NotfooledbyW
Gold Member
- Jul 9, 2014
- 25,427
- 5,156
Stu 10152035 10152035,
Why do you think you were proven right on the latter? Petraeus recently said no one knows if the withdrawal would have made a difference. Do you have more insight than Petraeus?
And it is interesting to note that you view the decision to invade and the decision to withdraw equally as a US President's decision. The decision to force inspectors out and invade was the sole decision of a US President. There is not doubt about that. But the decision to end foreign troops on Iraqi soul was ultimately the decision of the Iraqi people.
Also please provide some verification that Iraq's legislature actually voted in October 2011 to extend US troop presence in Iraq.
I thought it was a bad idea to go in and in hindsight I was proven right. I also thought it was a bad idea to leave prematurely, and in hindsight I was proven right.
Why do you think you were proven right on the latter? Petraeus recently said no one knows if the withdrawal would have made a difference. Do you have more insight than Petraeus?
And it is interesting to note that you view the decision to invade and the decision to withdraw equally as a US President's decision. The decision to force inspectors out and invade was the sole decision of a US President. There is not doubt about that. But the decision to end foreign troops on Iraqi soul was ultimately the decision of the Iraqi people.
Also please provide some verification that Iraq's legislature actually voted in October 2011 to extend US troop presence in Iraq.