How often have Palestinians been offered a state?

[USAF 2023]

https://www.quora.com/How-often-have-the-Palestinians-been-offered-their-own-state

They don't want their own State. They want Israel

 

[Boston1]

That pretty well sums it up.

First thing that happened with the British mandated area for the creation of a Jewish National Homeland was that ~75% was given to the Arabs. Then Gaza was given to the Arabs, another what 5% and now the pally's want a third state, carved out of Israel.

 

[Roudy]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

These Arabs didn't even call themselves "Palestinians" until Israel was established and they wanted it, too.

 

[rylah]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Arabs in Palestine had no problem proclaiming to be subjects of King Faisal from Mecca.
Or ask to be ruled by Jordan or Syria.

Independence is not the goal.

 

[P F Tinmore]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

 

[Hossfly]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

Oh, yeah? So WTF have they accomplished since 1948?

 

[P F Tinmore]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

Oh, yeah? So WTF have they accomplished since 1948?

Is deflection all you have?

 

[Indeependent]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

Sure...Anything that disagrees with your demented pov is Israeli bullshit.
Even the Arabs in the UN are spreading Israeli bullshit.

 

[Hossfly]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

Oh, yeah? So WTF have they accomplished since 1948?

Is deflection all you have?

Not deflecting Tin Whistle. In 69 years what attempts have they made to have a working government and have peace with their neighbors? Oh, and act civilized.

 

[Indeependent]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

Oh, yeah? So WTF have they accomplished since 1948?

Is deflection all you have?

Is revisionist history all you have?
Not that it makes a difference at this point in time as you lost.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

Oh, yeah? So WTF have they accomplished since 1948?

Well,you certainly can't ignore the great strides they have made in the field of suicide vest technology.

 

[teddyearp]

Oh, yeah? So WTF have they accomplished since 1948?

Is deflection all you have?

What deflection? It was perfectly on topic. Why are you trying to deflect and then say others are?

Something I've noticed. When you see a news show where they interview somebody(s) on this topic, am I the only one that sees the Anti-Israel (supposedly pro-palestinian) side always not be able to directly answer any direct question? It seems as though they always have to say, but, but, but it's really like this.

End the 'occupation', free and fair elections, get the filthy Jews (and Christians, and Druze) out, and then we'll be happy.

 

[Roudy]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

No Bullstien, after their failed attempt to destroy the newly formed Jewish state in 1948, the Jordanian and Egyptian Arabs "occupied" and abused the Belestinians for 20 years, during which time not a peep from any Belestinian OR Arab. You know the history Tinhead....

 

[P F Tinmore]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

No Bullstien, after their failed attempt to destroy the newly formed Jewish state in 1948, the Jordanian and Egyptian Arabs "occupied" and abused the Belestinians for 20 years, during which time not a peep from any Belestinian OR Arab. You know the history Tinhead....

CABLEGRAM DATED 28 SEPTEMBER 1948 FROM THE PREMIER AND
ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT
TO THE SECRETARY-GENERAL CONCERNING
CONSTITUTION OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT

I HAVE THE HONOR TO INFORM YOUR EXCELLENCY THAT IN VIRTUE OF THE NATURAL RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE OF PALESTINE FOR SELF-DETERMINATION WHICH PRINCIPLE IS SUPPORTED BY THE CHARTERS OF THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS, THE UNITED NATIONS AND OTHERS AND IN VIEW OF THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE OVER PALESTINE WHICH HAD PREVENTED THE ARABS FROM EXERCISING THEIR INDEPENDENCE, THE ARABS OF PALESTINE WHO ARE THE OWNERS OF THE COUNTRY AND ITS INDIGENOUS INHABITANTS AND WHO CONSTITUTE THE GREAT MAJORITY OF ITS LEGAL POPULATION HAVE SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO DECLARE PALESTINE IN ITS ENTIRETY AND WITHIN ITS BOUNDARIES AS ESTABLISHED BEFORE THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE AN INDEPENDENT STATE AND CONSTITUTED A GOVERNMENT UNDER THE NAME OF THE ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT DERIVING ITS AUTHORITY FROM A REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL BASED ON DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES AND AIMING TO SAFEGUARD THE RIGHTS OF MINORITIES AND FOREIGNERS PROTECT THE HOLY PLACES AND GUARANTEE FREEDOM OF WORSHIP TO ALL COMMUNITIES

AHMED HILMI PASHA
PREMIER AND ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY

Who Are The Palestinians?

 

[USAF 2023]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

So what happened in 1948? Gaza, the W. Bank and E. Jerusalem were part of Egypt and Jordan prior to ‘67. Where was their “ state” then? There will be no response

 

[USAF 2023]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

Sure...Anything that disagrees with your demented pov is Israeli bullshit.
Even the Arabs in the UN are spreading Israeli bullshit.

Where was “ Palestine” before 1967? Notice how the initial thread isn’t addressed?

 

[Roudy]

This is religious war disguised as a territorial war. It's quite obvious. If so called Palestinians were living under Muslim "occupation" as they did between 1948 to 1967 under Jordan and Egypt, there would not be a peep from ANYBODY about a so called Palestinian state or an occupation, as there wasn't. The entire Palestinian identity and movement was formed as a way to remove Jewish control from their ancestral, religious, and cultural homeland.

Israeli bullshit, of course. The Palestinians declared independence in 1948.

No Bullstien, after their failed attempt to destroy the newly formed Jewish state in 1948, the Jordanian and Egyptian Arabs "occupied" and abused the Belestinians for 20 years, during which time not a peep from any Belestinian OR Arab. You know the history Tinhead....

