Skylar
Diamond Member
- Jul 5, 2014
- 52,460
- 15,583
How is my saying, "Yes, your relationship is just like my marriage" essential for them to get married? How is having a specific baker bake their wedding cake required for them to get married?
No one's "not allowing" it. We just aren't agreeing with it. Doesn't stop them from having a marriage, if that's what they think it is, any more than my thinking the next-door neighbor's marriage is a sham because he's fucking three or four women a week on the side (my actual neighbor doesn't, but if he did . . .)
But here's the thing. Your neighbor who fucks three or four other women STILL gets the legal recognition of his marriage. His wife still gets the legal protections that the other four women don't get. He has a heart attack while boning Mistress #3, the wife still gets all his property and custody of the kids.
Gays should get the same protections.
We trumpet, long and loud, about all the legal protections allowed to straight couples, and denied to gays. But, the reality is, that if gays were really serious about all those supposed protections, they would go see a lawyer, have a contract set up, and move on. That caterwauling is nothing more than subterfuge.
Two problems with that reasoning. First, not all gays could get the same legal protections or benefits. Second, why should they have to? They have to put in far more expense and energy to get inferior legal results. Marriage is far simpler and far broader with a far more complete set of protections.
The government is consistent - if you are not a man and a woman, and you aren't married, then there are some benefits you will not get. Single couples, living together, got no more protection than a gay couple living together.
In 37 of 50 States the government recongizes same sex marriage as being as legally valid as straight marriage. And in a few weeks it will be 50 of 50 States.
That's consistency.
Don't like it? Fix the law. But, just like you don't want Christians to invoke their values on you, you should not be able to invoke YOUR values on them.
Already in process. Obergefell. Remember the name.