That crazy unreliable liar Nornan Finkelstein - no wonder neo nazis love to quote him / his twisted ideas

Since you expressed your opinion that there was no starvation in Gaza and no Israeli starvation policy, I've posted at least 5 credible sources that refute both claims not including the one below (1) that says, essentially, the same things that you deny.

Therefore, I'm not sure how to proceed in the face of your unwillingness to see what is so clear to a vast majority of Americans and a surprisingly large number of Holocaust survivors (2).

I believe that I already mentioned that denying blatant Zionist genocide, collective punishment, deliberate infliction of deaths by starvation and relentless expansionism (3) seems as absurd as claiming that all Israeli deaths on 7 October, 2023 were from IDF fire with not one death caused by Hamas.

From my point of view, your denial of genocide, deliberate infliction of starvation, collective punishment etc with nothing to support your opinion is just as outrageous as a claim that Hamas killed no one on 7 October, 2023.

This is the sort of dead end point at which name calling usually begins and things go downhill from there.

However, because I much prefer civil and informative exchanges, I recommend that we either address the topic of this thread or discuss another topic.

Your thoughts?







(1). "Israel/OPT: Two months of cruel and inhumane siege are further evidence of Israel’s genocidal intent in Gaza "​


EXCERPT "By blocking the entry of supplies critical for the survival of the population, Israel continues its policy of deliberately imposing conditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza calculated to bring about their physical destruction; this constitutes an act of genocide.

Harrowing new testimonies gathered by Amnesty International throughout April reveal the catastrophic human cost of Israel’s two-month long total siege, where starvation and denial of life-saving essentials are being used as weapons of war in flagrant violation of international law.

Israel’s refusal to allow aid into Gaza also flouts repeated ICJ orders to ensure Palestinians have access to sufficient humanitarian assistance and basic services. " CONTINUED


(2). U.S. Holocaust Museum Supporters Project "Stop The Genocide in Gaza'"

EXCERPT "Helping with the projection was Marianne Ehrlich Ross, a Holocaust survivor, and long time supporter of the Museum, who spoke about her experience being expelled from Vienna, then Prague, and then being stranded in England during the war. She is shocked that Israel, with US support, is engaging in ethnic cleansing of Palestinians, and asked the Museum to not be silent on the present war on the Palestinian people - or anyone else.

"Explaining the pictures of destruction and suffering in Gaza, Jonathan Kuttab, Director of Friends of Sabeel North America, spoke about his experience of Palestinians suffering from expulsion, occupation and murder on a vast scale. He spoke to the horrors of the Holocaust in Europe and said that “it is tragic that the Jewish state is perpetrating ethnic cleansing, war crimes and genocide.” Kuttab, a renowned International human rights lawyer, said “the Genocide Convention is clearly being openly violated by Israel and the US." CONTINUED


(3). “Officials: Israel plans to seize Gaza”

“Authorities approve operation to displace Palestinians to south”



EXCERPT “Israel approved plans Monday to seize the Gaza Strip and to stay in the Palestinian territory for an unspecified amount of time, two Israeli officials said, a move that, if implemented, would vastly expand Israel's operations there and likely draw fierce international opposition.

The new plan, which was approved in an early morning vote by Israeli Cabinet ministers, also calls for hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to move to Gaza's south. That would likely amount to their forcible displacement and exacerbate an already dire humanitarian crisis.” CONTINUED


015D0FD6-4B41-4843-8EDC-38707D841403.webp
 
Friday, May 25, 1956.
THE NATIONAL JEWISH POST.

Tells Rev. Elson Israel Had To Be Just Like Thirteen Colonies..

The so-called Arab “refugees” is not the real issue either, although it is being exploited politically. They are not refugees by our definition, people driven from their homes. On the contrary, they left voluntarily at the command of their own leaders, including the former Grand Mufti Haj Amin Al Husseini and the Arab commander Fawzi al Kaukji, who threatened with reprisals any who refused to leave.
The reason given by the Arab high executive was that upon the withdrawal of the British, the combined Arab armies would drive the Jews into the sea and then return triumphantly. The Jewish authorities begged them to stay and offered them protection and security. This was reported in the London Economist of Oct. 2, 1948. I am sure you can find similar data in the N. Y. Times of the same period.

The Governor of Maryland obtained the same information from eye-witnesses. I, too, have met an official eyewitness who had participated in the battle of Haifa.

About seven years ago I suggested to an Israeli official initial payments for abandoned properties and the balance when peace is established. He was anxious to proceed, but soon realized complications of international law, because compensation is interrelated with reparations and are contingent upon peace settlement which the Arabs refuse.

Majority population is not identical with original inhabitants. Over 80 per cent of Palestine’s Arabs had infiltrated from foreign countries, mostly in quest for better living standards by working for Jews. This is based upon a study by Cassidy of the N. Y. Herald Tribune, published in Middle East Affairs magazine 1946-47.
Using the interview method, he indicated that some 81 per rent of Palestine’s Arabs (including their forebears) had immigrated from Egypt-Sudan, Bosnia-Her-zegovina. Syria, Hauran, etc. The Bible and post-Biblical Jewish history are ample evidence as to the original inhabitants on both sides of the Jordan. Jewish legal residence and historical connections have been continuous.


