Question for liberals and Democrats about the Trump rally at Madison Square Garden

[Tumblin Tumbleweed]

See?

You are so stupid, you think you gain height by digging a hole.

Damn, kid: you truly are retarded.

Thanks, BackFlush. Always a treat.

 

[BackAgain]

Thanks, Always a treat.

Yeah. You’re not good for anything else, Fumblin’ Dickweed.

 

[Tumblin Tumbleweed]

Yeah. You’re not good for anything else, Fumblin’ Dickweed.

Good stuff, BackFlush.

 

[BackAgain]

Good stuff,

 

[alang1216]

Pt 1: kudos to you for at least trying to step up.

Pt 2: your contention is false. MAGA absolutely does NOT make such commentary about “immigrants.” Why can’t you guys ever admit the distinction between “immigrants” and “illegal immigrants?”

Also, isn’t it the goal of communism, here, to subvert America?

And isn’t it alright for a Political party to rally in opposition to any other POLITICAL entity which it sees as seeking to undermine us?

Kamalalala certainly can’t save America. She wouldn’t even be inclined to do so. She is a major part of the problem. So yeah; it is only Trump in this race who can steer us away from disaster.

Still no valid analogy between the Hitler rally and the Trump ELECTION rally.

 

[sartre play]

This question goes to our liberals and Democrats.

Please keep your answers concise. Brevity helps. Nobody wants to read a wall o’ words.

Question: for all the many complaints and claims and accusations I’ve read about Trump’s rally at MSG to the effect that it was somehow akin to a Hitler rally from Nazi Germany, I’d like to know the actual basis for that comparison.

I saw several such complaints and warnings even before the rally. But, factually, what (if anything) supports it?

Don't go to rallies, ( political party love ins). Read bills proposals, some TV or papers, & interviews.
its the bills put forward, We need to understand.
The rest is just loud conversation.

 

[BackAgain]

Don't go to rallies, ( political party love ins). Read bills proposals, some TV or papers, & interviews.
its the bills put forward, We need to understand.
The rest is just loud conversation.

Possibly some limited good advice

Not even remotely responsive to the question, however

 

[Tyrion234]

Note to trump. If you don't want yourself or your supporters to be compared to Nazis stop using the language of Nazis.

Echos of 1939 at Trump rally​

Speakers at both rallies raised alarm about immigration, Marxism and shady enemies within the U.S.

• Both events were immediately controversial, drawing protests outside the arena and condemnation from some in the press, along with sympathetic coverage from others in the media on ideological or free speech grounds.
• The remark that drew the most immediate backlash on Sunday was Comedian Tony Hinchcliffe's joke that Puerto Rico was "a floating island of garbage." Hinchcliffe also said Latinos made a lot of babies.

• Trump's rally featured speakers who had previously made racist and antisemitic remarks. Those include Trump himself, who has referred to immigrants as "poisoning the blood" of the nation, echoing Adolf Hitler.

The intrigue: Speakers at the Trump rally demanded a return to an earlier era of the U.S., but did not explicitly note that it had largely been controlled by white Americans.

https://www.axios.com/2024/10/28/trumps-msg-rally-1939-msg-nazi-event

Defining the Enemy​

Defining the Enemy

Nazi ideology aimed to promote the myth of an ideal national community and label those who were to be excluded from it as enemies. Propaganda was essential in promoting such myths.

encyclopedia.ushmm.org

During Rachel Maddow's most recent show she showed a clip of Sid Rosenberg at trump's rally berating immigrants followed by a recording of part of a speech from the 1939 Nazi rally. The language was almost identical.

Did you cry?

 

[Tyrion234]

The GOP under Trump has become the party of bigots, crackpots and grifters.

Define “grifter” would that be the poor class living off other peoples hard work? Think you have your classes mixed up you fucking worthless bum

 

[alang1216]

Pt 1: kudos to you for at least trying to step up.

Thanks.

Pt 2: your contention is false. MAGA absolutely does NOT make such commentary about “immigrants.” Why can’t you guys ever admit the distinction between “immigrants” and “illegal immigrants?”

Does that include legal immigrants from 'shithole' countries?

Also, isn’t it the goal of communism, here, to subvert America?

There are a miniscule number of communists in the US. The last ones I met were on a bus ride in 1972.

 

[BackAgain]

Thanks.


