Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

[Aries]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

 

[brummelben]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

So if you don't like the outcome, just change the rules, right Einstein? maybe he just needs to eliminate the entire court system and rule by decree?

 

[depotoo]

Honey, you need a course in Constitutional law.


The Ninth Circuit is the most overturned appeals court in the United States.. In total numbers, that is correct. From wiki
And
http://www.americanbar.org/content/...azine/LandslideJan2010_Hofer.authcheckdam.pdf

It's not sad when he wants a court that follows the law rather than one that rewrites it.

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Just because you have never read our Constitution doesn't mean they're making up laws.

 

[depotoo]

Just because you don't like it doesn't mean it is debunked, dear. From wiki
The Ninth Circuit is the most overturned appeals court in the United States.. In total numbers, that is correct.
http://www.americanbar.org/content/...azine/LandslideJan2010_Hofer.authcheckdam.pdf

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

 

[Doc1]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

You missed where I said I had been corrected, they are the SECOND most over turned Court in the Nation standing at 79%. Are you proud of that kid?

 

[Aries]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

You missed where I said I had been corrected, they are the SECOND most over turned Court in the Nation standing at 79%. Are you proud of that kid?

Still wrong that chart puts them at 3rd. Go have another coffee.

 

[Doc1]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

You missed where I said I had been corrected, they are the SECOND most over turned Court in the Nation standing at 79%. Are you proud of that kid?

Still wrong that chart puts them at 3rd. Go have another coffee.

LOL, nope. Like most Lefty's you want to play "dueling" sources. That's fine but only an idiot would defend ANY over turned as much as they be is first, second or third.

 

[Aries]

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

You missed where I said I had been corrected, they are the SECOND most over turned Court in the Nation standing at 79%. Are you proud of that kid?

Still wrong that chart puts them at 3rd. Go have another coffee.

LOL, nope. Like most Lefty's you want to play "dueling" sources. That's fine but only an idiot would defend ANY over turned as much as they be is first, second or third.

Only an idiot would support trunp breaking up courts because they are making sure he doesn't break the constitution. If you think the BS he tried to legislate through EOs is perfectly legal, what're you scared of? Let it go to the courts and we shall see

 

[2aguy]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Yep......it would be nice if they could just appoint a brand new set of judges for the new Circuit......

 

[2aguy]

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

You missed where I said I had been corrected, they are the SECOND most over turned Court in the Nation standing at 79%. Are you proud of that kid?

Still wrong that chart puts them at 3rd. Go have another coffee.

LOL, nope. Like most Lefty's you want to play "dueling" sources. That's fine but only an idiot would defend ANY over turned as much as they be is first, second or third.

Only an idiot would support trunp breaking up courts because they are making sure he doesn't break the constitution. If you think the BS he tried to legislate through EOs is perfectly legal, what're you scared of? Let it go to the courts and we shall see

The only ones screwing with the Constitution is the 9th circuit and these left wing activists in robes blocking his legitimate executive branch powers...

 

[EvilCat Breath]

There has been talk of breaking up the 9th for years. Now that there is a Republican government maybe they can do it.

 

[Wry Catcher]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Nice Excuse. Let's be honest and acknowledge this is worse than FDR's effort to pack the Supreme Court. Once upon a time Republicans and the Democrats both supported reigning in an Imperial Presidency.

See: A Question of Power: The Imperial Presidency

From the link above:
When James Madison shaped a new constitutional system for the United States, he and his fellow framers had one overriding fear: tyranny.

They wanted to divide power between three branches and create lines of separation that prevented the concentration of power in any single branch. The framers based their ideas on an understanding of human nature – and human weakness. They tried to create a system in which ambition would check ambition. However, they knew that citizens can be distracted or deceived into giving up their very freedom. Madison warned future generations that “if Tyranny and Oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy.” The framers knew how effective fear can be to induce citizens to give up their liberties. Recent years have proven them once again prophetic in their warnings.

To this day, many Americans misunderstand the separation of powers as simply a division of authority between three branches of government. In fact, it was intended as a protection not of institutional but of individual rights, by preventing any branch from assuming enough power to become tyrannical. No branch is supposed to have enough power to govern alone. Once power becomes concentrated in the hands of a president, citizens are left only with the assurance that such unchecked power will be used wisely – a Faustian bargain the framers repeatedly warned us never to accept. Benjamin Franklin said it best when he warned that “they who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”

Read the full article at the link above.


