Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
It is not for me to figure out how the Israelis can fix the problem they have created. They should have quit their land grabbing after the United Nations accepted Israel as a member state. The Occupation will destroy Israel.I am neither a Swiss banker nor an Israeli.I am asking you...As the Swiss bankers asked the next of kin of Jews gassed at Auschwitz-Birkenau.How can you verify claims then?Asking for land documents before Palestinian refugees can return to their land would be like Swiss banks requiring death certificates from Auschwitz-Birkenau before valuables can be withdrawn by Jewish next-of-kin. It is obscene.
Everyone knows who are the Palestinian refugees and their descendants. They have a right of return.
You really think that the time you're wasting with snarky answers actually HELPS the people who have 10 or 30 years in the refugee camps?
Figure out how to make BOTH sides happy. Figure out how to get people OUT of those camps. Or most of them. Sending them all to Israel is not gonna happen..
To their credit, the Spanish refuse to deny the right of return of Sephardic refugees even after 500 years....
All refugees who are no longer refugees -- in practical fact -- should be removed from consideration in terms of re-settlement. As in, removed from the lists and no longer considered refugees. ...
It is not for me to figure out how the Israelis can fix the problem they have created. They should have quit their land grabbing after the United Nations accepted Israel as a member state. The Occupation will destroy Israel.I am neither a Swiss banker nor an Israeli.I am asking you...As the Swiss bankers asked the next of kin of Jews gassed at Auschwitz-Birkenau.How can you verify claims then?
Everyone knows who are the Palestinian refugees and their descendants. They have a right of return.
You really think that the time you're wasting with snarky answers actually HELPS the people who have 10 or 30 years in the refugee camps?
Figure out how to make BOTH sides happy. Figure out how to get people OUT of those camps. Or most of them. Sending them all to Israel is not gonna happen..
Indeed, the historical homeland of the Sephardim is Spain.The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
Exactly. Neither has the right of the Jewish people to return to their ancestral and historical homeland been abrogated. (Yes, I realize you think the Jewish people originated in Spain, but that's just silly.)
Why do you refer to Palestinians as "PALIS"?It is not for me to figure out how the Israelis can fix the problem they have created. They should have quit their land grabbing after the United Nations accepted Israel as a member state. The Occupation will destroy Israel.I am neither a Swiss banker nor an Israeli.I am asking you...As the Swiss bankers asked the next of kin of Jews gassed at Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Everyone knows who are the Palestinian refugees and their descendants. They have a right of return.
You really think that the time you're wasting with snarky answers actually HELPS the people who have 10 or 30 years in the refugee camps?
Figure out how to make BOTH sides happy. Figure out how to get people OUT of those camps. Or most of them. Sending them all to Israel is not gonna happen..
Can we talk? I mean REALLY TALK? I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war.. I agree that camps full of refugees in OTHER countries is a bad thing. Although I DON'T know all their stories like you seem to do. But I also know that the PALIS have made a series of SERIOUS mistakes over the last 60 years or so.. Some that indicate they are NOT LIKELY to be CAPABLE of forming a nation-state...
Can you NAME ANY of these mistakes that THEY (the PALIS) have made??
The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
You keep pressing that argument as if it means something in the current situation. It is not a right of return issue. They are not refugees. It was Spains apology for expelling them, not an acknowledgement of indigenous rights.
Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war..
Look up the definition of refugee, and explain how they are refugees because that doesn't seem to fit.It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
You keep pressing that argument as if it means something in the current situation. It is not a right of return issue. They are not refugees. It was Spains apology for expelling them, not an acknowledgement of indigenous rights.
It is not for me to figure out how the Israelis can fix the problem they have created. They should have quit their land grabbing after the United Nations accepted Israel as a member state. The Occupation will destroy Israel.I am neither a Swiss banker nor an Israeli.I am asking you...As the Swiss bankers asked the next of kin of Jews gassed at Auschwitz-Birkenau.How can you verify claims then?
Everyone knows who are the Palestinian refugees and their descendants. They have a right of return.
You really think that the time you're wasting with snarky answers actually HELPS the people who have 10 or 30 years in the refugee camps?
