The main vulnerability of the German troops

[rupol2000]

The army of the German type is an army of non-professional infantrymen lined up on a wide front in several echelons.

This type is used by all totalitarian regimes.

Totalitarian regimes were not accidentally afraid of a deep operation. This is a breakthrough of the front at a critical point, and striking at key infrastructure and command.

The weakest point is centralization. It makes no sense to go against a huge mass. A blow to the head kills the whole body. The army becomes an uncontrollable corpse.

 

[Bleipriester]

The army of the German type is an army of non-professional infantrymen lined up on a wide front in several echelons.

This type is used by all totalitarian regimes.

Totalitarian regimes were not accidentally afraid of a deep operation. This is a breakthrough of the front at a critical point, and striking at key infrastructure and command.

The weakest point is centralization. It makes no sense to go against a huge mass. A blow to the head kills the whole body. The army becomes an uncontrollable corpse.

Nonsense. The German army was incredibly effective in WWII. Almost no time when they were not outnumbered by a multitude of enemies, restricted by permanent shortages of gum, nickel, fuel and everything, yet the statistics are very clear. You see there is no time/theatre where the Germans suffered more casualties than the allies:

 

[rupol2000]

Nonsense. The German army was incredibly effective in WWII. Almost no time when they were not outnumbered by a multitude of enemies, restricted by permanent shortages of gum, nickel, fuel and everything, yet the statistics are very clear. You see there is no time/theatre where the Germans suffered more casualties than the allies:

In World War II there were 2 armies. The Wehrmacht were ordinary Prussian slaves, and the SS was the heir to the Austro-Hungarian cavalry.
Tank troops, aviation and other technical units were not German, they were brought there by the United States in the golden 20s.

 

[rupol2000]

German type

 

[Bleipriester]

In World War II there were 2 armies. The Wehrmacht were ordinary Prussian slaves, and the SS was the heir to the Austro-Hungarian cavalry.

Both untrue. While Prussia still existed and the tradition of aristocratic commanders lived in the Wehrmacht, this was even a good thing, it kept the NSDAP from taking over the army, the aristocrats didn´t like the NSDAP too much. The SS was an elite unit, only the fittest and tallest could join until 1944, when the requirements were reduced.

Tank troops, aviation and other technical units were not German, they were brought there by the United States in the golden 20s.

Total bullshit, you want to grab German art of engineering. In fact, the Germans secretly developed tanks with the Russians. You know, tank force and aviation where not allowed by the Versailles Treaty. During the time of the Versailles Treaty, the Germans had to share each patent with the allies, they massively profited from German engineering and ingenuity.

 

[Bleipriester]

View attachment 809017

German type

European. Like American war of secession.

 

[rupol2000]

European. Like American war of secession.

The main role in the American War was played by the Indians, organized by the French knightly families, cavalry, aristocrats of the sword.

Strictly speaking, the mass army is European, but this does not apply to such peoples as Poles, Romanians, Hungarians, and other peoples of cavalry and knightly blood. In modern times, this is the German strategy. This is a typical Prussian army of slaves. Earlier it was used by the Macedonians and the plebeian Rome.

 

[rupol2000]

While Prussia still existed and the tradition of aristocratic commanders

Prussia has never had real aristocrats since, maybe, the Teutonic Knights. They have always been merchants, priests and slave owners, all the court non-military caste of the nobles of Europe of the old order comes from them.

Their command is built on staff office workers, they have officials in command instead of the military.

 

[Bleipriester]

The main role in the American War was played by the Indians, organized by the French knightly families, cavalry, aristocrats of the sword.

Strictly speaking, the mass army is European, but this does not apply to such peoples as Poles, Romanians, Hungarians, and other peoples of cavalry and knightly blood. In modern times, this is the German strategy. This is a typical Prussian army of slaves. Earlier it was used by the Macedonians and the plebeian Rome.

