Ray From Cleveland
Diamond Member
- Aug 16, 2015
- 97,215
- 37,439
- 2,290
That is true, because a "living wage" as you call it would have a domino effect causing inflation. Isn't it bad enough that we can't even compete with overseas products as it is without increasing our wages to make us less competitive? Isn't it bad enough that more and more industries are turning to automation to replace humans--even McDonald's franchise owners because of increased human wages?
Which is why I have a plan that wouldn't cause inflation.
-Base Federal tax for corporations at 30% of revenue.
-Raise minimum wage to $23.50/hr. Based on where minimum wage should be using 1970-2015 rise in food, shelter, and transportation.
-Eliminate all business subsidies (deductions/write-offs/write-downs) except for employee expenses which are deducted dollar-for-dollar on all city, state, and Federal taxes and fees with the Feds refunding city, State, and fees.
-Companies with 500 employees or less, employee expenses above the deduction are subsidized at 100% with funds usually give back to the States.
-Adjust Social Security and private/public retirement and pension payments using 1970-2015 price structure.
-Remove the FICA limit.
-Back down ALL costs, prices, fees, to January 1, 2009 levels and hold them for 10 years which will eliminate inflation.
-Recall ALL off-shore investments tax free, and disallow any further off-shore investments.
-Make inversion illegal.
My plan would reduce small business costs for employees and taxes to 30%. That's a 15%-30% drop.
My plan would put BILLIONS into the economy daily.
My plan would put the $100 trillion plus currently owned by corporate America back into the economy.
My plan would end all welfare.
My plan would significantly increase social security and pension payments.
My plan would hold prices for 10 years, thus eliminating inflation.
Your plan is not well thought out.
If $23,00 for minimum wage is good, then $43.00 per hour is even better. If $43.00 per hour for minimum wage is better, then $66.00 per hour must be the best.
How could this not cause inflation? If your plan were to go into effect, a $150,000 house today would cost over $300,000 within a few years. Your Big Mac combo would go from $5.50 per meal to $8.50 per meal. Your automobile would go from $27,000 to $40,000. How are you ahead?
All you would really accomplish is distancing ourselves further from our foreign competitors. Let me put it another way:
You have a company that makes widgets. You have starting positions at federal minimum wage. You have better paying positions at $10.00 per hour. You have skilled positions paying $18.00 per hour and the scale increases from there.
You are barely able to stay competitive with your foreign entities, but you still manage to provide some decent jobs and benefits.
Now you are forced to pay all employees $23.50 per hour. Would you still be able to compete with your competitors in China and India? Of course not. You would have to move out of the country or close shop.
Before you respond, remember that your employees that were making up to ten dollars over the old minimum wage would not be happy being back at minimum wage no matter what it was, so you would have to pay them even more. Then your skilled workers would have to make $34.00 per hour and up. Even your non-skilled workers would have to earn at least $26.00 per hour. How could you stay in business?
If $23,00 for minimum wage is good, then $43.00 per hour is even better. If $43.00 per hour for minimum wage is better, then $66.00 per hour must be the best.
If you can justify your wages based on where minimum wage should be using 1970-2015 rise in food, shelter, and transportation then you'd have an argument.
How could this not cause inflation? If your plan were to go into effect, a $150,000 house today would cost over $300,000 within a few years. Your Big Mac combo would go from $5.50 per meal to $8.50 per meal. Your automobile would go from $27,000 to $40,000. How are you ahead?
-Back down ALL costs, prices, fees, to January 1, 2009 levels and hold them for 10 years which will eliminate inflation. Inflation is caused by a rise in good and services, no rise, no inflation.
All you would really accomplish is distancing ourselves further from our foreign competitors. Let me put it another way:
You have a company that makes widgets. You have starting positions at federal minimum wage. You have better paying positions at $10.00 per hour. You have skilled positions paying $18.00 per hour and the scale increases from there.
You are barely able to stay competitive with your foreign entities, but you still manage to provide some decent jobs and benefits.
Now you are forced to pay all employees $23.50 per hour. Would you still be able to compete with your competitors in China and India? Of course not. You would have to move out of the country or close shop.
Before you respond, remember that your employees that were making up to ten dollars over the old minimum wage would not be happy being back at minimum wage no matter what it was, so you would have to pay them even more. Then your skilled workers would have to make $34.00 per hour and up. Even your non-skilled workers would have to earn at least $26.00 per hour. How could you stay in business?
Eliminate all business subsidies (deductions/write-offs/write-downs) except for employee expenses which are deducted dollar-for-dollar on all city, state, and Federal taxes and fees with the Feds refunding city, State, and fees.
-Companies with 500 employees or less, employee expenses above the deduction are subsidized at 100% with funds usually give back to the States.
My plan reduces all employee costs as well as State/local taxes and fees to 30% gross.
Example:
A company that grosses $100K will have a $30K federal tax. Typical employee expenses, State/local taxes and fees are $55k, the federal tax is off-set and a subsidy check for $25K is issued.
I don't have time to address your laundry list, but I will address a few:
You can't compare today to 1970. The 70's is when we began to inflate ourselves out of the world market. It was a bad strategy. It got worse as time went on and eventually chased jobs out of our country.
You can't freeze anything in a free country. It doesn't and can't work like that. The only possible way for that to happen is if we decided we wanted to live in a dictatorship. If you freeze the price of my widgets to $20.00 a piece, and it costs me $40.00 a piece to make them thanks to your new minimum wage, I go out of business just like everybody else in this country.
Subsides are tax write-offs which can't be eliminated. Government doesn't give money to anybody, government can only take less. Tax write-offs are not what you think they are. When you have a tax write-off, you only escape paying taxes on that money you spent which is only a few cents on the dollar. Many people think that when you write off one dollar, the government will remove that dollar from what you owe to them. No truth to that at all.