Give me a good reason illegal immigrants should be granted citizenship

[Missourian]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

 

[BlackFlag]

Because it will help take down the white devil

 

[TNHarley]

LOL good luck OP

 

[TNHarley]

Because it will help take down the white devil

Even when given the chance they cant say anything worth a shit

 

[hazlnut]

Jesus would like it if we did.

 

[TNHarley]

Jesus would like it if we did.

Second batch of evidence

 

[Borillar]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

Just to clarify, are you drawing a distinction between the "Dreamers", those brought here as children who have lived here most of their lives and identify as Americans, and other illegal immigrants who are here of their own volition ignoring our immigration laws and abusing our hospitality?

 

[TNHarley]

Fuck the "dreamers" as well. Thats just more incentive for future illegals.

 

[BluesLegend]

Ah, so the left can pat themselves on the back for caring while exploiting illegals for cheap labor?

 

[Tank]

Because brown people can't take care of themselves

 

[Tank]

Jesus would like it if we did.

Jesus needs to go to Mexico

 

[forkup]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

The Effects of Immigration on the United States’ Economy
"economic effects of immigration are clear: Economic analysis finds little support for the view that inflows of foreign labor have reduced jobs or Americans’ wages."
The article is from Wharton so pretty reliable.

 

[BlackFlag]

Because it will help take down the white devil

Even when given the chance they cant say anything worth a shit

But that's what you cons are always saying! You were right!

 

[Missourian]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

Just to clarify, are you drawing a distinction between the "Dreamers", those brought here as children who have lived here most of their lives and identify as Americans, and other illegal immigrants who are here of their own volition ignoring our immigration laws and abusing our hospitality?

Correct.

 

[Missourian]

Not even one?

 

[Borillar]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

Can't think of any reason to grant citizenship. Legal residency as guest workers perhaps, as long as they have a sponsor - and just them, not their entire families. People who want to be citizens should follow the legal path to that end. Undocumented aliens who are discovered should be deported.

 

[Syriusly]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

I personally don't think that they should be granted citizenship.

I am fine with a pathway to permanent work status- but not citizenship.

 

[Syriusly]

Ah, so the left can pat themselves on the back for caring while exploiting illegals for cheap labor?

Wow- so you really believe that all of the farmers and factories and contractors that exploit illegal immigrants are 'the left'?

LOL

 

[Missouri_Mike]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

There are no good reasons. Not even for the so called dreamers. All of them can go back.

 

[Missouri_Mike]

Make the case for granting citizenship. Not Dreamers...illegal immigrants.

And no "out of the shadows" argument...they can do that by going home...boom...out of the shadows.

I personally don't think that they should be granted citizenship.

I am fine with a pathway to permanent work status- but not citizenship.

And they can get that work permit once they go back home and apply for and are granted one.