RoccoR
Gold Member
- Sep 15, 2010
- 11,935
- 3,552
RE: Who Are the Israelis?
⁜→ Coyote, rylah, et al,
Yeah, there are some rough patches that need ironed-out. This runs afoul of the concept that there can be no stateless person(s).
And the concept of a separate and distinct member of society (one a citizen and one not) runs dangerously close to a pre-destined "Apartheid-like" society.
The trick here is not to create a political entity that, like a cube of sugar in water → the cube floats and remains solid for a while. But after a time, it breaks down and you have to start over again. Destine to fail.
(COMMENT)
There are two things that many of the plans fail to address.
Most Respectfully,
R
⁜→ Coyote, rylah, et al,
(COMMENT)According to MK Ben-Tzur, the Palestinian will a resident, not a citizen.
Yeah, there are some rough patches that need ironed-out. This runs afoul of the concept that there can be no stateless person(s).
And the concept of a separate and distinct member of society (one a citizen and one not) runs dangerously close to a pre-destined "Apartheid-like" society.
(COMMENT)On the other hand, MK Yehuda Gluck proposes sovereignty in the form of a federation, which sounds potentially better.
I think sovereignty is a possible solution to a complex problem but its success depends very much on how it is applied, and this movement specifically has some questionable aspects.
The trick here is not to create a political entity that, like a cube of sugar in water → the cube floats and remains solid for a while. But after a time, it breaks down and you have to start over again. Destine to fail.
(COMMENT)
There are two things that many of the plans fail to address.
◈ Poverty and the necessity to support the new economy, financial institutions, water allocations and other transporation and utility systems. This may sound funny, at first, but believe me when I say that these subdivided political entities are not going to survive in isolation. Thus, every aspect of the 21st Century is going to need to be interlocking.
◈ The plans assume that the envolved populations are going to work to make there peiceof the plan a going concern. You have to ensure that the new entity is not just another incubator and growth medium for Jihadists, Insurgents, Radicalized Islamic Troublemakers, Adherents, Guerrillas and Asymmetric Fighter.
◈ The plans assume that the envolved populations are going to work to make there peiceof the plan a going concern. You have to ensure that the new entity is not just another incubator and growth medium for Jihadists, Insurgents, Radicalized Islamic Troublemakers, Adherents, Guerrillas and Asymmetric Fighter.
Most Respectfully,
R