Advertiser: Planned Parenthood - Election Guide 2008 - The New York Times
Good point... I wonder if they felt the same about TV stations taking sides when they ran these ads.
Immie
Well in Planned Parenthood's defense--and it GALLS me to defend them--they have a right to advertise their perspective and agenda just as FonF does. But for the ads to be non-political, they would have to tell a story about somebody choosing to abort a baby without any comment on anybody's 'right to choose' just as the Tebow ad simply tells a story without specifically commenting on 'right to life'.
In this particular case, the argument is based on a CBS policy to allow no political ads as Super Bowl advertising. So the debate is on whether the Tebow ad is political or just a feel good ad.
My point was though that they choose to advertise on TV and do not seem to have a problem with it, yet they have a problem when FoF makes that same choice?
PP definitely does have a right to advertise, but why would they deny that right to someone else?
Immie
Oh I see what you mean. But that isn't what they're doing in this case. What they are doing is trying to get CBS to reject this ad during the Super Bowl on the grounds that it violates CBS's policy re no political ads during the Super Bowl. They say it isn't suitable for this 'young' crowd. Run it instead on--I can't remember what a Planned Parenthood rep recently recommended on Fox, but it was for them to run it on some obscure channel that nobody watches.
FonF on the other hand apparently went to great lengths to make it a message of inspiration and hope and not in the least bit political so that it would not violate the policy and apparently CBS, certainly nobody's idea of part of the vast rightwing conspiracy, agreed. But the pro-abortionists almost certainly have their panties in a bunch because of the major exposure the ad will get during the Super Bowl. Of course their public protests have greatly increased the probability that people will be looking for it now and it will probably be noticed by many more than it would have otherwise.