If I were on the jury I'd be seeing a whole lot more evidence from both sides about the case. Where's the rest of the surveillance vid? How did you get all that info from just watching the vid?
You cut my sentence. "The guy did what anyone would do when attacked..." You stopped there. What he did was to defend himself.Yes, someone who gets attacked will try to defend themselves. Many different ways to do that, not just with a gun."anyone" would not have behave so....and I can prove it.
The clerk had been held up and shot in the previous year. He got punched by an obviously angry guy so he defended himself and didn't take the chance on being shot again. Unfortunately for the attacker the guy's choice of self defense was a gun.
In the mornin you go gunnin'
For the man who stole your water
And you fire till he is done in
But they catch you at the border
And the mourners are all singin'
As they drag you by your feet
[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIoSL4GP398]Steely Dan - Do It Again With (Lyrics) - YouTube[/ame]