Do We Really Need Guns?

I agree with a lot of that with one strong exception. Basically I think we're saying similar things in different temporal directions; you're talking present tense and I'm talking future. I see a culture in the present tense that needs to change itself. What we suffer is not a failure of laws but of spirit.

The strong exception I take is here:
"Our opinions on firearms and how they are portrayed in media will never change that"

Au contraire, I submit that public opinion always effects change, and that media and the larger body of cultural mores follows, not leads, public opinion. The impediment in that dynamic is influencing that public opinion on a large scale. That's no easy task but it always starts with introspection; as the sage says, the longest journey begins with a single step.

Hollyweird sells violence because violence sells. And violence sells because it has cultural value, just as fire burns because it has fuel to consume. As long as we the people keep supplying the fuel by buying the product, the fire burns. In this particular cultural value we are not so much "consumers" as "enablers".

Maybe I didn't express my point about our opinions and firearms correctly. The statement was toward how effective firearms are at doing the job they do ... And opinions don't have an effect on the firearm.

We can influence more responsible firearm ownership and attitudes towards firearm violence ... But that doesn't effect to the ability of a firearm to remain the most effective defense mechanism. Our attitudes can change the desire to use a firearm (especially in unwarranted circumstances). Our attitudes can reduce the desire of individuals to reach for a firearm as a solution (much less the best solution) to any problem.

It will never make the firearm as a tool less effective at doing its job ... Not meaning to get technical ... But they work at eliminating threats.


I see. Maybe I just read it the way I wanted it to go. :)

I don't disagree with any of that, but I don't think it offers any solutions either. It just basically states the status quo. We don't disagree that that's what the status quo is. I like to focus on what it could be.
 
I see. Maybe I just read it the way I wanted it to go. :)

I don't disagree with any of that, but I don't think it offers any solutions either. It just basically states the status quo. We don't disagree that that's what the status quo is. I like to focus on what it could be.

Well ... What could be is more responsible. Unfortunately sacrificing my ability to protect myself is not a solution I am interested in.

I am not guilty of offering solutions though ... I am intrinsically attached to the idea that the present is handicapped in accepting bad things happen to good people. Perhaps we can accept that the best case scenario doesn't mean it is best for everyone.

.
 
i have head it before

but it is true you really are a dumb ass

--LOL

appearing in a public place
Public intoxication laws require that the defendant be in a public place, rather than a private residence or other area that is not open to the general public. Examples of public places include sidewalks, streets, stadiums, and parks. In some states, bars and restaurants are considered public places because they are open to the general public.


What is Public Intoxication Drunk in Public Laws and Penalties Criminal Law
Once again, we are not talking about public intoxication.

Well then what ARE you talking about? There are laws regarding using your firearm responsibly. You can't just go into a bar, get drunk and start shooting your weapon. You will be arrested. What other law would you like to see regarding this issue?
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.






It is? The cops don't carry guns? Ever?
 
Well then what ARE you talking about? There are laws regarding using your firearm responsibly. You can't just go into a bar, get drunk and start shooting your weapon. You will be arrested. What other law would you like to see regarding this issue?
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.


--LOL

it is prove it


If you think most of the world carries the violence mentality we do, you just ain't been outside, son...
Nonsense. We're no better or worse than other countries. If you disagree it's probably because you live in one of the democrat strong holds. Move to a republican strong hold and you'll see a helluva lot less violence and it will be more like Europe. Our problem isn't guns it's the people in democrat hell holes.
 
Once again, we are not talking about public intoxication.

Well then what ARE you talking about? There are laws regarding using your firearm responsibly. You can't just go into a bar, get drunk and start shooting your weapon. You will be arrested. What other law would you like to see regarding this issue?
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.






It is? The cops don't carry guns? Ever?
In some places the cops don't carry guns except in exceptional circumstances.
 
For example...rich guy and former Mayor Bloomberg, current leader of the anti gun movement has a home on one of the Caribbean islands....no one on the island is allowed to own or carry guns...even the police are disarmed...now this gun grabber bloomberg....he has a home, and he has professional security....and he came to a deal with the local government...his private security is allowed to carry guns on the island....so on an island with no private gun ownership allowed...he feels the need to have heavily armed private security...and you call us paranoid.....
 
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.


--LOL

it is prove it


If you think most of the world carries the violence mentality we do, you just ain't been outside, son...
Nonsense. We're no better or worse than other countries. If you disagree it's probably because you live in one of the democrat strong holds. Move to a republican strong hold and you'll see a helluva lot less violence and it will be more like Europe. Our problem isn't guns it's the people in democrat hell holes.

I *am* in a "Republican strong hold", genius, and that cockamamie theory has been tried before. It's profoundly irrelevant and has absolute Zero relationship to anything.

I'm not saying I've never been outside, I'm saying the Haiku Man hasn't. Hell I travel all over this country and others. That's exactly why I know better. Moreover the point wasn't about "violence"; it was about the presence of guns.

And part of that travel is in Europe, and I guarantee you, it bears no resemblance whatsoever to a "Republican strong hold".
 