____


Debunking the claim that “Palestinians” are the indigenous people of Israel.
JPost. May 12, 2015.

___


Hamas Minister: "Half of the Palestinians Are Egyptians and the Other Half Are Saudis"

Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad told Egypt's Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012: "Every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties." "Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in Gaza are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis." "Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians. We are Arabs. We are Muslims. We are a part of you."
Source: MEMRI TV

____

Lissak, R. S. (2021). When and How the Arabs and Muslims Immigrated to the Land of Israel—Period of British Rule, 1918–1948: Volume Two. United Kingdom: Xlibris US.

 
Speaking of hospitals ...

_____

"PALESTINIAN" ARAB ISLAMIC GENOCIDAL REGIME KILLINGS ITS PEOPLE SO PALLYWEID CAN BE BOOSTED

b40d134a662104d3db9eefd782bea9f99835b21f.jpg

Fascista Fancesca Albanese
download - 2025-05-13T193514.784.webp
download - 2025-05-13T194010.750.webp
images - 2025-05-13T194103.588.webp
images - 2025-05-13T194154.427.webp
download - 2025-05-13T193454.122.webp


Biden: Palestinians being used as 'human shields'.
The Washington Post
Oct 14, 2023 — President Biden accused Hamas of using Palestinian civilians as "human shields" at the Human Rights Campaign National Dinner on Oct. 14.


____


Florida Republican urges defunding UN Human Rights Council until UN condemns Hamas.
The bill already has several cosponsors, including Florida Democrat Rep Jared Moskowitz.
Houston Keene By Houston Keene , Thomas Phippen. Fox News, October 31, 2023.
..."The United States should not fund the UN Human Rights Council until it stops targeting our closest ally," Luna said. "The UN must unequivocally condemn Hamas’s utter disregard for human life and the terror they are inflicting on Israelis and the innocent Palestinians they use as human shields."

___


U.S. Says Hamas Operates Out of Gaza Hospitals, Endorsing Israel’s Allegations
John Kirby, a spokesman for the National Security Council, said that intelligence from U.S.-generated sources supported Israel’s claim that Hamas has tunnels under Al-Shifa and other hospitals.
By Michael D. Shear.
reporting from Washington.
NY Times. Nov. 14, 2023

____


Hamas use of the civilian population as human shields and Gaza’s civilian facilities for terrorism.
Published: 18/11/2023.

____


Hamas are cruelly turning hospitals into targets.
The Telegraph.

16 nov 2023 — The international community should direct its outrage at the terrorists systematically using civilians as human shields.


Hamas cannot be allowed to use hospitals as fortresses.
The Telegraph.
Nov 14, 2023— Hamas's tactic of placing itself in and around hospitals in Gaza is despicable. We cannot encourage it by allowing this evil organisation .

____

The Pinsker Centre.
REPORT: Hamas and Human Shields
23 Nov, 2023.
Since the outbreak of the war between Israel and Hamas after the October 7th Massacres, Hamas has consistently used tactics that put unarmed civilians at risk of death or injury. Hamas has a long history of using the people of Gaza as human shields to protect their terrorist leaders from Israeli strikes, and even operates its command center under the Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City.

How has Hamas used civilians to protect its leaders?
Since Hamas took power in the Gaza Strip in 2007 after a bloody war with Fatah, the terrorist organization has utilized human shield tactics such as putting entrances to terror tunnels in residential buildings, hiding rockets to fire indiscriminately at Israeli civilians in schools, hospitals, and mosques, and even publicly calling on its own civilians to climb onto the roofs of Hamas officials’ homes to ward off Israeli strikes.

As the current war expands in the Gaza Strip, Hamas has not strayed away from its traditional tactics. In one instance, it launched a barrage of rockets from a diplomatic building, which was just across the street from a UN-run school for Gaza children. The IDF has revealed an increasing and troubling use of UN facilities for its war against Israel– although the UN has condemned Hamas’s use of the tactic since the 2012 war, the terror group has continued using UN schools, offices, and hospitals to stash and launch rockets at Israeli civilians.

The Gazan people are victims of this war, but not from Israeli aggression. Hamas repeatedly puts the people of Gaza in the line of fire to protect its own terrorists, and the intricate tunnel network under Gaza reflects that. While the terrorists get to hide in bunkers from bombardment, the Gazans are indefensibly shuttled above command centers to deter Israeli airstrikes and to create mass casualty events. Ultimately, Hamas has weaponized the innocent people of Gaza and turned them into expendable pawns to advance terrorism.

