OohPooPahDoo
Gold Member
- May 11, 2011
- 15,347
- 985
VTINX is 30% invested in stock ,took a 20% hit in the last downturn before coming around. It does not satisfy your requirement that such a fund be able to "weather any market turbulence", further, it guarantees no particular return for the future, like an annuity would. And if course you are just.picking the winners after the fact and falling prey yet again to survivorship bias.hey Moron you don't keep the lion's share of your money in stocks when you're retired.
I've only told you that about a hundred times in this thread.
Now you're missing a lot of info on your projections
How long is "the rest of their lives"?
What is the rate of return on the 1 million?
Rule of thumb
150K earning 5% will allow you to withdraw 1000 a month for 20 years
For example for that 1 million held at 5% you could withdraw 15000 a quarter and after 20 years still have 640K left
Hey I fell for the annuities are great sales pitch when I was young and uninformed.
I used to sell fixed and variable annuities and made a lot of money doing it.
But I continued my education and realized they were a complete rip off. But hey go ahead and buy them if you want IDGAF what you do with your money
You keep saying that you shouldn't hold many stocks in retirement and then turn around and say you should have that money invested in something that returns 5%. What investment, today, 1) returns 5% and 2) is not a stock 3) is low risk and 4) isn't a promotional offer from a bank? Seriously, I would love to know, I wanna put some money there.
Further - what way is there to guarantee 5% returns are available 20 years from now when you might be reinvesting your remaining principal?
You've got to base your arguments in reality, man! Not only are 5% returns not available TODAY - there's no guarantee they will be available in the FUTURE - either! The only way to guarantee a fixed income of a certain amount for the rest of your life is to either a) have much much more money than you actually need for retirement b) buy an annuity.
Where did I ever say to have no stocks in retirement?
I said you hold a smaller percentage of your money in stocks
And who says 5% is not attainable today?
And I don't look for guarantees because in reality a guaranteed return is a guaranteed loss.
But go ahead and get ripped off buying an annuity because its guaranteed like I said IDGAF what you do
But if you must know the Vanguard VTINX fund has averaged 5.4% over the last 10 years
and many other income funds have averages 6 or more over the same time frame
I'm still a ways away from retirement so I don't spend a lot of time researching income funds
It was an example and downturns are temporary the long term average is what matters.
And no one fund will do it all or haven't you learned that yet?
Seriously you have to learn how not to boil everything down to just one choice. Do you do that with all decisions you have to make?
Tell you what you go buy your annuities and make your insurance broker a lot of money and I'll worry about my own money
Sound good?
How much will he make?