For futher thought provoking reading:
The Imperial Presidency

 

[kiwiman127]

Trump is trying to compromise the Judicial, because he disagrees with their rulings.
If Congress doesn't pass enough of Trump's wishes, will he try to compromise Congress?
Trump is attacking one of the three branches of government because his over-inflated ego can't accept the fact that he is wrong and he isn't man enough to accept he isn't perfect.
Trump is attacking the Constitution and his ass clowns are eating it all up.

 

[Ame®icano]

Fucking idiots


No, 9th Circuit isn't 'most overturned court in the country'


6th Circuit - 87 percent;

11th Circuit - 85 percent;

9th Circuit - 79 percent;

3rd Circuit - 78 percent;

2nd Circuit and Federal Circuit - 68 percent;

8th Circuit - 67 percent;

5th Circuit - 66 percent;

7th Circuit - 48 percent;

DC Circuit - 45 percent;

1st Circuit and 4th Circuit - 43 percent;

10th Circuit - 42 percent.

By looking at percentages only, that's correct.

However, 9th circuit gets far more cases than any other circuit, and if you look at the number of cases overturned, the 9th circuit is a shame.

Supreme Court Reversal Rates

 

[EvilCat Breath]

Trump is attacking nothing. This started with two senators and is supported by six. Trump agreed with Jeff Sessions and John McCain. Trump is certainly not the first president who saw the necessity of breaking up the 9th and it doesn't compromise the court anymore than the court was compromised any of the other times a district was split.

 

[Marion Morrison]

I think the problem is that when Obama was in office, he packed the courts with appointed judges of his choosing to skew things.

List of federal judges appointed by Barack Obama - Wikipedia

 

[Dont Taz Me Bro]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Nice Excuse. Let's be honest and acknowledge this is worse than FDR's effort to pack the Supreme Court. Once upon a time Republicans and the Democrats both supported reigning in an Imperial Presidency.

See: A Question of Power: The Imperial Presidency

From the link above:
When James Madison shaped a new constitutional system for the United States, he and his fellow framers had one overriding fear: tyranny.

They wanted to divide power between three branches and create lines of separation that prevented the concentration of power in any single branch. The framers based their ideas on an understanding of human nature – and human weakness. They tried to create a system in which ambition would check ambition. However, they knew that citizens can be distracted or deceived into giving up their very freedom. Madison warned future generations that “if Tyranny and Oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy.” The framers knew how effective fear can be to induce citizens to give up their liberties. Recent years have proven them once again prophetic in their warnings.

To this day, many Americans misunderstand the separation of powers as simply a division of authority between three branches of government. In fact, it was intended as a protection not of institutional but of individual rights, by preventing any branch from assuming enough power to become tyrannical. No branch is supposed to have enough power to govern alone. Once power becomes concentrated in the hands of a president, citizens are left only with the assurance that such unchecked power will be used wisely – a Faustian bargain the framers repeatedly warned us never to accept. Benjamin Franklin said it best when he warned that “they who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”

Read the full article at the link above.


For futher thought provoking reading:
The Imperial Presidency

As I stated in an earlier post, breaking up of the ninth circuit has been discussed for over a decade. Trumps motivation may be purely partisan, but that doesn't mean it's wrong

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

This needed to happen years ago, mainly because the 9th Circuit has case load roughly 30% higher than the other circuit courts due to the population boom here in the west the last several decades.

Exclusive interview: Trump 'absolutely' looking at breaking up 9th Circuit

Sadly, Trump would like to break up the 9th circuit for other reasons, not caseload.

Yeah, like their complete disregard for the law?

 

[whitehall]

The 9th circuit has not only 30% more cases but it has a 79% higher reversal number than any other court of appeals. So far it holds the record for 5 unanimous reversals in a row. So why is the 9th at odds with the Supreme Count? The short answer is that the 9th no longer depends on the U.S. Constitution. The Court decides cases on the basis of emotion and political expediency.

 

[Doc1]

Well sure, they are the most over turned Court in the Nation.

That's already been debunked. Stop the fake news.

You missed where I said I had been corrected, they are the SECOND most over turned Court in the Nation standing at 79%. Are you proud of that kid?

Still wrong that chart puts them at 3rd. Go have another coffee.

LOL, nope. Like most Lefty's you want to play "dueling" sources. That's fine but only an idiot would defend ANY over turned as much as they be is first, second or third.

Only an idiot would support trunp breaking up courts because they are making sure he doesn't break the constitution. If you think the BS he tried to legislate through EOs is perfectly legal, what're you scared of? Let it go to the courts and we shall see

Afraid of? Nothing now. I face no more Combat, and we've already gotten my wife's biopsy results back. It's all good. There's no reason to keep a group of public servants together when their work keeps having to done over by more competent people.