YouTube is now deleting history because "hate speech"

[Bush92]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Are they going to ban videos promoting Antifa and Black Lives Matter hate speech.

 

[BlueGin]

I have a feeling this is going to backfire. I was watching a video earlier where some of the smaller channels are going to start lawsuits. Some of these guys do videos for a living and this VOX crap is threatening their livelihood.

Not a good look for libs to use big corporations to stifle free speech.

 

[Bush92]

YouTube is not the repository of "history". It CANNOT therefore "delete" any. Get a grip.

It's the 2nd most visited website on the planet. Read between the lines and stop being a fucking brainlet.

I don't give a flying fuck how "visited" it is. McDonald's sells a skillion cardboard-burgers, doesn't make it "food" because "volume". That's not even an argument.

The point stands. The yahoos who put a "funny" on that point without disputing it are not about to convince anybody that the Mark Dices and the Prager "U"s and the Alex John Brinkley Joneses are any kind of "history".

History lives in BOOKS.

Liberals don’t read books, they let CNN and Democratic Party tell them what to think.

 

[C_Clayton_Jones]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Nonsense.

YouTube isn’t ‘deleting history’ – the notion is a lie and nothing but rightwing demagoguery.

And what YouTube does or doesn’t do with regard to editing content has nothing to do with ‘leftists.’

 

[Deplorable Yankee]

Start moving your content to bitchute. You'll be forced to eventually anyway so start now.

I posted a history teacher on one of mind wars threads .The poor guy was beside himself..he couldnt understand why they banned him . he was a sleepy normie. He didnt understand its progressive corporate McCarthyism

Theyre worse The left are authortarian NAZIS

BitChute @BitChute
We're adding more processing capacity, there's a bit of a mass exodus from YT atm and everyone is trying to back up years worth of content.

Very good news! People will continue to use youtube because that's where the content is, and that's where the eyeballs currently go. But we have to move content to another platform and start directing people there.

very true sir
Site like this and others should make it easy to embed a video form bitchute
That would probably help them along

 

[C_Clayton_Jones]

YouTube is not the repository of "history". It CANNOT therefore "delete" any. Get a grip.

It's the 2nd most visited website on the planet. Read between the lines and stop being a fucking brainlet.

This is yet another example of the right’s ridiculous, unwarranted effort to demonize internet hosting sites conservatives incorrectly perceive to be ‘liberal’ and ‘opposed’ to conservative views – when in fact nothing could be further from the truth.

 

[ColonelAngus]

This is what happens when you start hysterically censoring people.

Collateral damage

 

[Deplorable Yankee]

YouTube is not the repository of "history". It CANNOT therefore "delete" any. Get a grip.

It's the 2nd most visited website on the planet. Read between the lines and stop being a fucking brainlet.

I don't give a flying fuck how "visited" it is. McDonald's sells a skillion cardboard-burgers, doesn't make it "food" because "volume". That's not even an argument.

The point stands. The yahoos who put a "funny" on that point without disputing it are not about to convince anybody that the Mark Dices and the Prager "U"s and the Alex John Brinkley Joneses are any kind of "history".

History lives in BOOKS.

You really are a fucking tool.

The medium of how history is stored/relayed changes over time, idiot. There's a reason we don't cave paint in animal blood and chisel things in stone anymore - we created more efficient ways of storing and disseminating information. Now that we're in a digital age we're doing it again. Denial of this is patently absurd... but I'd expect nothing less from a dumb ass leftist.

Pogo's an anti-civilization leftist. If books were being burned, he'd say, "what's the big deal. We still have our history on all these cave walls!"

Whenever a moron lefttard says it no big deal theyre either complete idiots or like for some "the issue is never the issue the issue is the revolution" .

this is So gonna help the left with all the normies who get nailed

keep screaming its no big deal
maybe banned and demonetized normies WHO didnt do a damn thing wrong wont notice

 

[WheelieAddict]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Very Orwellian. Sounds like shit North Korea and Iran would do.

Nope. North Korea tightly controls all information. The US allows freedom of information. Just because a non government website in the US chooses to block vile content doesnt make it "like North Korea". It's a dumbass argument. Should fox news be forced to allow stalinist propaganda on its website? Yes or no?

 

[Deplorable Yankee]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Are they going to ban videos promoting Antifa and Black Lives Matter hate speech.

LOl yeah right
Then watch the useful idiots scream about free speech

WIth BLM they'd get to use their favorite word to ...that would be racist!

