koshergrl
Diamond Member
- Aug 4, 2011
- 81,129
- 14,025
The Bill of Rights is a limitation on the government not on individuals. This must be the first you are hearing this.I said no and meant no. Can someone force you out of your house and into a concert hall where the music is too loud? Paying taxes is an arrangement between a citizen and the government. It does not involve the whims of another citizen.But we don't live in a society where you can do what you like.
"I don't want to pay taxes, no means no"
"I don't want to keep the noise down on my music, no means no"
Problem is you don't live in a country where anarchy reigns supreme. Sorry.
We are supposed to live in a society where we do whst we like. It's called freedom. Why do you dislike it so much? What makes someone else's judgment on what you do better than your own? How personal does interference need to be before you say no?
But you're picking and choosing where no means no. This is the problem.
Can the govt force you to do things?
Yes, it can force you to go to war, force you to go to prison, force you to pay them money, force you to do quite a number of things, actually.
No, you're not supposed to live in a society where you do whatever you like.
If you didn't notice there is something called the Bill of Rights and the theory behind rights is that you can do what you like AS LONG AS you don't harm or hurt other people. In other words, all rights have LIMITS.
I'm sorry no one managed to tell you this before. But it's there.
There is no right to not be offended. There is no right to not get your feelings hurt. The government can force you to give it money. When an individual forces you to give him money it's theft.
The government cannot force you to be nice. It can not force you to be a friend or a good neighbor. It cannot force a business to provide good customer service. The government cannot stop someone from being nasty, or insulting. It won't stop anyone from hurting your feelings even if you cry for a week.
Where do you get these nonsense ideas?
I didn't say the Bill of Rights was a limitation on the people. You just decided I had said that. What I said was that the ideals of the Bill of Rights exist and the US is bound up in this theory whether you like it or not.
I didn't say there was a right to not be offended. However we live in a society and the people have decided how they want society to be, and they make rules and regulations to make sure that happens. And yes, there are laws that say you can't do some things, things that hurt people.
No, government can't force you to be nice. But it CAN force you to respect the laws of the land. And if those laws say a business can't discriminate against someone based on gender, sexual preference, skin color, ethnicity, then YOU CAN'T DO IT.
So hurt feelings of a protected class equates to ruining the livelyhood of people selling cakes?
And government force is government force. One wonders if someone like you supports government overwhelming force in something as trivial as a baker not wanting to bake a cake, what other uses of force you could support against people you don't like.
I don't wonder. I know exactly what these people are about.