emilynghiem
Constitutionalist / Universalist
- Jan 21, 2010
- 23,669
- 4,181
- Thread starter
- #61
Dear Brian Blackwell and Pogo
I hope you both continue to post here and anywhere else as well.
You are both very articulate and informative explaining your views, thank you!
Brian the problem I have found with liberal minded people
is they can't tell the difference between the govt/law
forbidding someone or a business from abusing someone illegally
and "discriminating" as in choosing not to "engage in a behavior of choice."
Withthe LGBT cake service lawsuits,
I tried to make a distinction between
* not serving customers because of their affiliation
vs
* not PROVIDING certain services they choose not to because of their beliefs
The choice of services are different from the people being served.
The LGBT arguments were blending this together.
Pogo this is what I mean by BELIEFS changing how we look at laws or rights.
If one person BELIEFS LGBT orientation is not a choice but is born into like race,
that's a different LAW being applied than someone who sees LGBT orientation
as a choice and same sex marriage faith based practice that govt cannot force anyone to engage in.
If we don't BELIEVE the same things about where LGBT orientation comes
from, we don't see rights or laws the same way. So it's like conflicting cultures.
I hope you both continue to post here and anywhere else as well.
You are both very articulate and informative explaining your views, thank you!
Brian the problem I have found with liberal minded people
is they can't tell the difference between the govt/law
forbidding someone or a business from abusing someone illegally
and "discriminating" as in choosing not to "engage in a behavior of choice."
Withthe LGBT cake service lawsuits,
I tried to make a distinction between
* not serving customers because of their affiliation
vs
* not PROVIDING certain services they choose not to because of their beliefs
The choice of services are different from the people being served.
The LGBT arguments were blending this together.
Pogo this is what I mean by BELIEFS changing how we look at laws or rights.
If one person BELIEFS LGBT orientation is not a choice but is born into like race,
that's a different LAW being applied than someone who sees LGBT orientation
as a choice and same sex marriage faith based practice that govt cannot force anyone to engage in.
If we don't BELIEVE the same things about where LGBT orientation comes
from, we don't see rights or laws the same way. So it's like conflicting cultures.