Tom Paine 1949
Diamond Member
- Mar 15, 2020
- 5,407
- 4,507
- 1,938
“The filthy, cowardly communists and their supporters” you denounce are mainly just Chinese nationalists who believe a strong state is necessary to defend and develop themselves. They are essentially authoritarian state capitalists.The battle against the filthy, cowardly Communists and their supporters, will be won via economic might. I've said it many times before, national security starts with economic might, this does include, by the way, reasonable and manageable debt levels on top of civil liberties and innovation.
Next is intelligence success. You must know more than your enemy and be able to influence their citizens better than they influence yours. You must steal their technology and stunt their abilities. In this regard, we are failing.
During the Eastern Bloc, many in the East wanted what the West had, the music, (which was so much better than the soulless music played now), sports, opportunity to achieve success, civil liberties, freedom of religion, to party and enjoy life instead of being under the thumb of some despot. Right now, in China, the best influence comes from HK, but China is quickly smothering them, knowing their desire for democracy is strong but not wanting the Mainland citizens to see this better life.
This is where the West is particularly failing. We aren't just exporting their goods, we have some who wish to export their systems of government and they aren't even hiding this agenda! The view of government as being a central power, all knowing, all powerful, in essence a creepy covert police state. In Canada, we are already gone, hence our weak economy and human rights, America must not become like us or some of the soft European nations.
You are right that they are effective economic competitors, but wrong about most everything else. Almost nobody in this country wants to adopt their system. Also, many Chinese do admire our freedoms and success, but they mostly believe that theIr own history and objective circumstances means that a strong (as it were “Confucian”) state and a mixed economy is best for them. That doesn’t mean they want a permanent emperor, or favor all XiJinping’s new restrictions on their freedoms, or want to destroy our own way of life, it just means they are unlikely to overthrow their whole system.
Before Covid-19, millions of Chinese mainlanders traveled to Hong Kong, Taiwan, Japan, the West. They see our failures as well as our successes, and they know us better than we know them. Unlike the old Soviet Union, China has shown it can compete with us economically even when we set the international rules of the game. While I might agree with some of your suggestions for action, overall I think you misunderstand the problem.
Last edited: