If a child tells teachers they are transgender, should the school keep that secret from parents?

[Seymour Flops]

If so, what else should schools be keeping secret from parents?

 

[progressive hunter]

If so, what else should schools be keeping secret from parents?

any teacher that keeps any secret from a parent should be killed on sight,,

 

[JackOfNoTrades]

If so, what else should schools be keeping secret from parents?

Encourage the child to tell this to their parents.

 

[johngaltshrugged]

Absolutely not.
If a child can't have an aspirin in school without parental permission there is no way to possibly justify "transitioning" kids without their knowledge.

I'll raise my kids the way I see fit- they can take the "it takes a village" propaganda BS & shove it up their butts with their heads

 

[progressive hunter]

Encourage the child to tell this to their parents.

not enough,, with so many trannies killing themselves they should be required to tell them

 

[1srelluc]

Of course, potential budding mental problems should be reported to the parents. I see no difference in that than if a kid sat in a corner talking to themselves.

 

[rightwinger]

Schools can tell the parents and students will learn they can’t trust schools to confide in

 

[rightwinger]

not enough,, with so many trannies killing themselves they should be required to tell them

Trannies kill themselves because of the way they are treated by their family and society

Outing them will only encourage more suicide

 

[Seymour Flops]

Schools can tell the parents and students will learn they can’t trust schools to confide in

Nor should they.

Why in the world would you want students keeping secrets with adults? Telling a child "let's keep this our secret," is the classic groomer move.

 

[progressive hunter]

Trannies kill themselves because of the way they are treated by their family and society

Outing them will only encourage more suicide

and keeping it from parents should result in death,,

 

[JackOfNoTrades]

not enough,, with so many trannies killing themselves they should be required to tell them

Make up your mind. Should teachers be involved in getting in the middle of issues like this, or should it be left to the parents?
The whole bullshit about "parents rights" in school board meetings(a non-existent issue) and school systems' argument is that parents rights should be paramount.

If you truly believe that, then the teacher should strongly encourage the child to talk to their parents about it. If the child is a teen, then by all means bring in counseling to mediate...but always involve the parents.

You can't have this both ways.

 

[rightwinger]

Nor should they.

Why in the world would you want students keeping secrets with adults? Telling a child "let's keep this our secret," is the classic groomer move.

It all comes down to trust
If a child is having difficulties in school and can’t trust the school to confide in, the school can’t do their job of educating

 

[progressive hunter]

Make up your mind. Should teachers be involved in getting in the middle of issues like this, or should it be left to the parents?
The whole bullshit about "parents rights" in school board meetings(a non-existent issue) and school systems' argument is that parents rights should be paramount.

If you truly believe that, then the teacher should strongly encourage the child to talk to their parents about it. If the child is a teen, then by all means bring in counseling to mediate...but always involve the parents.

You can't have this both ways.

teachers are paid to teach the subject they are paid to teach,, nothing more,,

some of them only see the kid for less than an hour a day,, the parents have to live with them and make sure they are safe 24/7/365

 

[progressive hunter]

It all comes down to trust
If a child is having difficulties in school and can’t trust the school to confide in, the school can’t do their job of educating

it has nothing to do with trust,,

 

[Seymour Flops]

It all comes down to trust
If a child is having difficulties in school and can’t trust the school to confide in, the school can’t do their job of educating

Give me an example of a school needing to keep a secret from a child's parent specifically so that the child can be educated. Like end your example with something like, "and therefore, the child could not learn to multiply fractions."

Keeping it secret when a child asked to be called by a name and pronouns different from their actual gender wouldn't be an example of that, would it?

 

[White 6]

any teacher that keeps any secret from a parent should be killed on sight,,

While just speaking as a poster, I agree teachers should not be keeping secrets of children from parent, you are totally wrong to advocate killing teachers or anybody else on message boards or public media. It is wrong and it is personally stupid on your part. If any teachers are found murdered in your area, I hope your social media will be used against you in court. Violence is not the answer among adults in civilized societies.

 

[progressive hunter]

While just speaking as a poster, I agree teachers should not be keeping secrets of children from parent, you are totally wrong to advocate killing teachers or anybody else on message boards or public media. It is wrong and it is personally stupid on your part. If any teachers are found murdered in your area, I hope your social media will be used against you in court. Violence is not the answer among adults in civilized societies.

when children are being harmed or used for a political agenda violence is always the right response,,

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

Encourage the child to tell this to their parents.

.


And you know damned well they don't do that, so it's a safe place to throw out a bunch of speculation.



.

 

[JackOfNoTrades]

teachers are paid to teach the subject they are paid to teach,, nothing more,,

some of them only see the kid for less than an hour a day,, the parents have to live with them and make sure they are safe 24/7/365

Then the correct course of action is to encourage the child to tell and discuss it with their parents. End of story.

 

[progressive hunter]

Then the correct course of action is to encourage the child to tell and discuss it with their parents. End of story.

the correct course is to tell the parents.........

what if the teacher opposes the tranny narrative and is trying to convince the child they arent tans and really a boy or girl they were born as??

both are grooming and not the teachers business,,