Figure out how to make BOTH sides happy. Figure out how to get people OUT of those camps. Or most of them. Sending them all to Israel is not gonna happen..
Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war..
The Palestinians did not initiate the war.It is not for me to figure out how the Israelis can fix the problem they have created. They should have quit their land grabbing after the United Nations accepted Israel as a member state. The Occupation will destroy Israel.I am neither a Swiss banker nor an Israeli.I am asking you...As the Swiss bankers asked the next of kin of Jews gassed at Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Everyone knows who are the Palestinian refugees and their descendants. They have a right of return.
You really think that the time you're wasting with snarky answers actually HELPS the people who have 10 or 30 years in the refugee camps?
Figure out how to make BOTH sides happy. Figure out how to get people OUT of those camps. Or most of them. Sending them all to Israel is not gonna happen..
Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war..
It's" illegal" for Israel to keep the land but not " illegal" for the Arab Nations to initiate War, destroy and occupy" Israel? Not surprised at the mentality of the Palestinian
Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war..
Yes, Moldovan Jews can return to the former Soviet republic.Look up the definition of refugee, and explain how they are refugees because that doesn't seem to fit.It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
You keep pressing that argument as if it means something in the current situation. It is not a right of return issue. They are not refugees. It was Spains apology for expelling them, not an acknowledgement of indigenous rights.
I assume then that you would agree that at least the rest of the Jews deserve to return to their homeland by your logic?
Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war..
Yes, Moldovan Jews can return to the former Soviet republic.Look up the definition of refugee, and explain how they are refugees because that doesn't seem to fit.It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.My view is right of return only applie to those who had once actually lived in an area, not their descendants and the refugees need to be taken in by all involved states and given citizenship. They've been held hostage for too long.
You keep pressing that argument as if it means something in the current situation. It is not a right of return issue. They are not refugees. It was Spains apology for expelling them, not an acknowledgement of indigenous rights.
I assume then that you would agree that at least the rest of the Jews deserve to return to their homeland by your logic?
All refugees have a right of return.Yes, Moldovan Jews can return to the former Soviet republic.Look up the definition of refugee, and explain how they are refugees because that doesn't seem to fit.It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.The Sephardic Jews were taken in by Muslims and Latin Americans for centuries and that did not abrogate the right of return of their descendants to become Spanish citizens since 2015.
You keep pressing that argument as if it means something in the current situation. It is not a right of return issue. They are not refugees. It was Spains apology for expelling them, not an acknowledgement of indigenous rights.
I assume then that you would agree that at least the rest of the Jews deserve to return to their homeland by your logic?
Do Palestinian refugees who originated from Egypt have a right of return to Palestine?
All refugees have a right of return.Yes, Moldovan Jews can return to the former Soviet republic.Look up the definition of refugee, and explain how they are refugees because that doesn't seem to fit.It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.You keep pressing that argument as if it means something in the current situation. It is not a right of return issue. They are not refugees. It was Spains apology for expelling them, not an acknowledgement of indigenous rights.
I assume then that you would agree that at least the rest of the Jews deserve to return to their homeland by your logic?
Do Palestinian refugees who originated from Egypt have a right of return to Palestine?
Forgive me but I am not an expert.All refugees have a right of return.Yes, Moldovan Jews can return to the former Soviet republic.Look up the definition of refugee, and explain how they are refugees because that doesn't seem to fit.It is clear that the Spanish understand the status of refugees and the right of return of their descendants cannot be changed by the passage of time. The Israelis and some posters here have no such understanding.
I assume then that you would agree that at least the rest of the Jews deserve to return to their homeland by your logic?
Do Palestinian refugees who originated from Egypt have a right of return to Palestine?
You didn't actually answer the question.
That is true. However, back then it was not illegal. In the 20th century it was.Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.I agree Israel has dragged it's feet a bunch about the lands they ended up with after the 68 war..
Indeed, and it is illegal to acquire territory by war.
How silly. Just about every country, including the USA acquired territory by war.
That's how the Arabs took over Jewish land in Palestine, after Roman diaspora.