I don´t know where you are taking such nonsense from. Unlike in the old times the Germans chose their strategy according to the situation in the modern era. For instance, if you are confronted by an enemy whose strategy was non-stop mass assaults without regard to losses, you have to adapt your strategy. It has to be a strategy that allows for maximum impact with minimal losses.

 

[rupol2000]

German art of engineering

There has never been German engineering. Everything that was there was from the USA, Poland, or Austria-Hungary.

Now, when America is leaving Germany, they are again sliding into slavery and mediocrity, they have destroyed the entire industry.

Germany was a slave agricultural country before the great Hungarian Revolution, and Prussia in general was almost in the Neolithic.

 

[rupol2000]

I don´t know where you are taking such nonsense from. Unlike in the old times the Germans chose their strategy according to the situation in the modern era.

There was only one strategy - a huge mass of hungry slaves lined up in front in several echelons. This is a classic Prussian strategy, which was also used by the Bolsheviks.

Professional troops were only on the Danube and in Poland.

 

[Bleipriester]

Prussia has never had real aristocrats since, maybe, the Teutonic Knights. They have always been merchants, priests and slave owners, all the court non-military caste of the nobles of Europe of the old order comes from them.

Their command is built on staff office workers, they have officials in command instead of the military.

While Prussia was still a feudal monarchy with low income jobs, it was a pioneer of renaissance, free society and even the first country to introduce compulsory education. Prussia defeated the Austrian led alliance in a month and finally, all German states asked the Prussian king to become the Kaiser of the unified Germany.

 

[rupol2000]

That's where the professionals were.
And all professional technical armies inherit from the cavalry.

 

[Bleipriester]

There has never been German engineering. Everything that was there was from the USA, Poland, or Austria-Hungary.

Now, when America is leaving Germany, they are again sliding into slavery and mediocrity, they have destroyed the entire industry.

Germany was a slave agricultural country before the great Hungarian Revolution, and Prussia in general was almost in the Neolithic.

Total BS. Austria was even part of Germany, parts of Poland too. Poland is now an artificial country, because it has been moved westwards. And the US was and is very productive but Germany too. You hate Germany, that is your motivation for such bullcrap threads, not history.

 

[rupol2000]

While Prussia was still a feudal monarchy with low income jobs, it was a pioneer of renaissance, free society and even the first country to introduce compulsory education. Prussia defeated the Austrian led alliance in a month and finally, all German states asked the Prussian king to become the Kaiser of the unified Germany.

Lies. The state of Wilhelm and Bismarck was the usual Prussian "welfare state" of totalitarianism and strict subordination. And it was they who strangled freedom in Europe, the Spring of Nations.

 

[rupol2000]

The Prussian martinet has always been and is still considered a model of stupidity and herd servility.

 

[rupol2000]

Total BS. Austria was even part of Germany, parts of Poland too. Poland is now an artificial country, because it has been moved westwards. And the US was and is very productive but Germany too. You hate Germany, that is your motivation for such bullcrap threads, not history.

Germany has long turned into a country of brothels, now they spit on German goods even in China. You live in the illusion of propaganda. There has been no German quality for a long time, only the disgustingness of the German burghers remains.

 

[whitehall]

Ike was willing to put a million Troops in France if that's what it took. The problem for the Germans is that they ran out of soldiers.

 

[Zincwarrior]

The army of the German type is an army of non-professional infantrymen lined up on a wide front in several echelons.

This type is used by all totalitarian regimes.

Totalitarian regimes were not accidentally afraid of a deep operation. This is a breakthrough of the front at a critical point, and striking at key infrastructure and command.

The weakest point is centralization. It makes no sense to go against a huge mass. A blow to the head kills the whole body. The army becomes an uncontrollable corpse.

What is your timeframe of discussion?

 

[rupol2000]

What is your timeframe of discussion?

All times.
I do not mean by "Germans" Celts, knights, Polish horsemen or Scandinavian warriors.