A No one is "taking" anyone's land away.there are several different reasons on why people do not support the xl portion of the keystone pipeline, and not all agree with all of them...The funny part is that the typical liberal has no clue why they're supposed to hate the XL pipeline. We have pipelines all over the place, but liberals are told they need to worry about this exact one.
It's probably because the oil company behind this didn't spread enough bribery money to Congressmen or the President.
The point is, liberals are told what to do, and have no idea why.
Eminent domain being used by our gvt to take US Citizens land away to give it to a foreign corporation for their own betterment of company profits. How is that using eminent domain for public use?
Another reason that some are upset is the using of clean drinking water to extract the oil sands, something like 3 to 4 barrels of drinking water to extract 1 barrel of oil sands
And other enviro groups are against the pipeline because it is bitumen.. dirty oil crude and refining it is dirtier or something of the sort,
Along with the path of the pipeline crossing key aquifers, that are critical to the bread basket of the nation and world....one big Murphy's Law mishap leak, and the whole country can be hurt.
And others just want us to start thinking of the future and spending money and labor on cleaner, sustainable energy.
And others don't like the fact that a Canadian corporation will own this pipeline and as owners they can give priority to transporting Canadian oil and restrict American companies from using it, but if it were our own pipeline, Americans would have priority.
The landowner still owns the land where the pipeline is laid. The land owner is leasing the land and being well compensated.
B The bullshit lie that "clean drinking water" is being used to extract the oil is just that. A fucking lie! EVERY barrel of water being used is recycled and filtered and reused over and over and over and over.
C Yes to the point that bitumen is a 'dirtier' oil then say sweet crude from Oklahoma.
D As I have already explained the technology being used today literally guarantees even in the case of an earthquake breaking the pipeline in half there are safety valves installed to 100% isolate the rupture. Even then the barrier in place under 100% of the pipeline is designed to contain every ounce of oil within the ruptured section.
The valves are designed to function 100% independently from any electric grid etc. They are mechanical and shut themselves off if there is any drop in pressure detected.
E The agreement between Transcanada and the US is ironclad with regards to which party has the final say in what the pipeline is used for. The US Government maintains the final say.
Transcanada will not "own" the pipeline. Transcanada is willing to build it in return for being able to lease it to move Canadian oil to Texas. Period.