 

[WheelieAddict]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Nonsense.

YouTube isn’t ‘deleting history’ – the notion is a lie and nothing but rightwing demagoguery.

And what YouTube does or doesn’t do with regard to editing content has nothing to do with ‘leftists.’

What this is really about is of course money. The alt right has infected youtube with a bunch of vile content and propaganda. People have complained to youtube's advertisers about it-does your company promote this crap? Youtube is reacting to retain advertising revenue.

 

[Deplorable Yankee]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Very Orwellian. Sounds like shit North Korea and Iran would do.

Nope. North Korea tightly controls all information. The US allows freedom of information. Just because a non government website in the US chooses to block vile content doesnt make it "like North Korea". It's a dumbass argument. Should fox news be forced to allow stalinist propaganda on its website? Yes or no?

\
How is a history teachers vids that was being used by other teachers VILE ?Finally Christan bakers dont have to bake vile gay cakes if they dont want to? . Thanks for that

Who is defining what is and isnt vile ? We already know the answer to that question .

So are they a tech company or now a publisher since they're controlling content ?

Technology company? Publisher? The lines can no longer be blurred | Emily Bell
Sir Martin Sorrell, chairman of the world’s largest advertising agency, WPP, put it like this: “We have always said Google, Facebook and others are media companies and have the same responsibilities as any other media company ... They cannot masquerade as technology companies, particularly when they place advertisements.”

It could equally be argued that they are not “masquerading” as technology companies. They are, after all, stuffed to the primary-coloured rafters with the world’s finest technologists, and they do really believe themselves to be “technology” companies. But it’s hard to deny that they are also publishers. Social platforms including Google, Facebook, Snapchat and Twitter monetise, host, distribute, produce and even in some cases commission material.

 

[CrusaderFrank]

Break up Google, make them cough out YouTube.

 

[WheelieAddict]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Very Orwellian. Sounds like shit North Korea and Iran would do.

Nope. North Korea tightly controls all information. The US allows freedom of information. Just because a non government website in the US chooses to block vile content doesnt make it "like North Korea". It's a dumbass argument. Should fox news be forced to allow stalinist propaganda on its website? Yes or no?

\
How is a history teachers vids that was being used by other teachers VILE ?Finally Christan bakers dont have to bake vile gay cakes if they dont want to? . Thanks for that

Who is defining what is and isnt vile ? We already know the answer to that question .

So are they a tech company or now a publisher since they're controlling content ?

Technology company? Publisher? The lines can no longer be blurred | Emily Bell
Sir Martin Sorrell, chairman of the world’s largest advertising agency, WPP, put it like this: “We have always said Google, Facebook and others are media companies and have the same responsibilities as any other media company ... They cannot masquerade as technology companies, particularly when they place advertisements.”

It could equally be argued that they are not “masquerading” as technology companies. They are, after all, stuffed to the primary-coloured rafters with the world’s finest technologists, and they do really believe themselves to be “technology” companies. But it’s hard to deny that they are also publishers. Social platforms including Google, Facebook, Snapchat and Twitter monetise, host, distribute, produce and even in some cases commission material.

You'd have to ask youtube. Fox news hosts, distributes, produces, and in even some cases commisssions material. Should they be forced to host content they don't approve of?

 

[C_Clayton_Jones]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Nonsense.

YouTube isn’t ‘deleting history’ – the notion is a lie and nothing but rightwing demagoguery.

And what YouTube does or doesn’t do with regard to editing content has nothing to do with ‘leftists.’

What this is really about is of course money. The alt right has infected youtube with a bunch of vile content and propaganda. People have complained to youtube's advertisers about it-does your company promote this crap? Youtube is reacting to retain advertising revenue.

And whatever the motive or motives, all this is occurring in the realm of the private sector, where private hosting sites, private search engines, and private social media entities are at complete liberty to edit their content with impunity.

Indeed, no history is being ‘deleted’ – there are ample resources available online to access all manner of content, including content concerning Hitler.

 

[G.T.]

YouTube is not the repository of "history". It CANNOT therefore "delete" any. Get a grip.

It's the 2nd most visited website on the planet. Read between the lines and stop being a fucking brainlet.

I don't give a flying fuck how "visited" it is. McDonald's sells a skillion cardboard-burgers, doesn't make it "food" because "volume". That's not even an argument.

The point stands. The yahoos who put a "funny" on that point without disputing it are not about to convince anybody that the Mark Dices and the Prager "U"s and the Alex John Brinkley Joneses are any kind of "history".

