Seymour Flops
Diamond Member
From the WaPo, a list of Shutdowns from
I'll let you read it for yourself, if you don't mind giving them an email address to read it free.
Basically, it chronicles a long list of "shutdowns," in which nearly all of them ended in the Republicans caving in almost completely, often in exchange for unenforceable promises that were of course never kept. There were a few minor exceptions under Reagan, but nothing that addressed the issue of the expanding debt and growing deficits.
What McCarthy and his fellow borrow-and-spend Republicans did was to cut to the chase. They said to themselves 'Wellie, wellie, wellie, wellie, wellie, wellie, well. We can pretend to shut the government down, take the blame in the media for the non-existent suffering that will cause, and then cave, or we can just enlist a few Democrats to help us pass in spite of our GOP colleagues who have the bizarre idea that we are not hear to continue Pelosi's budgets."
It was they who "tore the bandaid off," by ending the budget fight before it began. I have some ideas for their motivation, but I'll let you comment on what I've said so far.
Maybe McCarthy did not anticipate such near-unanimous bandwagon jumping by the Dems in Congress. Not sure why. Why would they not gleefully vote for everything they wanted? I think McCarthy also anticipated at least enough Dems would support his Speakership to save him, as Matt Gaetz predicted. Kevin and Matt got that one wrong.
Expecting Democrats to feel gratitude for a political favor is like expecting a hungry lion to have sympathy for the warthog he eats. Expecting a Democrat to reciprocate a political favor is like expecting the lion to take some grubworms to the warthog's family.
It would have been in the Dems best interest to keep Kevin around, as far as I can see. He would have played Santa Claus until January of 2025. But they are cagey and slick, so I'm sure they have something in mind for the next Republican Speaker.
I'll let you read it for yourself, if you don't mind giving them an email address to read it free.
Basically, it chronicles a long list of "shutdowns," in which nearly all of them ended in the Republicans caving in almost completely, often in exchange for unenforceable promises that were of course never kept. There were a few minor exceptions under Reagan, but nothing that addressed the issue of the expanding debt and growing deficits.
What McCarthy and his fellow borrow-and-spend Republicans did was to cut to the chase. They said to themselves 'Wellie, wellie, wellie, wellie, wellie, wellie, well. We can pretend to shut the government down, take the blame in the media for the non-existent suffering that will cause, and then cave, or we can just enlist a few Democrats to help us pass in spite of our GOP colleagues who have the bizarre idea that we are not hear to continue Pelosi's budgets."
It was they who "tore the bandaid off," by ending the budget fight before it began. I have some ideas for their motivation, but I'll let you comment on what I've said so far.
Maybe McCarthy did not anticipate such near-unanimous bandwagon jumping by the Dems in Congress. Not sure why. Why would they not gleefully vote for everything they wanted? I think McCarthy also anticipated at least enough Dems would support his Speakership to save him, as Matt Gaetz predicted. Kevin and Matt got that one wrong.
Expecting Democrats to feel gratitude for a political favor is like expecting a hungry lion to have sympathy for the warthog he eats. Expecting a Democrat to reciprocate a political favor is like expecting the lion to take some grubworms to the warthog's family.
It would have been in the Dems best interest to keep Kevin around, as far as I can see. He would have played Santa Claus until January of 2025. But they are cagey and slick, so I'm sure they have something in mind for the next Republican Speaker.