Last edited:
Well then what ARE you talking about? There are laws regarding using your firearm responsibly. You can't just go into a bar, get drunk and start shooting your weapon. You will be arrested. What other law would you like to see regarding this issue?
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.






It is? The cops don't carry guns? Ever?
In some places the cops don't carry guns except in exceptional circumstances.






I know. But when they need them, they have them....don't they. And unlike here in the US, the majority of police in Europe are armed with submachine guns.
 
I know. But when they need them, they have them....don't they. And unlike here in the US, the majority of police in Europe are armed with submachine guns.

Like the Greater Manchester Police Department ...



.
 
Blacksand...who are you going to trust....the anti gunners...or your lying eyes....
 
Blacksand...who are you going to trust....the anti gunners...or your lying eyes....

I don't need to trust the anti-gunners ... I haz Google locked and loaded!



Edit:
I should add that I have a fair amount of respect for cops in the United Kingdom ... They can brawl almost as good as cops in Germany.

.
 
Last edited:
passing a law saying it is illegal does not deter a person who doesn't care about the law, and those are the people who would be most likely to start shooting up a place.
We do not have to encourage people who are going to be drinking to carry guns in bars because it is legal.

or we say you can't be intoxicated and carry, and leave it up to the CCW person to either carry and stay sober, or not carry and drink. The issue is when a blanket restriction is made that doesn't prevent people of ill will from carrying, and only restricts those who would follow the law anyway.
Encourage it then. Have the police go into bars, frisk everyone and breathalize those with guns.

How about we do the same thing to everyone with a set of car keys in their pockets?
In many places, the bartender is responsible for serving a person if they drive drunk and are in an accident. If a drunk person shoots someone, should the bartender be responsible.

And yes, a drunk person's car keys should be confiscated from them. I did it when I was a bartender.

You cannot take a person's car keys just because they are in a bar, and you cannot take a person's gun either.
 
I know. But when they need them, they have them....don't they. And unlike here in the US, the majority of police in Europe are armed with submachine guns.

Like the Greater Manchester Police Department ...



.




French
05francespan-articleLarge.jpg


Italian
Italian-police-escort-maf-001.jpg


German-police-at-Frankfur-006.jpg
German

Spanish
photo_verybig_118795.jpg
 
We do not have to encourage people who are going to be drinking to carry guns in bars because it is legal.

or we say you can't be intoxicated and carry, and leave it up to the CCW person to either carry and stay sober, or not carry and drink. The issue is when a blanket restriction is made that doesn't prevent people of ill will from carrying, and only restricts those who would follow the law anyway.
Encourage it then. Have the police go into bars, frisk everyone and breathalize those with guns.

How about we do the same thing to everyone with a set of car keys in their pockets?
In many places, the bartender is responsible for serving a person if they drive drunk and are in an accident. If a drunk person shoots someone, should the bartender be responsible.

And yes, a drunk person's car keys should be confiscated from them. I did it when I was a bartender.

You cannot take a person's car keys just because they are in a bar, and you cannot take a person's gun either.
I did that once too.
 
Well then what ARE you talking about? There are laws regarding using your firearm responsibly. You can't just go into a bar, get drunk and start shooting your weapon. You will be arrested. What other law would you like to see regarding this issue?
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.






It is? The cops don't carry guns? Ever?
In some places the cops don't carry guns except in exceptional circumstances.
That is how it is here in Ireland. Could you imagine American cops patrolling without guns?
 
Passing a law that says it is legal to carry a firearm in a bar does not help society.

cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.






It is? The cops don't carry guns? Ever?
In some places the cops don't carry guns except in exceptional circumstances.
That is how it is here in Ireland. Could you imagine American cops patrolling without guns?

Security guards patrol without guns. Now granted, their job description is a bit different. But they could still wind up getting shot. Shopping malls for example, are a place where security patrol is not much different from police patrol.
 
gun control hippies seem to forget that criminals get guns illegally. And most gun owners- 95% or higher- get them legally and are very responsible and only get them for protection and not for the commission of a crime.
 
cobbling together "gun free zones" certainly has not helped society
Most of the civilized world is a gun free zone. You should get out and experience the civilized world.


--LOL

it is prove it


If you think most of the world carries the violence mentality we do, you just ain't been outside, son...
Nonsense. We're no better or worse than other countries. If you disagree it's probably because you live in one of the democrat strong holds. Move to a republican strong hold and you'll see a helluva lot less violence and it will be more like Europe. Our problem isn't guns it's the people in democrat hell holes.

I *am* in a "Republican strong hold", genius, and that cockamamie theory has been tried before. It's profoundly irrelevant and has absolute Zero relationship to anything.

I'm not saying I've never been outside, I'm saying the Haiku Man hasn't. Hell I travel all over this country and others. That's exactly why I know better. Moreover the point wasn't about "violence"; it was about the presence of guns.

And part of that travel is in Europe, and I guarantee you, it bears no resemblance whatsoever to a "Republican strong hold".


reduced to name calling --LOL

hey fuck wad i have traveled quite a bit you loser

btw even GUN FREE England is not gun free to the criminal element

it certainly is not violent crime free

you are an internet joke
 

Forum List

Back
Top