Should illegal aliens who commit crimes in America go to jail or be deported instead?

[Scoutster]

Well, they are already criminals by being illegal aliens.

And if you throw them in prison for a crime, you are just adding to your own problem now as now they are costing you incarceration expenses. Besides, they would probably like prison. It is probably better than where they came from.

So I would recommend a good beating to within an inch of their life first, then deported with a chip implanted in them with the understanding that if we catch them here again, the next beating will make the first one look like a love-fest.

The key to effective border control is to both make potential invaders fear getting caught and not wanting to come here in the first place.

I note that NO ONE tries to sneak into North Korea.

 

[candycorn]

We dont know what will happen in a Red state like Texas

That happens in Texas every day.

We can trust the republican governor and attorney general to do the right thing

If the "right thing" is to make an illegal alien spend time in prison and deliver justice to the party who was injured....that isn't happening in Texas. Illegals get a much better deal than those born in the United States.

The leaders there are pro criminal

Didn't you vote for a 34X convicted felon in November?

Yes you did.

Shut the fuck up you hypocritical piece of shit.

 

[candycorn]

Take your cheap personal insults and stick them up your ass

If you had a better argument you would not have start foods fights with others

I think people should serve time in prison if they commit crimes.

DO you have a better argument than that dick breath?

Nope.

Fuck off.

 

[candycorn]

Well, they are already criminals by being illegal aliens.

And if you throw them in prison for a crime, you are just adding to your own problem now as now they are costing you incarceration expenses. Besides, they would probably like prison. It is probably better than where they came from.

What about justice for the victims? That is the point of incarceration.

So I would recommend a good beating to within an inch of their life first, with pipes and glass bottles and socks filled with rolls of quarters, then deported with a chip implanted in them with the understanding that if we catch them here again, the next beating will make the first one look like a love-fest.

Yeah...see that is thoroughly un-American.... Nobody is surprised that you came up with it.

I note that NO ONE tries to sneak into North Korea.

And you apparently want us to be more like North Korea.

 

[Mac-7]

Well, they are already criminals by being illegal aliens.

And if you throw them in prison for a crime, you are just adding to your own problem now as now they are costing you incarceration expenses. Besides, they would probably like prison. It is probably better than where they came from.

So I would recommend a good beating to within an inch of their life first, with pipes and glass bottles and socks filled with rolls of quarters, then deported with a chip implanted in them with the understanding that if we catch them here again, the next beating will make the first one look like a love-fest.

The key to effective border control is to both make potential invaders fear getting caught and not wanting to come here in the first place.

I note that NO ONE tries to sneak into North Korea.

Tell the ACLU and the lib judges to go fuck themselves and build prisons in America that do not coddle criminals

I like what the prisons in El Salvador are doing to these monsters that libs care so much for

 

[Mac-7]

I think people should serve time in prison if they commit crimes.

DO you have a better argument than that dick breath?

Nope.

Fuck off.

The reason that debates with you always become personal insult food fights is because you have to drag the rest of us down to your level

Otherwise you lose every time

 

[candycorn]

The reason that debates with you always become personal insult food fights is because you have to drag the rest of us down to your level

Otherwise you lose every time

The reason you never win is because you have zero evidence to support your wacky accusations.

Take this thread for an example. You're worried that a Democratic President may pardon illegal aliens. The idea is clear evidence that you have shit for brains because you don't have a fucking clue....Presidents cannot pardon people for state crime. Very few crimes committed by illegal aliens (outside of their being here illegally) are federal crimes. There are less than 160,000 people in federal prison--about the size of Murfeesboro TN... This thread is baseless and you're worried about nothing.

 

[candycorn]

Great. That was MY answer. Do both. If convicted, make them pay their debt to society and after their debt has been paid, deport them.

Yeah...that seems like a no-brainer right? We've decided as a people--in every nation on earth pretty much--that if you commit a crime, you are incarcerated and that is supposedly delivering justice to the people you wronged. That is the case on all six continents.... Why in the world would you reward an illegal alien by deporting him and letting him get out of spending a very long time in a very small cell?

 

[Mac-7]

That happens in Texas every day.

If the "right thing" is to make an illegal alien spend time in prison and deliver justice to the party who was injured....that isn't happening in Texas. Illegals get a much better deal than those born in the United States.

Didn't you vote for a 34X convicted felon in November?

Yes you did.

Shut the fuck up you hypocritical piece of shit.

What is it that you think is happening every day in texas?

Try to be specific


If the "right thing" is to make an illegal alien spend time in prison and deliver justice to the party who was injured....that isn't happening in Texas. Illegals get a much better deal than those born in the United States.

