Rustic
Diamond Member
- Oct 3, 2015
- 58,769
- 5,895
No reason for small rural states to vote in presidential elections without the EC... one major city would nullify all of their votes if there was just a popular vote. FactMore people in more states voted for trump... 30 as opposed to 20.And yet ---- you still can't explain why that would be.
Or why it's not "mob rule" when we elect a Governor.
Or a Senator.
Or a Congresscritter.
Or a mayor.
Or a city council.
Or a county commissioner.
Or a sheriff.
Or a judge.
Or a Commissioner of Paper Clips.
Or how a "mob rule" is even possible when everybody's got the same choices on the ballot.
But if you ever come up with an answer you be sure to run back here lickety-split.
Your argument is facetious AND fallacious (Now, THAT is a real twosome!).... it IS the same for the presidency as it is for those offices.
There is NO national election for president. It is 51 separate popular vote elections for the president. The winner of the popular vote in each state is awarded its electoral votes. The case COULD be made that the person who wins the most states gets to be president.
All the rest of your whining is based on your lack of knowledge ... so, it will simply be disregarded.
Actually what you "disregarded" here was the original point I was responding to, which you excised out.
Inconvenient, was it?
The poster (and I remember it even though it was like 2300 posts ago) tried to float the same canard about a popular vote being some kind of "mob rule", a phrase many parrots have parroted yet none can explain.
So I demonstrated that Governors, which are a microcosm of a President, are so elected, and no one cries "mob rule", because it isn't. Ditto Senators, Mayors, and County Commissioner of Paper Clips.
Easy to think you "won" an internet argument when you've removed the context it was addressing, innit.
Obviously it is decidedly *NOT* the same for the presidency as for those offices. THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT.
This country can't have crazy Cali determining the presidency… and survive through it.
true, but if you look at the voting map of Ca by county or congressional district, Trump wins more of them. The libs may be ramming their own petard up their own ass on this.
Congressional Districts are bullshit. Purposely engineered to give one party control. But regardless how the distribution was, something like four million Californians voted for Rump, and the EC will see to it that their vote is ignored. Therein lies the point.