CABLEGRAM DATED 28 SEPTEMBER 1948 FROM THE PREMIER AND
ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT
TO THE SECRETARY-GENERAL CONCERNING
CONSTITUTION OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT

I HAVE THE HONOR TO INFORM YOUR EXCELLENCY THAT IN VIRTUE OF THE NATURAL RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE OF PALESTINE FOR SELF-DETERMINATION WHICH PRINCIPLE IS SUPPORTED BY THE CHARTERS OF THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS, THE UNITED NATIONS AND OTHERS AND IN VIEW OF THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE OVER PALESTINE WHICH HAD PREVENTED THE ARABS FROM EXERCISING THEIR INDEPENDENCE, THE ARABS OF PALESTINE WHO ARE THE OWNERS OF THE COUNTRY AND ITS INDIGENOUS INHABITANTS AND WHO CONSTITUTE THE GREAT MAJORITY OF ITS LEGAL POPULATION HAVE SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO DECLARE PALESTINE IN ITS ENTIRETY AND WITHIN ITS BOUNDARIES AS ESTABLISHED BEFORE THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE AN INDEPENDENT STATE AND CONSTITUTED A GOVERNMENT UNDER THE NAME OF THE ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT DERIVING ITS AUTHORITY FROM A REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL BASED ON DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES AND AIMING TO SAFEGUARD THE RIGHTS OF MINORITIES AND FOREIGNERS PROTECT THE HOLY PLACES AND GUARANTEE FREEDOM OF WORSHIP TO ALL COMMUNITIES

AHMED HILMI PASHA
PREMIER AND ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY

Who Are The Palestinians?

What a lame diversion! A "declaration" by a party who never controlled the state in history doesn't make a state. ISIS also declared an Islamic state, so they should get one, eh? The greedy Arabs who weren't in control of the land, wrote to the British, who conquered the land from the Ottoman's requesting that the Jews not be given a state.

Now what does all of this have to do with with the fact that it was the Arab countries that "occupied" the West Bank and Gaza for 20 years, yet not a peep about this mythical Palestine from either the occupied or the occupiers.

History and facts always blow up your arguments.

 

[abi]

CABLEGRAM DATED 28 SEPTEMBER 1948 FROM THE PREMIER AND
ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT
TO THE SECRETARY-GENERAL CONCERNING
CONSTITUTION OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT

I HAVE THE HONOR TO INFORM YOUR EXCELLENCY THAT IN VIRTUE OF THE NATURAL RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE OF PALESTINE FOR SELF-DETERMINATION WHICH PRINCIPLE IS SUPPORTED BY THE CHARTERS OF THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS, THE UNITED NATIONS AND OTHERS AND IN VIEW OF THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE OVER PALESTINE WHICH HAD PREVENTED THE ARABS FROM EXERCISING THEIR INDEPENDENCE, THE ARABS OF PALESTINE WHO ARE THE OWNERS OF THE COUNTRY AND ITS INDIGENOUS INHABITANTS AND WHO CONSTITUTE THE GREAT MAJORITY OF ITS LEGAL POPULATION HAVE SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO DECLARE PALESTINE IN ITS ENTIRETY AND WITHIN ITS BOUNDARIES AS ESTABLISHED BEFORE THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE AN INDEPENDENT STATE AND CONSTITUTED A GOVERNMENT UNDER THE NAME OF THE ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT DERIVING ITS AUTHORITY FROM A REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL BASED ON DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES AND AIMING TO SAFEGUARD THE RIGHTS OF MINORITIES AND FOREIGNERS PROTECT THE HOLY PLACES AND GUARANTEE FREEDOM OF WORSHIP TO ALL COMMUNITIES

AHMED HILMI PASHA
PREMIER AND ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY

Who Are The Palestinians?

That seems pretty definitive.

 

[Indeependent]

CABLEGRAM DATED 28 SEPTEMBER 1948 FROM THE PREMIER AND
ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT
TO THE SECRETARY-GENERAL CONCERNING
CONSTITUTION OF ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT

I HAVE THE HONOR TO INFORM YOUR EXCELLENCY THAT IN VIRTUE OF THE NATURAL RIGHT OF THE PEOPLE OF PALESTINE FOR SELF-DETERMINATION WHICH PRINCIPLE IS SUPPORTED BY THE CHARTERS OF THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS, THE UNITED NATIONS AND OTHERS AND IN VIEW OF THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE OVER PALESTINE WHICH HAD PREVENTED THE ARABS FROM EXERCISING THEIR INDEPENDENCE, THE ARABS OF PALESTINE WHO ARE THE OWNERS OF THE COUNTRY AND ITS INDIGENOUS INHABITANTS AND WHO CONSTITUTE THE GREAT MAJORITY OF ITS LEGAL POPULATION HAVE SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO DECLARE PALESTINE IN ITS ENTIRETY AND WITHIN ITS BOUNDARIES AS ESTABLISHED BEFORE THE TERMINATION OF THE BRITISH MANDATE AN INDEPENDENT STATE AND CONSTITUTED A GOVERNMENT UNDER THE NAME OF THE ALL-PALESTINE GOVERNMENT DERIVING ITS AUTHORITY FROM A REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL BASED ON DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES AND AIMING TO SAFEGUARD THE RIGHTS OF MINORITIES AND FOREIGNERS PROTECT THE HOLY PLACES AND GUARANTEE FREEDOM OF WORSHIP TO ALL COMMUNITIES

AHMED HILMI PASHA
PREMIER AND ACTING FOREIGN SECRETARY

Who Are The Palestinians?

That seems pretty definitive.

To a dunce such as yourself.