toomuchtime_
Gold Member
- Dec 29, 2008
- 20,085
- 4,990
- 280
Then regardless of your beliefs, you are irrelevant to the real events going on in America.I am not attacking your philosophy, just pointing how irrelevant it is the real events transpiring. You continue to make the argument that if some one is not as true a believer as yourself, then he is a liberal, which is essentially what you are saying when you claim Trump would appoint the same kind of justice as Clinton would. As I have said before, Trump is not an ideological conservative but a pragmatist with no political allegiances who leans right. I am an independent who tends to lean right on national security issues and economic issues but left on social issues. As for broad healthcare coverage by some means, most Americans left or right support it. Hayek, Hume, Locke, Tocqueville, Birch and no doubt the others who inspire you, did not have to deal with the problems of governing a democracy, so it is foolish to think anyone could remain entirely faithful their precepts in the real political world and get anything done.
Like most Americans, Trump believes everyone should have access to healthcare but that Obamacare is the wrong way to do it. Right now there is a federal district court decision that the government cannot provide subsidies if the Congress has not appropriated funds specifically for that purpose. Obama is appealing this decision since it would spell the end of Obamacare and whatever the appeals court says, it is a certainty it will go to the Supreme Court. If Clinton is elected, the Court will strike down the lower court's decision and Obamacare will go on, but if Trump gets to appoint Scalia's replacement, the lower court's decision will be upheld clearing the way for a fresh debate on healthcare. What will happen after that is anyone's guess, but Obamacare will be gone.
Well, sorry, but whenever you put "conservative" in quotes, it is attacking my political philosophy. I am a Conservative and I am consistently a Conservative, every day of day of the week. My Conservative principles don't change with the times or over the "popularity" of a candidate. My viewpoint is very much relevant because it's the viewpoint of our founders and framers of the Constitution.
Hayek, Hume, Locke, Tocqueville and Birch didn't have to deal with governing a democracy and neither do we... The US is not a democracy, it's a republic. We don't have a problem with "access to health care" ...there is no state in the union that doesn't have indigent care law where health care is accessible to anyone regardless of their ability to pay. Trump has said, in so many words, he favors a plan more like that of Hillary Clinton from before Obamacare. That's simply not Conservative and I can't support it.
We can get into a whole entire side-debate about health care but the idea that health care is a "right" has used a weird context of a "right" from the progressives. A "right" is, by nature, something you have that doesn't infringe upon someone else. Like, I can say that I have a right to freely travel... we agree on this, right? It's my right to come and go as I please... that doesn't infringe upon you in any way. But if we interpret my "right to travel" in the same way as progressives articulate the "right to health care" then you should be obligated to pay for my travel expenses. I would suspect, most Americans wouldn't go along with this... they'd say, I have the right to travel but they don't have an obligation to pay for it. The same is true with health care. You have the right to health care, I don't have the obligation to pay for it.
Again, I originally thought that Trump was a non-ideological pragmatist and I was prepared for supporting that in this election over Hillary, who is very clearly a leftist ideologue. But Trump has changed radically from who he was during the primaries and has now come out in favor of many left-wing viewpoints. I can't support that as a Conservative. I'm sorry if that hurts your feelings or if that causes a problem... it's just not something I can do. I may be able to vote for him if he convinces me he will not govern as a liberal ideologue but he's going to have to stop attacking conservatives and contradicting conservative principles. If he doesn't, I can't help it... that's not MY fault... I can't support him and I won't vote for him. If he loses because of that, it's on him... this is his responsibility. He has to win my vote.