Has Hamas broken international law by using human shields?
International humanitarian law is unequivocally against the use of human shields, and Hamas’s actions even invalidate protective status that is normally given to civilian locations in war. The 4th Hague Convention, one of the tenets of Treaty Law on the laws of armed conflict, clearly states that protected status should be granted to cultural, religious, medical, and other civilian sites, but it also clearly states that such protection is only given “provided they are not being used at the time for military purposes.” Moreover, the Geneva Conventions also state similar directives: civilian, cultural, and medical facilities are protected as long as they are not used “to commit, outside their humanitarian duties, acts harmful to the enemy.” Although certainly not the fault of Gazan civilians, many of their crucial humanitarian sites are now weaponized by Hamas as military targets. Putting rockets in hospitals, mosques, and schools only creates unnecessary hurt for the people of Gaza, but this is due to the actions of Hamas.

Sources and further reading:

“Exposed: Hamas’s hospital hideouts– a grave abuse of Gaza’s medical lifelines,” The Jerusalem Post, 8 November 2023, [Exposed: Hamas's hospital hideouts - a grave abuse of Gaza's medical lifelines - editorial].

“Hamas’ use of human shields in Gaza,” NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence, 6 June 2019, [https://stratcomcoe.org/cuploads/pfiles/hamas_human_shields.pdf].

Pamela Falk, “Israel says these photos show how Hamas places weapons in and near U.N. facilities in Gaza, including schools,” CBS News, 8 November 2023, [Israel says these photos show how Hamas places weapons in and near U.N. facilities in Gaza, including schools].

Pamela Falk, “Israel says these photos show how Hamas places weapons in and near U.N. facilities in Gaza, including schools”

“Palestinian Lives Matter, Except to Hamas,” The Wall Street Journal, 16 October 2023, [https://www.wsj.com/articles/israel-hamas-gaza-civilians-united-nations-1222797b].

Convention (IV) respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and its annex: Regulations concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land. Sec. 2, Chap. 1, Art. 21, 27. The Hague, 18 October 1907.

Convention (IV) relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War. Part II. Geneva, 12 August 1949, pp. 174-178.

____

What Can We Possibly Say to the Children of Gaza?
By Nicholas Kristof. NY Times. Feb 3, 2024 — Any government would have struck back, and Hamas maximized the suffering of civilians by using them as human shields...

____




We've got to stop believing Hamas' lies about civilian ...

The Telegraph.
19 Feb 2024 — War is hell. But the IDF are killing 'astonishingly' few civilians, say the experts.

___


Martyrs Inc. in Rafah as Hamas gets just what it wants: civilian deaths.
By Mark Toth and Jonathan Sweet.
NY Post. May 28, 2024.

____


UN: Funding, word count limits kept Hamas human shields off blacklist.
António Guterres put the Israeli security forces on the annual "list of shame."
Mike Wagenheim.

(June 16, 2024 / JNS)
The United Nations’ point person on a report blacklisting Israeli forces’ treatment of Palestinian children says the decision to minimize Hamas’s use of human shields is partially a result of low funding and allowable word counts.

___


Gaza Chief’s Brutal Calculation: Civilian Bloodshed Will Help Hamas.
Yahya Sinwar’s correspondence with compatriots and mediators shows he is confident that Hamas can outlast Israel
By Summer Said and Rory Jones. WSJ.
June 10, 2024.

___


Max Boot:
I’ve read student protesters’ manifestos. This is ugly stuff. Clueless, too.
Cosplaying pro-Palestinian activists on campuses are repeating the mistakes of the 1960s.

Washington Post. May 6, 2024.

As a journalist for the Daily Californian, the university’s independent, student-run newspaper, I covered a lot of protests for causes as varied as divesting from South Africa, ending U.S. proxy wars in Central America, getting the ROTC off campus and staying out of the 1991 Gulf War (“no blood for oil”). But underlying all of the transitory passions of the day, I detected a powerful nostalgia for the 1960s — that heady era when mere students could imagine they were heroic figures in the vanguard of historical change. It often felt as if the students of my generation were simply historical reenactors of past glories for whom the act of protest was more important than the causes for which they protested.

... today’s pro-Palestinian protesters are their own worst enemies; they have even been reenacting some of the excesses of the past, such as briefly occupying Columbia’s Hamilton Hall last week before police cleared them out. The students are not succeeding in forcing universities to divest from Israel, and even if they were, it wouldn’t have much impact on Israel’s economy.

Instead, the demonstrations are making an in-kind contribution to former president Donald Trump’s campaign by fostering an erroneous impression that the country is out of control and requires his authoritarian rule to restore “law and order.” The damage will only grow if demonstrators disrupt this year’s Democratic National Convention in Chicago in August as they did the one there in 1968...

The protesters are usually described as being opposed to the war in Gaza and in favor of Palestinian rights. In truth, the groups organizing these protests are opposed to the very existence of what they call the “Zionist project.” As a manifesto from Columbia University Apartheid Divest, endorsed by 94 student groups, states: “The brutal onslaught over the last month is but another chapter in over 75 years of violence, dispossession, and ethnic cleansing against the Palestinian people.” No mention, naturally, of all the violence perpetrated against Israel, including the horrifying Hamas attack on Oct. 7 and the Iranian drone and missile strike on April 13.

