Olde Europe
Diamond Member
- Dec 8, 2014
- 6,025
- 4,523
- 2,065
We are, as a matter of pure and simple fact, presently in stage 4 of Robert Paxton's Five Stages of Fascism. We are not "headed" anywhere. We are in the middle of an evolving process that results in iterative change between different stages. Fascism, like any political ideology, does not work like a light switch. Fascism doesn't just show up one day. You don't cross a line and suddenly become fascist. Fascism as an ideology has existed within the American political spectrum for a long time, and American fascists--who believe in the philosophical underpinnings of fascism, regardless of what they call themselves--have existed for just as long.
Interesting, thanks.
You should also mention that your diagnosis deviates in important respects from what Paxton outlined. Most notably, fascism is supposed to create a movement, and then to form its own party in order to acquire power via electoral success. You seem to have either dismissed that aspect, or changed Paxton's stages insofar as that movement - presumably the Tea Party movement - didn't form a party, but infested the GOP. That also requires that thereafter, the usual alliances with conservative big wigs of other parties didn't happen in the way Paxton outlined. Rather, the conservative GOP elites accommodated the crazies after a short and meek struggle, and, also presumably, the struggle over who controls the GOP is still ongoing, even while Trump nominally stands at the helm and exercises power.
I also agree that the basic ideological ingredients are present, and have been for a long time, within the "American political spectrum", most notably nationalism, militarism, disregard and contempt for intellectualism, the glorification of will and self-assertion over reasonable persuasion, contempt for liberal democracy and compromise, contempt for a broad variety of minorities throughout history, and depicting the white majority as victims of these minorities, which in turn is supposed to justify whichever measures are deemed necessary to fight back.