History lives in BOOKS.

I agree with your premise...but McDonald's is a poor analogy.

I don't eat it because I stay fit like a God with a capital G...but what makes something FOOD is that people eat it, it's got calories and they like it. And McDonald's...it's fuckin' delicious. That elitist snobby snooty shit is trash.

 

[RoshawnMarkwees]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Very Orwellian. Sounds like shit North Korea and Iran would do.

Nope. North Korea tightly controls all information. The US allows freedom of information. Just because a non government website in the US chooses to block vile content doesnt make it "like North Korea". It's a dumbass argument. Should fox news be forced to allow stalinist propaganda on its website? Yes or no?

\
How is a history teachers vids that was being used by other teachers VILE ?Finally Christan bakers dont have to bake vile gay cakes if they dont want to? . Thanks for that

Who is defining what is and isnt vile ? We already know the answer to that question .

So are they a tech company or now a publisher since they're controlling content ?

Technology company? Publisher? The lines can no longer be blurred | Emily Bell
Sir Martin Sorrell, chairman of the world’s largest advertising agency, WPP, put it like this: “We have always said Google, Facebook and others are media companies and have the same responsibilities as any other media company ... They cannot masquerade as technology companies, particularly when they place advertisements.”

It could equally be argued that they are not “masquerading” as technology companies. They are, after all, stuffed to the primary-coloured rafters with the world’s finest technologists, and they do really believe themselves to be “technology” companies. But it’s hard to deny that they are also publishers. Social platforms including Google, Facebook, Snapchat and Twitter monetise, host, distribute, produce and even in some cases commission material.

You'd have to ask youtube. Fox news hosts, distributes, produces, and in even some cases commisssions material. Should they be forced to host content they don't approve of?

Are they virtually the only channel on TV?

 

[G.T.]

Quotes:

"YouTube announced new rules around hate speech on Wednesday that prohibit videos promoting Nazi ideology or denying the existence of the Holocaust or other well-documented violent events like the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School. Thousands of channels are expected to be shut down. But now multiple teachers are complaining that videos uploaded to educate people about Nazi history have been deleted, the Guardian reported."

"Scott Allsop, who owns the longrunning MrAllsopHistory revision website and teaches at an international school in Romania, had his channel featuring hundreds of historical clips on topics ranging from the Norman conquest to the cold war deleted for breaching the rules that ban hate speech."

"Richard Jones-Nerzic, another British teacher affected by the crackdown, suggested YouTube’s policy did not take into account the extent to which the history syllabus focused on the second world war.

“Modern world study and Hitler in particular have dominated the history curriculum in the UK over the last 25 years,” he said, explaining that he had been censured for uploading clips to his channel from old documentaries about the rise of nazism."

YouTube is deleting videos on Nazi history as part of its hate speech crackdown

YouTube blocks history teachers uploading archive videos of Hitler


This is what happens when you start dictating who is allowed to speak and what they are allowed to speak about - erasure of history and ensuring that the bloody cycle of freedom --> bondage happens AGAIN. Thank your local leftist snowflake.

Nonsense.

YouTube isn’t ‘deleting history’ – the notion is a lie and nothing but rightwing demagoguery.

And what YouTube does or doesn’t do with regard to editing content has nothing to do with ‘leftists.’

What this is really about is of course money. The alt right has infected youtube with a bunch of vile content and propaganda. People have complained to youtube's advertisers about it-does your company promote this crap? Youtube is reacting to retain advertising revenue.

And whatever the motive or motives, all this is occurring in the realm of the private sector, where private hosting sites, private search engines, and private social media entities are at complete liberty to edit their content with impunity.

Indeed, no history is being ‘deleted’ – there are ample resources available online to access all manner of content, including content concerning Hitler.

It's really weird that conservatives want social media entitlements. What Universe is this...

 

[WheelieAddict]

Fox news website has to allow my video that proclaims trump is a nazi android, his wife is a tranny, republicans did 911, and that conservatives are all involved in a pedophile conspiracy. This must be allowed or we are just like north korea.

 

[RoshawnMarkwees]

Fox news website has to allow my video that proclaims trump is a nazi android, his wife is a tranny, republicans did 911, and that conservatives are all involved in a pedophile conspiracy. This must be allowed or we are just like north korea.

Why? You can already get all of that on MSNBC, NPR, PBS, CBS, ABC, CNN, etc.