Peejay - if the hostage jumping was expected, how did the pirates allow him to get away with it ?
Maybe you should wait until you get more facts and understanding of the situation before you get into an argument over silly stuff. Phillips got away. The SEALS were in position at the ready.
It was over in a couple seconds. Why argue about it ?
If they didn't expect him to jump again, why would they tie him up to try and prevent it?
Gunny thinks the captain saved his own ass. I think that maybe the fact that the pirates were caused to be dead by the bullets fired into them may have contributed to his escape. Don't you?
here Gunny seems to acknowledge that the SEALS must have been prepared to do something.
There was no plan, numbnuts. Try reading, huh? Phillips jumping overboard was unexpected and killing the pirates seizing an opportunity. Contingency my ass.
But then he goes back to dumb luck. No plan? The guy had jumped once and they missed an opportunity and you think no one made the very simple observation of "hey....if this guy jumps again we will be ready." You know, a plan based on the simple knowledge that if he jumped once, it is reasonable to expect he may jump again.
Your problem seems to be that you cannot read and comprehend from one statement to the next. Nothing I have posted contradicts anything else I have posted, and in fact my posts support each other.
I'd say you need to learn to read, but the sad truth is you are WAY over your head trying to engage in a game of semantics and you aren't good at it.
Until Phillips did something, what rescue plan was in motion? Oh yeah ... none. In that regard he DID save his own ass and the SEALS did what they were trained to do and took out the pirates the second the opportunity presented itself.
Without him jumping in the water, the standoff would have remained.
I guess you don't buy your own logic then. Is that it? You know, if you burn your hand once are you going to stick it back in the fire expecting a different result?
The simple fact is, what you are trying to call a plan was shooters prepared to take advantage of an opportunity if one arose. THAT was all that was "planned." That was NOT a plan for Phillips to jump in the water again.