Oldstyle
Platinum Member
- Jul 19, 2011
- 31,206
- 4,935
So you're claiming that our system was doomed until FDR "saved" it? You're an amusing fellow, Joey! Speaking as a History major I'd like to commend you on your total lack of understanding of what made the United States great and what continues to make it great!
Listening to you expound on world history makes me wonder where you studied the subject? Or didn't...
I have a bachelor degree in history from UIC. True, it's not one of those universities that teaches about talking snakes, so there's that.
The first problem is, no history major would expound that the US is "Great". Frankly, we have just as much in our history to be ashamed of than proud of. You know, genocide of the Native Americans, slavery, exploitation of immigrant labor.
Second, um, yeah, the US probably would have slid into fascism if FDR hadn't saved it. As Herbert Hoover expounded,
View attachment 308408
It's an interesting "take" on American history, Joe when you declare that no history major would claim that America was "great" because of 3 things that took place in this nation that were not our finest moments! I disagree with your premise that those 3 things negate all of the truly great things that have been accomplished by this country! For literally hundreds of years the United States of America has been a shining "beacon on a hill" that oppressed people throughout the rest of the world looked to for hope and inspiration! We were the place that people with a dream came to make those dreams come true. We were the nation where your contributions to society mattered more than your social status! We were the nation where the strong fought to protect the rights of the weak! We were the nation where freedom of the press and freedom of religion were bedrock rights...a nation whose judicial system was the envy of the world! We were the nation that showed others that power could be transferred from one individual to another without warfare and coups...that it could be done in peaceful elections! We are the nation that was always there in times of crisis...the most generous nation in the history of the world!
To be quite frank with you...I've always found the intellectual left's narrative that America should be ashamed of what it is to be myopic in view. It's quite scary to think what might have happened to the world if the United States DIDN'T exist! Do we have our warts and blemishes? Of course...all nations do! But to claim that America isn't great is progressive hog wash!