- Moderator
- #101
Not. Quite. Accurate.
Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.
Yikes are you ever confused.
I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.
I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .
Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.
Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.
The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.
Except in Israel that is ;--)
Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.
Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.
Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.
You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.
Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.
But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?
Not a nightmare at all, they'd just be going home where they belonged. They can get their UN welfare somewhere else, clearly they are not happy in Israel, so out they go.
8 million Israeli's are going to have a tough time figuring out where "they belonged'.
Again not Israel's problem
Where in the Geneva Conventions does it say its Israel's problem to figure out where they end up ?
You're confusing things - the 8 million are the Israeli's Monte wants to export. Your export quota is only 4 million Palestinians.
Either way - whomever does the exporting is screwed - it may not "be their problem" but it is defacto their problem because it's no one else's responsibility. So, either you're opting for genocide, soylent green, or...something else. What something else?