Humanity
Gold Member
- Jul 17, 2014
- 5,089
- 361
- Thread starter
- #141
America and Israel are different. Just because Israel has westen characteristic aspect, it doesn't mean anything American should be found in Israel.
I agree. I'm just explaining where my perspective comes from. Every country has the right to govern itself as it's people see's fit. I don't dispute that. I just think this new law is a bad idea given Israel's minorities and peculiar divisions of citizenship.
I disagree. It doesn't go against the constitutional law of Human freedom, life and dignity. It must go hand in hand with the previous basic law. If it went against it, of course I would agree it's awful. But honestly, if the social rights of Israeli minority can be kept, the objection will be purely out of populist and shallow reasons.
Which is exactly the case in here. Because who goes against that? Livni and Hetzog, both almost didn't cross the threashold of the voters' election, both dreaming of being the next PM. It's laughable. I didn't vote Netanyahu, I think he's bad for us, but it pisses me off the nonstopping attempt to cause a political crisis just to bring him down. It's horrible for the people of Israel, who voted fairly for who they wanted.
And it even more laughable that Tzipi Livni talked about democracy, when two weeks ago she voted for closing a free newspaper, "Israel Today". Isn't closing a newspaper out of political reasons, the core of anti-democracy? What's up with THAT crap?
Lipush - I applaud your honesty... I applaud your beliefs...
There are a lot of IF's about this new bill... After all only a limited number have seen it, know the full extent of the bill and it is NOT in the interests of Netanyahu for it to become public until it's law!
One has to consider the thoughts and views of those, who have knowledge of the bill, within the cabinet, who have expressed grave concern over it...
The scant details of this bill that ARE in the public domain are, worrying.
I'm with you on this one... IF there is NO change in the rights of the minorities in Israel, regardless of religion, colour or creed then fine...
The question has to be, if the bill changes NOTHING then why have it? Why not keep the status quo?
My concern is that it's just a step on the downward ladder into something that will, ultimately, become a monster that cannot be controlled.
Provided that the bill does not go against the Israel Declaration of Independence, which I fear it will, then, again, I see little point in the bill.
Tzipi Livni voting to close a 'free newspaper' is highly undemocratic... I am unclear on what grounds that decision was taken... However, Israel Today is a right leaning newspaper that has little time for center or left of center politics.
I hope that you are right Lipush... I too hope that there is no real change to the minorities within Israel...