Is a third so called palestinian state really necessary

[Boston1]

There are already two states, Gaza and Jordan which both claim to be palestinian. How many more do they want before they will embrace peace, or is it all just a sham to keep chipping away at Israel ?

 

[abi]

You have this framed incorrectly. The mandate of 1948 that was never implemented asked the indigenous people to forfeit half of their land to immigrants from Europe. Obviously, they declined.

Go ask that of any other people on earth and see if the response would be any different than that of the Palestinians.

 

[Boston1]

Indigenous people ???????

Surely you must be referring to the Judaic people who have inhabited this area since at least the early to mid bronze age who had already forfeited roughly 80% of their land when the British gave it to Arabs and created Trans-Jordan.

Perhaps you would benefit from a little education in this matter prior to posting again ;-)

 

[rylah]

You have this framed incorrectly. The mandate of 1948 that was never implemented asked the indigenous people to forfeit half of their land to immigrants from Europe. Obviously, they declined.

Go ask that of any other people on earth and see if the response would be any different than that of the Palestinians.

Those indigenous Arabian tribes You were referring to, who colonized Levant have whole Emirates in the Arabian peninsula. Emirates for their tribes, where they're the indigenous people.

Yet they still demand an additional Jew free land in Judea, where Jews are the indigenous people.

 

[Indeependent]

You have this framed incorrectly. The mandate of 1948 that was never implemented asked the indigenous people to forfeit half of their land to immigrants from Europe. Obviously, they declined.

Go ask that of any other people on earth and see if the response would be any different than that of the Palestinians.

No wonder your heart is looks like a twisted, confused pretzel.

 

[Hollie]

You have this framed incorrectly. The mandate of 1948 that was never implemented asked the indigenous people to forfeit half of their land to immigrants from Europe. Obviously, they declined.

Go ask that of any other people on earth and see if the response would be any different than that of the Palestinians.

That’s an odd notion. You’re claiming that Arabs-Moslems were asked to give up half of their land. That’s odd because the land area was controlled by the Turkish Islamists who relinquished all rights and title to the Mandatory. Arab-Moslem squatters didn’t own the land.