The manifesto goes on to endorse “the Right of Return” for Palestinian refugees who have fled Israel since its creation in 1948. Allowing 7 million Palestinians — most of them the descendants of refugees — to move to Israel (with its 7 million Jewish and 2 million Arab residents) would be a death knell for Israel as a Jewish state. The protesters’ slogan “from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” is a call not for a two-state solution but for a single Palestinian state — and a mass exodus of Jews.

Note how one-sided all of this is: While denouncing alleged Israeli atrocities[sic], the manifesto has not one word of censure for Hamas or its brutal tactics, which include seizing hostages and perpetrating sexual violence, in addition to committing wholesale murder. Indeed, even though the protesters claim to care about Palestinian lives, they do not denounce Hamas for stealing international aid to build its tunnels and missiles or for using civilians as human shields. They call for Israel to stop fighting but not for Hamas to release its hostages or surrender.

The protesters’ agenda does not end in the Middle East; indeed, the movement’s ideologues see Israel as merely an “imperial outpost in the Arab world,” even though Jews have lived in the area since antiquity.

___

Hamas tries to prevent civilians fleeing danger in northern Gaza.
As troops urge Gazans to leave, many remain fearing travel through areas under IDF control and after threats from Hamas that seeks to use them as human shields while forces hunt them down.

Einav Halabi. Ynet. Oct 10, 2024.

____


Hamas, Palestinian Authority trade blows over human shields, West Bank operations
Fatah said it wouldn't allow Hamas "to reproduce its activities in the West Bank" and that the terror group jeopardized the Palestinian people.
By Mathilda Heller. JPost. January 11, 2025.

____


Hamas’ rule in Gaza has been disastrous for both Arabs and Israelis.

Commentary.
By Ariel and Rena Cohen.
The Washington Times, January 28, 2025.

Hamas’ rule in Gaza has been disastrous for both Arabs and Israelis. Hamas will continue to be an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, a worldwide Islamist group intent on rebuilding a caliphate, an Islamic empire. These terrorists and their paymasters will not abandon jihad, a “holy war” to destroy the Jewish state, kill the Jews, and then turn against Europe and the United States.

Almost immediately after the ceasefire was announced, masked and uniform-clad terrorists emerged from Gaza’s tunnels, weapons in hand, reclaiming control of the strip. They have already killed six locals and shot a score more. They are poised to exploit the remaining hostages and the Gaza civilians as their human shields. They will return to seizing aid and selling it to the people at exorbitant prices while glorifying the bloodshed, torture, rape, violence and abductions of Oct. 7. 2023. They have already promised to repeat it...

___


Emirati Political Analyst: We Must Remove The Extremist Hamas From Power In Gaza...
MEMRI. April 21, 2025
Palestinians, United Arab Emirates | Special Dispatch No. 11935

In his March 22, 2025 column in the Saudi news portal Elaph, titled "Hamas and the Strategy of Collective Suicide," Emirati political analyst Salem Al-Ketbi accused Hamas of espousing an extremist ideology and of provoking Israel into an all-out war in Gaza despite being aware that it is the Gazan civilians who would pay the price. As part of its extremist outlook, he said, Hamas uses civilians as human shields, places its military facilities in dense population centers and in hospitals and schools, commandeers the humanitarian aid delivered to Gaza and uses the suffering of the Gazans to gain political leverage – all while its leaders live abroad in fancy hotels and villas.

____


The People of Gaza Are Human Shields for Hamas.
idf-soldier-with-palestinian-child-768x432.jpg

An IDF soldier escorts a Palestinian child to safety.

Hamas’s Human Shields: The Truth the World Ignores.
Sabine Srerk. Mar 8, 2025.
In a world where truth is a matter of perspective rather than fact, a strange and dangerous illusion takes hold. The world has seen terror before, but never has it been so skillfully disguised as victimhood. Hamas, a group known for its brutality, rules over Gaza with an iron grip—not as protectors of their people, but as their captors. They do not build schools to educate or hospitals to heal. Instead, they build tunnels, stretching for miles beneath the city.

But these tunnels are not for sheltering civilians from war; they are for smuggling weapons, for ambushes, for terror. Yet when war comes, the civilians have nowhere to run. Hamas makes sure of that. They fire rockets from schoolyards, knowing return fire will bring destruction. They store weapons in hospitals, ensuring that any military response leads to tragic images of wounded innocents. They turn their own people into shields, yet the world only sees the suffering—not those responsible for it.
And the world believes…

When Hamas hijacks aid trucks, stealing food meant for their own people, they blame Israel for the famine. When their tunnels remain empty of refugees but full of armed militants, they cry of Israeli cruelty. When their leaders live in luxury abroad while their people starve, they point the finger not at themselves, but at the Jews. And the world believes…

Journalists, afraid of reprisals, report only what Hamas allows them to see. Politicians, eager for approval, repeat the lies without question. Protesters in far-off cities, disconnected from reality, march in rage—against the very people fighting to defend themselves. And what about the hostages?

