rylah
Gold Member
- Jun 10, 2015
- 22,081
- 4,703
- 290
You keep bringing up Resolution 181 like it means something. Israel also mentioned Resolution 181 in its declaration of independence. Even in fake history it is said that Israel acquired territory beyond that what was allotted in Resolution 181.RE: Palestinians Massing At The Israeli Border
⁜→ P F Tinmore, et al,
I think you missed my question!
(ANSWER)Where was Israel's territory?(COUNTER-QUESTION)
And just where does the Hostile Arab Palestinian derive the authority to make credible threats and THEN use force against the territorial integrity or political independence of the newly formed State of Israel???
Most Respectfully,
R
Got a map?
At Midnight 14/15 May 1948, at the initial declaration of Independence, the official territory conformed to that annotated in:
However that all change immediately upon the observation of movement towards that boundary. Israel redeployed forward to defendable positions to meet the imminent attack, by Arab League Forces. which came in the daylight hours of 15 May.
Annex A
Plan of Partition with Economic Union
Annex B
City of Jerusalem
Boundaries Proposed By The Ad Hoc Committee On The Palestinian Question
* *** *
At the conclusion of hostilities in 1949, by Armistice Arrangement through the efforts of the UN Mediator by Dr. Ralph Bunche. Dr Bunche became a 1950 Nobel Peace Prize Laureate for his efforts. The Armistice Lines represented the Forward Edge of the Battle Areas.
More permanent arrangements have been established since that time, with the parties to the conflict; which did not include the Hostile Arab Palestinians.
Most Respectfully,
R
However, there was no Resolution 181. There was no territory allotted to a Jewish state. There was no legitimacy given to a Jewish state. Resolution 181 was not implemented by the Security Council as required by the resolution.
So my question remains unanswered. You ducked it again.
No territory acquired by Israel is beyond the border of the territory vested with the sovereignty of the Jewish Nation.
Resolution 181 was the first time an Arab state was suggested on the west bank of the territory that was alloted to the Jewish Nation under international law, not the other way around.
With or without the resolution Jews had all the legal claim to independence in that territory, Arabs still don't, and that's the grasp at 181 as a bluff pretending it gives them any right to dominate any more territory beyond the 99% given to them in the middle east.
Was not implemented, was denied by the Arab league, therefore no territory was EVER legally alloted to an Arab state.
While You keep obsessively trying to turn every fact on its head , the territory alloted to the Jewish Nation is recognized even by the"Palestinian Academic Society for The Study of International Affairs" website:
PASSIA - MAPS - Palestine - PALESTINE UNDER THE BRITISH MANDATEPalestine was already there. It was multi ethnic, multi religious state. The "Arab" state and "Jewish" state were products of the partition that didn't happen. So yeah, there was no "Arab" state.Was not implemented, was denied by the Arab league, therefore no territory was EVER legally alloted to an Arab state.
77% of the land intended for the Jewish Nation was partitioned for the Hashemite Kingdom,
an Arab state that bans all Jews by law.
Partition indeed happened, You just obsess, at the expense of all involved, about chipping away at the little left for Jews.