The Fetterman Massacre: The History and Legacy of the U.S. Army’s Worst Defeat during Red Cloud’s War

[basquebromance]

In the summer of 1866, Colonel Henry B. Carrington set out from Fort Laramie to establish a series of forts along the Bozeman Trail with the goal of protecting migrants moving along the trail. The Bozeman Trail ran through the Powder River country, which included the traditional hunting grounds of Lakota, Cheyenne, and Arapaho peoples. Carrington had about 1,000 people in his column, of which about 700 were soldiers and 300 were civilians, likely soldiers’ families and migrants.

The colonel established Fort Phil Kearny as his headquarters and based 400 troops and most of the civilians there. During the construction of Fort Kearny, which lasted months, Native Americans killed several dozen soldiers and civilians in some 50 separate attacks. The attacks were largely focused on the “wood trains”, comprised of soldiers and civilians harvesting lumber from the surrounding forest for the construction of the fort. Though younger warriors like Crazy Horse conducted the actual attack, Red Cloud and other, older leaders would help plan and direct the harassment and interdiction campaign against the construction of Fort Kearney.

By October 1866, Carrington’s officers and men pressured him to go on the offensive and take the fight to the Native Americans. The pressure was increased by the arrival of a company of sixty-three cavalry troopers led by Lieutenant Horatio S. Bingham in early November. Civil War veterans Captain William J. Fetterman and Captain James W. Powell accompanied the cavalry troopers and were assigned to Fort Kearny as infantry officers, but despite having a distinguished war record, Fetterman had no experience fighting Native Americans. Nevertheless, that lack of experience did not keep Fetterman from criticizing the conservative and defensive posture Carrington had established at Fort Kearny, adding to an already growing chorus of criticism. Fetterman also repeatedly displayed utter contempt for the Native Americans.

 

[JGalt]

That Fetterman sure gets around.

 

[whitehall]

Carrington and Fetterman were both political soldiers in the Civil War with little or no tactical training. Carrington Was a Yale graduate and lived to a ripe old age despite being blamed for the massacre. Lt Fettermn once boasted that he could ride through the Souix Nation with 80 Troops. Ironically he had 81 Troops when he was lured into an ambush of about 2000 Indians. The "massacre" was hardly the worst example of American Troop lured into an ambush but it is notable for the Indians.