____


Trump Admin Eyes Fresh Hamas Sanctions Under 'Human Shield' Law That Biden Admin Ignored.
'The Treasury Department is proud to use every tool available to us' to target Iran-backed terrorists, spokesman says.

Adam Kredo. Washington Free Beacon
April 18, 2025.

____


Such a report’s appeal to the international community is unlikely to succeed so long as there is a strong current of opinion that questions the right of Israel to defend itself when attacked.
Rob Killick
— May 13, 2025
 

Attachments

  • download - 2025-05-13T193514.784.webp
    download - 2025-05-13T193514.784.webp
    10.1 KB · Views: 1
  • download - 2025-05-13T193505.359.webp
    download - 2025-05-13T193505.359.webp
    20.1 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:
Reaction by that same one: SP:

Hondo50/apolitical/yeh/dismantle this country/stevez/the user/Topeka/Todd down under /cyrus k/ice and fire

And many more..
 
The look of a Zionist dupe.
View attachment 1111029
Have you heard the latest act of nauseating sickness? Trump will meet the Al Qaeda /ISIS terrorist the self declared leader of Syria Julani in Saudi Arabia, he also says they will lift sanctions on Syria, so let me get this right, the US wage a proxy terror war on Syria for years by these head chopping maniacs, the same outfit that blew up the twin towers and beheaded several Western hostages and are at this moment murdering minorities in Syria including Christians, wonder what if anything the families of the twin tower victims will have to say? the public are so far gone probably nothing to say.
 
Speaking of hospitals ...

_____

"PALESTINIAN" ARAB ISLAMIC GENOCIDAL REGIME KILLINGS ITS PEOPLE SO PALLYWEID CAN BE BOOSTED

b40d134a662104d3db9eefd782bea9f99835b21f.jpg

Fascista Fancesca Albanese
View attachment 1111039View attachment 1111040View attachment 1111041View attachment 1111042View attachment 1111038

Biden: Palestinians being used as 'human shields'.
The Washington Post
Oct 14, 2023 — President Biden accused Hamas of using Palestinian civilians as "human shields" at the Human Rights Campaign National Dinner on Oct. 14.


____


Florida Republican urges defunding UN Human Rights Council until UN condemns Hamas.
The bill already has several cosponsors, including Florida Democrat Rep Jared Moskowitz.
Houston Keene By Houston Keene , Thomas Phippen. Fox News, October 31, 2023.
..."The United States should not fund the UN Human Rights Council until it stops targeting our closest ally," Luna said. "The UN must unequivocally condemn Hamas’s utter disregard for human life and the terror they are inflicting on Israelis and the innocent Palestinians they use as human shields."

___


U.S. Says Hamas Operates Out of Gaza Hospitals, Endorsing Israel’s Allegations
John Kirby, a spokesman for the National Security Council, said that intelligence from U.S.-generated sources supported Israel’s claim that Hamas has tunnels under Al-Shifa and other hospitals.
By Michael D. Shear.
reporting from Washington.
NY Times. Nov. 14, 2023

____


Hamas use of the civilian population as human shields and Gaza’s civilian facilities for terrorism.
Published: 18/11/2023.

____


Hamas are cruelly turning hospitals into targets.
The Telegraph.

16 nov 2023 — The international community should direct its outrage at the terrorists systematically using civilians as human shields.


Hamas cannot be allowed to use hospitals as fortresses.
The Telegraph.
Nov 14, 2023— Hamas's tactic of placing itself in and around hospitals in Gaza is despicable. We cannot encourage it by allowing this evil organisation .

____

The Pinsker Centre.
REPORT: Hamas and Human Shields
23 Nov, 2023.
Since the outbreak of the war between Israel and Hamas after the October 7th Massacres, Hamas has consistently used tactics that put unarmed civilians at risk of death or injury. Hamas has a long history of using the people of Gaza as human shields to protect their terrorist leaders from Israeli strikes, and even operates its command center under the Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City.

How has Hamas used civilians to protect its leaders?
Since Hamas took power in the Gaza Strip in 2007 after a bloody war with Fatah, the terrorist organization has utilized human shield tactics such as putting entrances to terror tunnels in residential buildings, hiding rockets to fire indiscriminately at Israeli civilians in schools, hospitals, and mosques, and even publicly calling on its own civilians to climb onto the roofs of Hamas officials’ homes to ward off Israeli strikes.

As the current war expands in the Gaza Strip, Hamas has not strayed away from its traditional tactics. In one instance, it launched a barrage of rockets from a diplomatic building, which was just across the street from a UN-run school for Gaza children. The IDF has revealed an increasing and troubling use of UN facilities for its war against Israel– although the UN has condemned Hamas’s use of the tactic since the 2012 war, the terror group has continued using UN schools, offices, and hospitals to stash and launch rockets at Israeli civilians.

