Andylusion
Platinum Member
Social Security is exactly the kind of Ponzi scheme you've been screeching about.George, when has government ever solved any of the problems you claim it can solve?You claim capitalists are greedy...but you and other socialists think you're entitled to what you didn't earn.
YOU'RE greedy, George. This is undeniable.The greed of capitalism produces waste through externalities that require costly, public corrective measures and regulation. Capitalists get rich from clean, clean coal, for example, while externalizing health and air quality onto the greater society. Capitalism also concentrates power and wealth within a small segment of society who don't use available technology and resources for their maximum potential in the interest of the public, but rather concentrating wealth into fewer and fewer hands with each passing generation.You claim capitalists are greedy...but you and other socialists think you're entitled to what you didn't earn.
YOU'RE greedy, George. This is undeniableSocial Security solved the problem of senior poverty in the US, and state, local, and federal governments greatly improved air quality in the LA basis over the past fifty years. When have capitalists ever cleaned up any of their externalities without government mandate?eorge, when has government ever solved any of the problems you claim it can solve?
But consistency is not your strong suit, is it?Social Security is exactly the kind of Ponzi scheme you've been screeching about.
But consistency is not your strong suit, is it?![]()
"GOP Candidate Rick Perry caused a relative firestorm in recent weeks by referring to Social Security as a Ponzi Scheme. This has caused a number of rebuttals – one I’m particularly fond of – being a visual person – is this one at MotherJones.
"While that graphic makes a number of good points – and it may reasonably demonstrate that Gov. Perry’s statement that 'Social Security is a Ponzi Scheme' is false as-stated at face-value – it doesn’t really acknowledge that there are some striking similarities between the two – let’s explore..."
Eschewing Obfuscation » Social Security and Ponzi Schemes
SO there is a couple of statements on your Venn Diagram that needs fixed, and some things that are missing.
1. Both engage in clear Fraud. They lie to people about how the system works. Both a Ponzi Scheme, and Social Security, total lies.
2. Contrary: Both put out false statements about how much they have "earned".
3. Contrary: Social Security invests in nothing. Refer to point one, about fraud. (I'll explain more on this later)
4. Whether legal authorities intervene or not, the system does not work. Legislation has never prevented collapse, only delayed it. Social Security has been modified many times. When it was first created, it was a 1% tax. Now it's a 15% tax. Still going broke.
So back to number 3... Your graphic says that Social Security can only be invested in US Treasury Bonds. This is a lie. This is the clear fraud I was referring to. Social Security does not invest in US Treasury Bonds. Never was. Never has. Never will be.
The money that goes into Social Security, is spent, like any other tax money. It is not "invested". There are no investments.
Now to complete the Fraud, the government had to make up a method, so that it appears there are investments, when there are none.
To do this, they made up.... just fabricated a new type of "bond". These "bonds" are not real. They are no more real, than me taking a crayon, and writing "US Bond" on a white piece of paper.
To explain this..... if you purchase a US Treasury Bond online, you will get a US bond. This certificate has a market value. If the bond is 30-years, it will be 30 years before you can cash in that bond to the US government. But you could sell that bond on the open market, and get money for it, before the 30 years is up.
Again... this is because it has a market value.
The "bonds" in the Social Security Trust 'Fund'.... are made up. They are not real bonds. You can't sell them. They have zero market value.
Put another way, if you were in a group of thieves, like a Hollywood movie, and you raided the Social Security Trust Fund, you would leave with lots of paper, and no money. If you stole all the "bonds" in the Social Security Trust Fund, you would have stolen nothing.
Again, this is why when Obama said if we don't increase government borrowing that Social Security would have to be cut... he wasn't lying that time. He was actually saying the truth. There is nothing in the Social Security Trust Fund. Nothing. It's just paper. It has no value.
Social Security, like a Ponzi Scheme, has no investments in anything. There is no savings. No bank accounts. No assets. No ROIs on the money put into it. The money taxed into Socialist Security, is spent just like any other tax money.