TheGreatGatsby
Gold Member
Good point.
All I'm saying is this:
If you can hit the ball a long way and it goes over the fence, you have a home run. Umpires can't take that away.
If you beat the ball to first base, 99.5% of the time, you're safe. Umpires can't take that away.
If you drop the ball in the outfield, it's an error and umpires don't call the batter out.
But when you're a pitcher, borderline calls that you're not getting force you to lob the ball over the plate. If the ball is too high, you have to toss it lower...if the ball is judged to be too low, you have to throw it higher. This is a judgment call made by an umpire hundreds of times a game.
Maddux and Glavine got 3-6 inches outside the plate consistently.
Hundreds of white pitchers didn't get the calls Glavine and Maddux got either, I know.
Mariano Rivera gets 3-6 inches outside the plate consistently. How do you explain that?
![]()
Many times it's the movement on the pitch and the perception it gives umpires. Great pitchers make the balls look like strikes and the strikes look like balls.
Disagree. Spotting where a ball crosses a plate is pretty easy to do. I disagree that Glavine, Maddux, Rivera routinely got 3-6 inches. But if they got 1-3 inches it is because they were consistent and umps are less inclined to reward wild pitchers.
Also, MLB give umps a remarkable amount of latitude when it comes to being assholes. When Doug Eddings effectively robbed the Angels of a World Series appearance in 05; they didn't even take him out of the rotation.
In many cases, you'll get umps that call b.s. so that they can move a game along and get out to the club before it gets too late.