Kicked Out: Israeli authorities evict Palestinian couple from home they lived in for 53yrs

[Shusha]

Okay, since Louie isn't going to drop his foolishness about it being okay to steal as long as its from Jews, can we talk about the real problems and issues this brings up with respect to the conflict?

On a practical, single house, level, I don't understand what the problem is. Unless Israel's rental laws are vastly different from Canada's -- there is no issue here. Renting a property owned by another does not transfer ownership to the tenants, no matter how long the tenants have been renting and living in the property. So if the true owners of the property are discovered, the ownership is re-registered in the true owners names. The State of Israel, which has been collecting rents on the property for 50 years turns those funds over to the owners (or heirs). All of this affects the tenants not one bit. In Canada, one can not evict a tenant without cause EXCEPT for personal use of the property. That is always an option, provided the tenant is given proper notice. So the owners can either move into the property themselves or they can keep the tenants. If they have any shred of decency, they will permit the elderly tenants to stay until the end of their lifetime before taking it over for personal use. Or they will just keep the current tenants. There doesn't seem to be much controversy here.

Now, on a political level it is somewhat more challenging. Millions of people were uprooted and displaced in the conflict and it is impossible to unbreak all those eggs. It was an exchange of populations, which was accepted practice at the time and quite common, even if it is viewed as inhumane now. There are some practical reasons why a population exchange is a good solution. It would be political suicide for Israel and potentially dangerous for Jews, both those in Israel and elsewhere.

Enough people have been uprooted and in my opinion, there is no cause for further displacement. People who lost homes or businesses should be compensated for their loss. People wishing to re-locate from where they are now should make applications to do so, with the understanding that neither Israel nor the wanna-be Palestine wants a flood of the "other" into their nation. Its not a perfect solution. But its the most practical one.

 

[Shusha]

Okay, since Louie isn't going to drop his foolishness about it being okay to steal as long as its from Jews...

Louie never said that, liar.

The rest is OFF TOPIC.

Of course you are saying that. The tenants living in the house are not the owners. Therefore, they have no RIGHT to the house, other than the limited rights of tenants.

The owners of a house have every right to assert their ownership of the house. The argument that long-term tenants assume ownership is ridiculous.

 

[Shusha]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

 

[louie888]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

Nope. And you keep forgetting that Europeans are doing this in Jerusalem which is not even in israel.

That is where it really gets awkward for you retrogrades.

 

[Shusha]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

Nope. And you keep forgetting that Europeans are doing this in Jerusalem which is not even in israel.

That is where it really gets awkward for you retrogrades.

So, the true point of this thread is that Europeans aren't permitted to own homes in Jerusalem and should have Arab families move in? Sounds suspiciously like stealing again.

 

[louie888]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

Nope. And you keep forgetting that Europeans are doing this in Jerusalem which is not even in israel.

That is where it really gets awkward for you retrogrades.

So, the true point of this thread is that Europeans aren't permitted to own homes in Jerusalem and should have Arab families move in? Sounds suspiciously like stealing again.

No, illiterate. The point is obvious. You people have no right to do anything like this in Jerusalem (not part of israel), or anywhere else for that matter.

 

[Boston1]

Sounds like the Squatters were finally evicted after justice prevailed and the Judaic people were allowed into the area to reclaim their property.

Well done Israel ;-)

THANKS FOR PROVING MY POINT ABOVE:
You are trying to argue that is acceptable to make an 80 year old couple homeless... who have lived in THEIR HOME for 53 years.

Nobody on earth accept for you fake jew zionists believe that.

Actually it wasn't their home and you know it. You're just spreading more antisemitic hatred. The FACTS are that a court found the home to have been forcefully occupied by Arabs and the rightful owners to have been evicted 53 years ago.

Good job Israel for righting this wrong and returning the owners to their property

 

[Boston1]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

Nope. And you keep forgetting that Europeans are doing this in Jerusalem which is not even in israel.

That is where it really gets awkward for you retrogrades.

So, the true point of this thread is that Europeans aren't permitted to own homes in Jerusalem and should have Arab families move in? Sounds suspiciously like stealing again.

No, illiterate. The point is obvious. You people have no right to do anything like this in Jerusalem (not part of israel), or anywhere else for that matter.

So Jews have no rights. Gotcha. Thanks for making your antisemitic hatred perfectly clear

 

[Shusha]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

Nope. And you keep forgetting that Europeans are doing this in Jerusalem which is not even in israel.

That is where it really gets awkward for you retrogrades.

So, the true point of this thread is that Europeans aren't permitted to own homes in Jerusalem and should have Arab families move in? Sounds suspiciously like stealing again.

No, illiterate. The point is obvious. You people have no right to do anything like this in Jerusalem (not part of israel), or anywhere else for that matter.

"You people"? Jews have no right to own homes in Jerusalem?

 

[louie888]

So, the whole point of this thread is that elderly tenants should be given special consideration? Fine. No problem with evicting the younger tenants once their elderly parents pass on, though?

Nope. And you keep forgetting that Europeans are doing this in Jerusalem which is not even in israel.

That is where it really gets awkward for you retrogrades.

So, the true point of this thread is that Europeans aren't permitted to own homes in Jerusalem and should have Arab families move in? Sounds suspiciously like stealing again.

No, illiterate. The point is obvious. You people have no right to do anything like this in Jerusalem (not part of israel), or anywhere else for that matter.

"You people"? Jews have no right to own homes in Jerusalem?

Off topic, please start a thread asking tha question. Great idea for a topic.

 

[Boston1]

So Jews have no rights. Gotcha. Thanks for making your antisemitic hatred perfectly clear

Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody.

Actually it wasn't their home and you know it. You're just spreading more antisemitic hatred. The FACTS are that a court found the home to have been forcefully occupied by Arabs and the rightful owners to have been evicted 53 years ago.

Good job Israel for righting this wrong and returning the owners to their property

THANKS FOR PROVING MY POINT ABOVE AGAIN:
You are trying to argue that is acceptable to make an 80 year old couple homeless... who have lived in THEIR HOME for 53 years.

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Not only that but you want to ignore that fact and simply ask you're same asinine question about how unfair it is for the squatters to be removed when they are squatting on the 1/6 of 1% of the Arab world that compromises Israel.

Your argument is about as transparent as your racism.

 

[louie888]

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Fine, who was thrown out? Let's take a look at what you are claiming.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Louie, you really need to make up your mind about whether or not its okay to steal people's homes. The owners of this home are Jewish and were forcibly removed in 1948. The couple that live in it now, and pay rent for it, are not the owners.

By supporting this Arab couple you are now advocating stealing people's homes.

So, those Palestinians can go back to the homes they lost in 1948, no?

 

[Hollie]

So Jews have no rights. Gotcha. Thanks for making your antisemitic hatred perfectly clear

Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody.

Actually it wasn't their home and you know it. You're just spreading more antisemitic hatred. The FACTS are that a court found the home to have been forcefully occupied by Arabs and the rightful owners to have been evicted 53 years ago.

Good job Israel for righting this wrong and returning the owners to their property

THANKS FOR PROVING MY POINT ABOVE AGAIN:
You are trying to argue that is acceptable to make an 80 year old couple homeless... who have lived in THEIR HOME for 53 years.

"Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody."

It appears you really mean Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody..... except Arabs-Moslems when they're dispossessing Jews.

 

[louie888]

"Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody."

It appears you really mean Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody..... except Arabs-Moslems when they're dispossessing Jews.

No, illiterate, and if that was happening I would speak out on that too, but it is the other way around - READ THE OP.

 

[Hollie]

"Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody."

It appears you really mean Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody..... except Arabs-Moslems when they're dispossessing Jews.

No, illiterate, and if that was happening I would speak out on that too, but it is the other way around - READ THE OP.

Obviously, you want an entitlement for the Arab-Moslem invaders / colonists / dispossessors who stole the homes of the indigenous Jews.

 

[Boston1]

So Jews have no rights. Gotcha. Thanks for making your antisemitic hatred perfectly clear

Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody.

Actually it wasn't their home and you know it. You're just spreading more antisemitic hatred. The FACTS are that a court found the home to have been forcefully occupied by Arabs and the rightful owners to have been evicted 53 years ago.

Good job Israel for righting this wrong and returning the owners to their property

THANKS FOR PROVING MY POINT ABOVE AGAIN:
You are trying to argue that is acceptable to make an 80 year old couple homeless... who have lived in THEIR HOME for 53 years.

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Not only that but you want to ignore that fact and simply ask you're same asinine question about how unfair it is for the squatters to be removed when they are squatting on the 1/6 of 1% of the Arab world that compromises Israel.

Your argument is about as transparent as your ra

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Fine, who was thrown out? Let's take a look at what you are claiming.

Renters were thrown out. Its pretty simple. The apartment buildings belonged to Jewish owners who didn't feel like continuing to rent to hostile Arabs. The situation is no different than any other land lord who has a right to evict tenants.

 

[louie888]

So Jews have no rights. Gotcha. Thanks for making your antisemitic hatred perfectly clear

Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody.

Actually it wasn't their home and you know it. You're just spreading more antisemitic hatred. The FACTS are that a court found the home to have been forcefully occupied by Arabs and the rightful owners to have been evicted 53 years ago.

Good job Israel for righting this wrong and returning the owners to their property

THANKS FOR PROVING MY POINT ABOVE AGAIN:
You are trying to argue that is acceptable to make an 80 year old couple homeless... who have lived in THEIR HOME for 53 years.

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Not only that but you want to ignore that fact and simply ask you're same asinine question about how unfair it is for the squatters to be removed when they are squatting on the 1/6 of 1% of the Arab world that compromises Israel.

Your argument is about as transparent as your ra

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Fine, who was thrown out? Let's take a look at what you are claiming.

Renters were thrown out. Its pretty simple. The apartment buildings belonged to Jewish owners who didn't feel like continuing to rent to hostile Arabs. The situation is no different than any other land lord who has a right to evict tenants.

Jerusalem is not even in israel. Do they teach geography at your temple?

 

[TNHarley]

What fucking bullshit. No wonder so many people hate israel.

 

[Boston1]

So Jews have no rights. Gotcha. Thanks for making your antisemitic hatred perfectly clear

Nobody has the right to thieve and murder. Nobody.

Actually it wasn't their home and you know it. You're just spreading more antisemitic hatred. The FACTS are that a court found the home to have been forcefully occupied by Arabs and the rightful owners to have been evicted 53 years ago.

Good job Israel for righting this wrong and returning the owners to their property

THANKS FOR PROVING MY POINT ABOVE AGAIN:
You are trying to argue that is acceptable to make an 80 year old couple homeless... who have lived in THEIR HOME for 53 years.

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Not only that but you want to ignore that fact and simply ask you're same asinine question about how unfair it is for the squatters to be removed when they are squatting on the 1/6 of 1% of the Arab world that compromises Israel.

Your argument is about as transparent as your ra

LOL I love it, so you're OK with the Jewish family that lived there before getting thrown out, but the Arab family that squatted in their home you're not OK with.

Fine, who was thrown out? Let's take a look at what you are claiming.

Renters were thrown out. Its pretty simple. The apartment buildings belonged to Jewish owners who didn't feel like continuing to rent to hostile Arabs. The situation is no different than any other land lord who has a right to evict tenants.

Jerusalem is not even in israel. Do they teach geography at your temple?

LOL clearly you've never looked at the map.

If you notice the ENTIRE area listed as Jewish Palestine is available for the creation of a Jewish homeland. No different than any of the other mandated areas were available for the creation of other tribal homelands. Might want to review the Mandate before you embarrass yourself any further