Does that include legal immigrants from 'shithole' countries?

Again: you must distinguish between legal immigration and illegal immigration.

Try again. (By the way, like it or not, there are indeed some truly “shithole” countries on our planet.)

There are a miniscule number of communists in the US. The last ones I met were on a bus ride in 1972.

Baseless report. But also nothing of consequence anyway.

 

[el midgetron]

That thing deserves a gold medal. And it’s true! Today JEWS are safer at a “Nazi” rally than they are on a liberal college campus, or a left-wing political protest.

 

[IDIOCRACY]

You first. Why do think your orange Fuhrer’s usual hate filled rant is somehow different from a typical Hitler rant?

Please keep your answers concise. Brevity helps. Nobody wants to read a wall o’ words. Go

Geezuz, what a copout.

Ever notice leftists often sport avatars that conflict with their character?

 

[IDIOCRACY]

This question goes to our liberals and Democrats.

Please keep your answers concise. Brevity helps. Nobody wants to read a wall o’ words.

Question: for all the many complaints and claims and accusations I’ve read about Trump’s rally at MSG to the effect that it was somehow akin to a Hitler rally from Nazi Germany, I’d like to know the actual basis for that comparison.

I saw several such complaints and warnings even before the rally. But, factually, what (if anything) supports it?

Speaking as the first Democrat to answer truthfully, snozberries taste like snozzberries. A liberal thought is was cute to interject penis into a children's story, because we democrats are just creative that way.

 

[Magnus]

Geezuz, what a copout.

Ever notice leftists often sport avatars that conflict with their character?

Lucky us, that you identified yourself correctly.

But it good to see all the retards come out in support of the other retard. I must have really left a mark. LOL

 

[alang1216]

Again: you must distinguish between legal immigration and illegal immigration.

Tell that to Trump

Trump is planning a crackdown on legal immigration, too​

I actually agree with Trump on some immigration issues like ending chain migration and getting tougher on illegal immigration but his fear mongering and dehumanization of a group is very Nazi-like.

Baseless report. But also nothing of consequence anyway.

Nothing of consequence until Trump sends the military after us Libs as 'enemies within'. Again, very Nazi-like.

 

[BackAgain]

Tell that to Trump

Trump is planning a crackdown on legal immigration, too​

I actually agree with Trump on some immigration issues like ending chain migration and getting tougher on illegal immigration but his fear mongering and dehumanization of a group is very Nazi-like.


Nothing of consequence until Trump sends the military after us Libs as 'enemies within'. Again, very Nazi-like.

No. We have immigration laws. We used to flat out ban Chinese, for example. Eventually, that changed. Now we have an overly complex maze and web of laws compounded by rules and regulations which make it all but impossible to decipher.

But rules for legal immigration is not Nazi like. That’s a completely baseless ignorant claim. All nations impose restrictions on who may enter and/or remain within their borders.

As I’m sure you know, it’s all part and parcel of “sovereignty.”

So if a President wants to lower the number of legal aliens, he or she can go to Congress and have the Immigration and Naturalization law changed.

As to your parting comment, as I understand him, he believes that he might be able to invoke a part of the alien and Sedition laws to authorize military assistance in addressing the problem we have with such massive numbers of illegals

And if you and your fellow libs behave lawfully, there won’t ever be a chance of using military force against any of you. See, posse comitatus .

 

[konradv]

But rules for legal immigration is not Nazi like. That’s a completely baseless ignorant claim. All nations impose restrictions on who may enter and/or remain within their borders.

How do we know the rules won’t e Nazi-like? Trump already shot down a bipartisan deal. I don’t think we should taking that kind of chance.

#VOTEHARRIS

 

[BackAgain]

How do we know the rules won’t e Nazi-like?

WTF? How do we know that you’re not a Nazi? Ask smarter questions, you dingbat.

Trump already shot down a bipartisan deal. I don’t think we should taking that kind of chance.

He shot down nothing. He opposed that fake bill. And the representative shot it down. Rightfully so.

Also, clearly, you don’t think at all.

#VOTEHARRIS

#VoteAgainstHarris

 

[konradv]

WTF? How do we know that you’re not a Nazi? Ask smarter questions, you dingbat.

He shot down nothing. He opposed that fake bill. And the representative shot it down. Rightfully so.

Also, clearly, you don’t think at all.

#MAGALIES