Zone1 Have to now ask Trinitarians and Jehovah Witnesses

[JoeB131]

So, why are you responding? Funny how atheists and spiritual phonies respond and Christians and JWs won’t except to try and Bible bash changing subjects. That’s because when they really think about this they realize the three are separate distinct personages and all God.

I'm not sure if there are any JW's on this board.

Hey, I'm an ex-Catholic, so let's take a stab at it. The first question is, "Does God the Son" exist before the life of Jesus? Was he just waiting around to be Jesus for 30 years before returning to the Godhead?" The notion of Jesus is that he lived among humans to finally better understand us. We have to assume God the Father was still up in heaven taking care of the God Business.

The Holy Spirit is the part of God that lives inside all of us. In Catholicism, that was supposed to happen after our Confirmation, I think, but I didn't feel any different.