The Gazan people are victims of this war, but not from Israeli aggression. Hamas repeatedly puts the people of Gaza in the line of fire to protect its own terrorists, and the intricate tunnel network under Gaza reflects that. While the terrorists get to hide in bunkers from bombardment, the Gazans are indefensibly shuttled above command centers to deter Israeli airstrikes and to create mass casualty events. Ultimately, Hamas has weaponized the innocent people of Gaza and turned them into expendable pawns to advance terrorism.

Has Hamas broken international law by using human shields?
International humanitarian law is unequivocally against the use of human shields, and Hamas’s actions even invalidate protective status that is normally given to civilian locations in war. The 4th Hague Convention, one of the tenets of Treaty Law on the laws of armed conflict, clearly states that protected status should be granted to cultural, religious, medical, and other civilian sites, but it also clearly states that such protection is only given “provided they are not being used at the time for military purposes.” Moreover, the Geneva Conventions also state similar directives: civilian, cultural, and medical facilities are protected as long as they are not used “to commit, outside their humanitarian duties, acts harmful to the enemy.” Although certainly not the fault of Gazan civilians, many of their crucial humanitarian sites are now weaponized by Hamas as military targets. Putting rockets in hospitals, mosques, and schools only creates unnecessary hurt for the people of Gaza, but this is due to the actions of Hamas.

Sources and further reading:

“Exposed: Hamas’s hospital hideouts– a grave abuse of Gaza’s medical lifelines,” The Jerusalem Post, 8 November 2023, [Exposed: Hamas's hospital hideouts - a grave abuse of Gaza's medical lifelines - editorial].

“Hamas’ use of human shields in Gaza,” NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence, 6 June 2019, [https://stratcomcoe.org/cuploads/pfiles/hamas_human_shields.pdf].

Pamela Falk, “Israel says these photos show how Hamas places weapons in and near U.N. facilities in Gaza, including schools,” CBS News, 8 November 2023, [Israel says these photos show how Hamas places weapons in and near U.N. facilities in Gaza, including schools].

Pamela Falk, “Israel says these photos show how Hamas places weapons in and near U.N. facilities in Gaza, including schools”

“Palestinian Lives Matter, Except to Hamas,” The Wall Street Journal, 16 October 2023, [https://www.wsj.com/articles/israel-hamas-gaza-civilians-united-nations-1222797b].

Convention (IV) respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and its annex: Regulations concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land. Sec. 2, Chap. 1, Art. 21, 27. The Hague, 18 October 1907.

Convention (IV) relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War. Part II. Geneva, 12 August 1949, pp. 174-178.

____

What Can We Possibly Say to the Children of Gaza?
By Nicholas Kristof. NY Times. Feb 3, 2024 — Any government would have struck back, and Hamas maximized the suffering of civilians by using them as human shields...

____




We've got to stop believing Hamas' lies about civilian ...

The Telegraph.
19 Feb 2024 — War is hell. But the IDF are killing 'astonishingly' few civilians, say the experts.

___


Martyrs Inc. in Rafah as Hamas gets just what it wants: civilian deaths.
By Mark Toth and Jonathan Sweet.
NY Post. May 28, 2024.

____


UN: Funding, word count limits kept Hamas human shields off blacklist.
António Guterres put the Israeli security forces on the annual "list of shame."
Mike Wagenheim.

(June 16, 2024 / JNS)
The United Nations’ point person on a report blacklisting Israeli forces’ treatment of Palestinian children says the decision to minimize Hamas’s use of human shields is partially a result of low funding and allowable word counts.

___


Gaza Chief’s Brutal Calculation: Civilian Bloodshed Will Help Hamas.
Yahya Sinwar’s correspondence with compatriots and mediators shows he is confident that Hamas can outlast Israel
By Summer Said and Rory Jones. WSJ.
June 10, 2024.

___


Max Boot:
I’ve read student protesters’ manifestos. This is ugly stuff. Clueless, too.
Cosplaying pro-Palestinian activists on campuses are repeating the mistakes of the 1960s.

Washington Post. May 6, 2024.

As a journalist for the Daily Californian, the university’s independent, student-run newspaper, I covered a lot of protests for causes as varied as divesting from South Africa, ending U.S. proxy wars in Central America, getting the ROTC off campus and staying out of the 1991 Gulf War (“no blood for oil”). But underlying all of the transitory passions of the day, I detected a powerful nostalgia for the 1960s — that heady era when mere students could imagine they were heroic figures in the vanguard of historical change. It often felt as if the students of my generation were simply historical reenactors of past glories for whom the act of protest was more important than the causes for which they protested.

... today’s pro-Palestinian protesters are their own worst enemies; they have even been reenacting some of the excesses of the past, such as briefly occupying Columbia’s Hamilton Hall last week before police cleared them out. The students are not succeeding in forcing universities to divest from Israel, and even if they were, it wouldn’t have much impact on Israel’s economy.

Instead, the demonstrations are making an in-kind contribution to former president Donald Trump’s campaign by fostering an erroneous impression that the country is out of control and requires his authoritarian rule to restore “law and order.” The damage will only grow if demonstrators disrupt this year’s Democratic National Convention in Chicago in August as they did the one there in 1968...

The protesters are usually described as being opposed to the war in Gaza and in favor of Palestinian rights. In truth, the groups organizing these protests are opposed to the very existence of what they call the “Zionist project.” As a manifesto from Columbia University Apartheid Divest, endorsed by 94 student groups, states: “The brutal onslaught over the last month is but another chapter in over 75 years of violence, dispossession, and ethnic cleansing against the Palestinian people.” No mention, naturally, of all the violence perpetrated against Israel, including the horrifying Hamas attack on Oct. 7 and the Iranian drone and missile strike on April 13.

The manifesto goes on to endorse “the Right of Return” for Palestinian refugees who have fled Israel since its creation in 1948. Allowing 7 million Palestinians — most of them the descendants of refugees — to move to Israel (with its 7 million Jewish and 2 million Arab residents) would be a death knell for Israel as a Jewish state. The protesters’ slogan “from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” is a call not for a two-state solution but for a single Palestinian state — and a mass exodus of Jews.

Note how one-sided all of this is: While denouncing alleged Israeli atrocities[sic], the manifesto has not one word of censure for Hamas or its brutal tactics, which include seizing hostages and perpetrating sexual violence, in addition to committing wholesale murder. Indeed, even though the protesters claim to care about Palestinian lives, they do not denounce Hamas for stealing international aid to build its tunnels and missiles or for using civilians as human shields. They call for Israel to stop fighting but not for Hamas to release its hostages or surrender.

The protesters’ agenda does not end in the Middle East; indeed, the movement’s ideologues see Israel as merely an “imperial outpost in the Arab world,” even though Jews have lived in the area since antiquity.

___

Hamas tries to prevent civilians fleeing danger in northern Gaza.
As troops urge Gazans to leave, many remain fearing travel through areas under IDF control and after threats from Hamas that seeks to use them as human shields while forces hunt them down.

Einav Halabi. Ynet. Oct 10, 2024.

____


Hamas, Palestinian Authority trade blows over human shields, West Bank operations
Fatah said it wouldn't allow Hamas "to reproduce its activities in the West Bank" and that the terror group jeopardized the Palestinian people.
By Mathilda Heller. JPost. January 11, 2025.

____


Hamas’ rule in Gaza has been disastrous for both Arabs and Israelis.

Commentary.
By Ariel and Rena Cohen.
The Washington Times, January 28, 2025.

Hamas’ rule in Gaza has been disastrous for both Arabs and Israelis. Hamas will continue to be an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, a worldwide Islamist group intent on rebuilding a caliphate, an Islamic empire. These terrorists and their paymasters will not abandon jihad, a “holy war” to destroy the Jewish state, kill the Jews, and then turn against Europe and the United States.

Almost immediately after the ceasefire was announced, masked and uniform-clad terrorists emerged from Gaza’s tunnels, weapons in hand, reclaiming control of the strip. They have already killed six locals and shot a score more. They are poised to exploit the remaining hostages and the Gaza civilians as their human shields. They will return to seizing aid and selling it to the people at exorbitant prices while glorifying the bloodshed, torture, rape, violence and abductions of Oct. 7. 2023. They have already promised to repeat it...

___


Emirati Political Analyst: We Must Remove The Extremist Hamas From Power In Gaza...
MEMRI. April 21, 2025
Palestinians, United Arab Emirates | Special Dispatch No. 11935

In his March 22, 2025 column in the Saudi news portal Elaph, titled "Hamas and the Strategy of Collective Suicide," Emirati political analyst Salem Al-Ketbi accused Hamas of espousing an extremist ideology and of provoking Israel into an all-out war in Gaza despite being aware that it is the Gazan civilians who would pay the price. As part of its extremist outlook, he said, Hamas uses civilians as human shields, places its military facilities in dense population centers and in hospitals and schools, commandeers the humanitarian aid delivered to Gaza and uses the suffering of the Gazans to gain political leverage – all while its leaders live abroad in fancy hotels and villas.

____


The People of Gaza Are Human Shields for Hamas.
idf-soldier-with-palestinian-child-768x432.jpg

An IDF soldier escorts a Palestinian child to safety.

Hamas’s Human Shields: The Truth the World Ignores.
Sabine Srerk. Mar 8, 2025.
In a world where truth is a matter of perspective rather than fact, a strange and dangerous illusion takes hold. The world has seen terror before, but never has it been so skillfully disguised as victimhood. Hamas, a group known for its brutality, rules over Gaza with an iron grip—not as protectors of their people, but as their captors. They do not build schools to educate or hospitals to heal. Instead, they build tunnels, stretching for miles beneath the city.

But these tunnels are not for sheltering civilians from war; they are for smuggling weapons, for ambushes, for terror. Yet when war comes, the civilians have nowhere to run. Hamas makes sure of that. They fire rockets from schoolyards, knowing return fire will bring destruction. They store weapons in hospitals, ensuring that any military response leads to tragic images of wounded innocents. They turn their own people into shields, yet the world only sees the suffering—not those responsible for it.
And the world believes…

When Hamas hijacks aid trucks, stealing food meant for their own people, they blame Israel for the famine. When their tunnels remain empty of refugees but full of armed militants, they cry of Israeli cruelty. When their leaders live in luxury abroad while their people starve, they point the finger not at themselves, but at the Jews. And the world believes…

Journalists, afraid of reprisals, report only what Hamas allows them to see. Politicians, eager for approval, repeat the lies without question. Protesters in far-off cities, disconnected from reality, march in rage—against the very people fighting to defend themselves. And what about the hostages?

____


Trump Admin Eyes Fresh Hamas Sanctions Under 'Human Shield' Law That Biden Admin Ignored.
'The Treasury Department is proud to use every tool available to us' to target Iran-backed terrorists, spokesman says.

Adam Kredo. Washington Free Beacon
April 18, 2025.

____


Such a report’s appeal to the international community is unlikely to succeed so long as there is a strong current of opinion that questions the right of Israel to defend itself when attacked.
Rob Killick
— May 13, 2025

Stop spamming the board with ridiculously long posts no one reads, including your fellow genocide supporters.
 
Have you heard the latest act of nauseating sickness? Trump will meet the Al Qaeda /ISIS terrorist the self declared leader of Syria Julani in Saudi Arabia, he also says they will lift sanctions on Syria, so let me get this right, the US wage a proxy terror war on Syria for years by these head chopping maniacs, the same outfit that blew up the twin towers and beheaded several Western hostages and are at this moment murdering minorities in Syria including Christians, wonder what if anything the families of the twin tower victims will have to say? the public are so far gone probably nothing to say.
Yeah it’s disgusting, but typical. The US has supported numerous terrorist groups in the past. You’d think all Americans would demand this shit stop.
 
How can anyone not believe that children are starving in Gaza after that was a declared objective by Israeli government officials?

I sincerely believe that most of the people who are attempting to obfuscate such a sadistic and soulless genocide will either be too embarrassed to admit that they supported the Gaza genocide or will deny their complicity.

The level of hysterical and racist hatred against all Muslims is pathological and rarely heard outside of secure facilities.
You ignorant, illiterate bigots constantly repeat the same bullshit and lies as if at some point it will become true.

The so called Palestinians and their leadership are 100% to blame for what is occurring in Gaza today. Period end of story.
 
Most of the so called “children” are brainwashed youth ge 14 to 18 groomed from an early age to become one of their terrorist animals. They sent them to the from lines or situations where the likelihood of them getting killed is high. Then they can call them “children” and have Pallywood media do the rest. Not a surprise considering Palestinians have used their own women and “children” as human shields for many decades.
 
Yeah it’s disgusting, but typical. The US has supported numerous terrorist groups in the past. You’d think all Americans would demand this shit stop.
This is a new low, that clown Lammy gave them £50million a few weeks ago, the US are the biggest sponsors of Global terrorism than anyone and they have the brass balls to lecture others for resisting their terrorism, the Al Qaeda chief head chopper has also been invited for tea and crumpets at number ten he won't be able to wash the blood off his Gucci shoes the Western politicians are morally bankrupt scumbags.
 
Most of the so called “children” are brainwashed youth ge 14 to 18 groomed from an early age to become one of their terrorist animals. They sent them to the from lines or situations where the likelihood of them getting killed is high. Then they can call them “children” and have Pallywood media do the rest. Not a surprise considering Palestinians have used their own women and “children” as human shields for many decades.
Give it a rest Nazi boy.
 
This is a new low, that clown Lammy gave them £50million a few weeks ago, the US are the biggest sponsors of Global terrorism than anyone and they have the brass balls to lecture others for resisting their terrorism, the Al Qaeda chief head chopper has also been invited for tea and crumpets at number ten he won't be able to wash the blood off his Gucci shoes the Western politicians are morally bankrupt scumbags.
It does boggle the mind.
 
Yeah it’s disgusting, but typical. The US has supported numerous terrorist groups in the past. You’d think all Americans would demand this shit stop.
Many of the herd have been lobotomized, even after the US Diplomat Stevens was raped and beaten to death by an Islamist mob they still didn't wake up.
It does boggle the mind.
On the BBC news today they called Julani the Al Qaeda /ISIS deputy head as the new leader of Syria, the BBC never stopped attacking the secular Government of Assad where Christians and other minorities were safe in Syria, yet they call the head chopper in chief as the new leader with a straight face, the overthrow of Syria has taken one Country who resisted Israel out of the picture, that was probably the main reason for the terror war on Syria.
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom