Delta4Embassy
Gold Member
- Dec 12, 2013
- 25,744
- 3,045
With so many traditions of Judaism and Christianity, yet they all rely on the same canonized Bible (excluding Judaism of course. They all use the same Tanach though,) I've often wondered which is the "true" version those people practiced.
Until G-d gave Torah to Moses at Mt. Sinai, nothing had been written down so all Jews could follow the same things. Asking my rabbi about something relating to this (namely why G-d would destroy Sodom and Gomorrah before giving the law and lists of sins, or punishing Pharaoh, etc. his answer was prior to Mt. Sinai and receiving the Torah everyone (Jews and Gentiles alike) were under the Noahide Laws. These are the 7 "universal" commandments for all humankind to obey are a basically a condensed form of the 10 Commandments.
Unfortunately, the existence of the 7 universal laws aren't found in the Tanach (OT is a heavily edited and corrupted version of the Tanach.) But rather in the Jewish Talmud. Which itself wasn't written down and compiled until relatively modern times (around 300 CE.) So until the writings existed, the existence of such laws could only be spread by word of mouth.
Since the Jewish Tanach wasn't compiled until (very roughly, dates differ) 500BCE, and the Talmud after that, there could be no agreed upon Noahide Laws since they're taken from the Torah (first 5 books of the Tanach.)
So what did Adam and Eve, Moses, and everyone else practice insofar as religious tradition? What kind of Judaism?
The traditions extant today are Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, and smaller ones such as Chabad, and Karaite. Though most use the Talmud ('Talmudic Judaism' et al.) Karaites are one that does not. They reason only the Tanach is 'authoratative,' whereas the Talmud is simply Man's commentaries on Tanach, thus not 'directly from G-d, and thus not binding.' It's a position I happen to share but that's another matter.
Since everyone Jew and Christian (and Muslim but I'll limit this to the first two) recognize the validity of the Tanach/OT, yet follow religions and denominations not practiced by those figures, are these Scripturally wrong? If so, which one if any is right?
Until G-d gave Torah to Moses at Mt. Sinai, nothing had been written down so all Jews could follow the same things. Asking my rabbi about something relating to this (namely why G-d would destroy Sodom and Gomorrah before giving the law and lists of sins, or punishing Pharaoh, etc. his answer was prior to Mt. Sinai and receiving the Torah everyone (Jews and Gentiles alike) were under the Noahide Laws. These are the 7 "universal" commandments for all humankind to obey are a basically a condensed form of the 10 Commandments.
Unfortunately, the existence of the 7 universal laws aren't found in the Tanach (OT is a heavily edited and corrupted version of the Tanach.) But rather in the Jewish Talmud. Which itself wasn't written down and compiled until relatively modern times (around 300 CE.) So until the writings existed, the existence of such laws could only be spread by word of mouth.
Since the Jewish Tanach wasn't compiled until (very roughly, dates differ) 500BCE, and the Talmud after that, there could be no agreed upon Noahide Laws since they're taken from the Torah (first 5 books of the Tanach.)
So what did Adam and Eve, Moses, and everyone else practice insofar as religious tradition? What kind of Judaism?
The traditions extant today are Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, and smaller ones such as Chabad, and Karaite. Though most use the Talmud ('Talmudic Judaism' et al.) Karaites are one that does not. They reason only the Tanach is 'authoratative,' whereas the Talmud is simply Man's commentaries on Tanach, thus not 'directly from G-d, and thus not binding.' It's a position I happen to share but that's another matter.
Since everyone Jew and Christian (and Muslim but I'll limit this to the first two) recognize the validity of the Tanach/OT, yet follow religions and denominations not practiced by those figures, are these Scripturally wrong? If so, which one if any is right?