Is it ever acceptable to bomb a school or a hospital? (Poll)

[kyzr]

To a degree.
If there's a mortar battery in a hospital or school atrium raining HE on Israeli residential area, taking out that battery with a...

• 20kt nuke: Not proportional
• 2000lb guided bomb? Proportional

Suppose there are no active shooters in the school or hospital, but they are used as entrances to tunnels?
2,000# bomb ?
Ground forces?

 

[Road Runner]

It seems like a lose-lose situation but I think that I have to agree with the OP on this one. To sacrifice innocent people is horrible, and I'm sure there's other places to attack them at but a part of me is saying yes too but that's just a tiny fraction.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Ok, so if 40,000 were killed in total, and 15,000 were Hamas fighters, lets say that 40,000 -15,000 = 25,000 civilian deaths

Israel-Gaza war: More than 40,000 killed in Gaza, Hamas-run health ministry says

The actual number of people killed in the war is likely to be higher, local officials say.

www.bbc.com

More than 40,000 killed in Gaza, Hamas-run health ministry says​

This month, Israel’s military told the BBC that more than 15,000 terrorists had been killed during the war.

I don't have a dog in that fight, my bitch is that we give the IDF thousands of 2,000# bombs to level Gaza, then $billions to Hamas to rebuild Gaza, again, and again, and again, as long as I can remember. Where are those 2.3m people supposed to live?

You really are incredibly stupid. you are using Hamas' numbers and subtracting Israel's claims. So, you are combining two estimates from two sources who cannot verify each other's numbers. You don't see how blatantly stupid that is?

You need to seek an education and sue the people who gave you the one you have because it was defective.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Suppose there are no active shooters in the school or hospital, but they are used as entrances to tunnels?
2,000# bomb ?
Ground forces?

Making another assumption without facts. They knew there were terrorists in those buildings, and they dropped a bomb and killed them. Why do you not understand that is the easiest and most efficient way?

 

[M14 Shooter]

Suppose there are no active shooters in the school or hospital, but they are used as entrances to tunnels?
2,000# bomb ?
Ground forces?

If I had the option, I'd go with ground forces, for the intel if nothing else.
If not - pickle it.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Yeah and if Russia did like your beloved nation of Israel, the media and politicians would be screaming we must stop this and you would slavishly support them.

Can’t fix stupid.

The Russians are doing the exact same thing in Ukraine, and now the Ukrainians are killing Russians on the Russian side of the border. War sucks and then someone dies.

 

[irosie91]

It seems like a lose-lose situation but I think that I have to agree with the OP on this one. To sacrifice innocent people is horrible, and I'm sure there's other places to attack them at but a part of me is saying yes too but that's just a tiny fraction.

for a discussion on "who is
innocent" read the koran along
with Hadiths and commentary.
-----best choice the ALI YUSUF
version. hint----no joooos is
innocent

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

"WE" saw and heard honest truth of OCT 07 torturous massacre. Have seen nor heard no honest reporting of what you speak. That is the difference. Of course no one wants innocent Children blown up by bombings. But no one knows what is true. Once the enemy starts a unprovoked conflict, nothing can be believed AFTER. Ukraine blew up Norstrom, killed its own people in a desperate attempt to blame it on Russia. Might as well turn off your Al Jeezera for what its' worth now.

Wake up! You are dreaming.

 

[kyzr]

You really are incredibly stupid. you are using Hamas' numbers and subtracting Israel's claims. So, you are combining two estimates from two sources who cannot verify each other's numbers. You don't see how blatantly stupid that is?
You need to seek an education and sue the people who gave you the one you have because it was defective.

Yadda yadda yadda my numbers are better than your numbers dumbass.

Don't critique', put up a better answer. You and Trump like to throw insults instead of providing brilliant answers.

 

[kyzr]

If I had the option, I'd go with ground forces, for the intel if nothing else.
If not - pickle it.

That's where I'm at too. We're in the minority on this thread.

 

[Road Runner]

for a discussion on "who is
innocent" read the koran along
with Hadiths and commentary.
-----best choice the ALI YUSUF
version. hint----no joooos is
innocent

What about the children? They're innocent.

 

[kyzr]

Making another assumption without facts. They knew there were terrorists in those buildings, and they dropped a bomb and killed them. Why do you not understand that is the easiest and most efficient way?

Because I don't want to destroy schools or hospitals unnecessarily, not to mention patients and kids.

How about the IDF just uses neutron bombs to eliminate the Gazans but keeps the buildings intact?

 

[irosie91]

What about the children? They're innocent.

according to whom? In islamic
law--to wit 'shariah' the children
are booty

 

[irosie91]

Because I don't want to destroy schools or hospitals unnecessarily, not to mention patients and kids.

How about the IDF just uses neutron bombs to eliminate the Gazans but keeps the buildings intact?

there is no question----the weapons need further development

 

[Road Runner]

according to whom? In islamic
law--to wit 'shariah' the children
are booty

I don't care about the Islamic law, I care about the kids and the patients as kyzr already pointed out.

 

[M14 Shooter]

That's where I'm at too. We're in the minority on this thread.

The number of people agreeing with you does not make you right or wrong.

 

[irosie91]

I don't care about the Islamic law, I care about the kids and the patients as kyzr already pointed out.

Islamic law is very important in the
wars in the Middle East. In fact it is
very important wherever muslims
live.

 

[Road Runner]

Islamic law is very important in the
wars in the Middle East. In fact it is
very important wherever muslims
live.

What about human lives?

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

You make a good point

Genocide means wiping out an entire race or culture such as what communist china is doing to its muslim population

Nothing like that is happening in gaza

Or at least, killing more than 1 person per dropped bomb.

 

[Vastator]

How about the IDF just uses neutron bombs to eliminate the Gazans but keeps the buildings intact?

You have my attention...