Again, it is surreal to hear soft-on-crime liberals turn on a dime and suddenly want to punish criminals for thrir crimes

It took someone like trump to make libs change their strips this way

 

[candycorn]

~~~~~~
They would be welcomed in the max-security jails of El Salvador that would cost less than keeping them in U.S. jails.
We also have the ADX super-max prison..
Then again we might do what France is planning...by setting up a ADX type super-max in a desolate spot in Alaska.

​

https://www.cnn.com/2025/05/19/europe/france-prison-french-guyana-scli-intl

xxxxxxxxxx​

France revives Devil’s Island legacy with supermax Islamist jail

France’s plan to build a high-security prison in its South American colony of French Guiana has sparked anger among local leaders and residents.

www.newarab.com

We can always go back to executing the worse of the worst, like terrorists, and traitors.

Of course what you're ignoring is that someone has to carry out all of this cruelty you seem so eager to deliver.

So we open up a prison in Alaska--as you said. Who do you get to staff it? I'm sure that doesn't matter to you but those who work in prison are often working in the same harsh conditions that the prisoners face. This is one reason why Texas cannot keep corrections officers and have to offer bonuses to even recruit them.

 

[Polishprince]

What a deal. Commit a crime and your punishment is a free trip home where you can then freely return later.

You can only "freely return" if the Democrats get back in and reopen the border to illegals.

Deportation is fine for minor offenses, or even major ones if the illegal is eligible for deportation to El Salvador.

 

[candycorn]

What is it that you think is happening every day in texas?

Illegals are being deported instead of sentenced to prison.

Try to be specific


If the "right thing" is to make an illegal alien spend time in prison and deliver justice to the party who was injured....that isn't happening in Texas. Illegals get a much better deal than those born in the United States.

Again, it is surreal to hear soft-on-crime liberals turn on a dime and suddenly want to punish criminals for thrir crimes

I've never turned on a dime. This has been my position since day one.

 

[candycorn]

You can only "freely return" if the Democrats get back in and reopen the border to illegals.

People are crossing the border as you read this.

Deportation is fine for minor offenses, or even major ones if the illegal is eligible for deportation to El Salvador.

What about justice for the victims?

If an illegal robs you....don't you want to see him go to prison?

Here is where you lie your ass off and say "no". Go ahead...we're all waiting for it; we need a good laugh.

 

[Mac-7]

The reason you never win is because you have zero evidence to support your wacky accusations.

MAGAs are loathe to get down on your level and wallow in the mud with you

I dont need to “win” a meaningless debate with a meaningless person on the internet

No power on earth can change a liberal into something better than you are

And I dont flatter myself into believing I can

 

[candycorn]

MAGAs are loathe to get down on your level and wallow in the mud with you

Pal, you'd have to climb a ladder until Christmas to get to my level.

I dont need to “win”

Its a good thing, because you're a loser.

 

[AZrailwhale]

What gives you the idea that people deported are free to return to the United States?

Experience. When you look at the criminals they have all been deported multiple times and snuck back in.

 

[Mac-7]

Illegals are being deported instead of sentenced to prison.

Name a single case where that has happened

ICE is waiting outside the courthouse doors when lib judges and George Soros appointed DAs in deep blue cities like Austin turn illegal alien criminals loose, not inside to disrupt the trial

 

[Mac-7]

I've never turned on a dime. This has been my position since day one.

“Day one” meaning the day donald trump was sworn in as president

 

[protectionist]

Illegal alien A commits a violent crime. He’s arrested in a red state. He’s turned over to ICE. He is sent back to Mexico where he can come back across the border and commit more crimes.

Illegal alien B commits a violent crime. He’s arrested in a blue state. Sometimes he’s turned over to ice, sometimes he is released before ICE puts a detainer on him. When ICE does get him, he is sent back to Mexico where he can come back across the border and commit more crimes. Not a huge amount of difference except for the month or two he spends coming back across the border. Its like having a speed bump in the road.

What I think should happen is that A/B commits a violent crime and is arrested. He stays in jail. No bond becuase being here illegally certainly demonstrates he flaunts the law, has no real local ties, and is a threat to flee. He then is tried and if convicted, he goes to prison. That is called justice (or what passes for it anyway). If he is found not guilty...he is deported. After his stretch in prison, he gets deported.

For once, I agree with you, except that those who committed the murders, should get deported to hell (the death penalty)

 

[Mac-7]

Experience. When you look at the criminals they have all been deported multiple times and snuck back in.

That was before trump returned to the white house and has since closed the border that liberal said could not done

A few may still slip in but most will have to wait till the next democrat president takes office