Should the U.S. Have Two Constitutions?

[jwoodie]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

 

[candycorn]

dumbest
idea
ever

 

[TNHarley]

Or how about the repubs and dems stop shitting all over it? That sounds like a better idea.

 

[Oddball]

 

[MarcATL]

lol

 

[Votto]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

If they can't follow one, why do we need two?

 

[SavannahMann]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

I think the Red States would object the loudest.

I think the Red States and a vast majority of Conservatives detest the Constitution.

 

[g5000]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

Republicans in Florida want news organizations to be required to register with the state before they can talk about state politicians.

Does that sound to you like these fascists are adhering to the Constitution?

 

[Ralph Norton]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

Don't make me agree with candycorn.

 

[Circe]

If they can't follow one, why do we need two?

It does sound like the gun laws in failed cities. If the 16 laws they have don't stop the shootings, enact several more.

Apparently this idea has worked so well they are spreading it to the Constitution.

I'd say the best thing would just be to split the country and then each new country could rewrite the constitutions however each wanted.

 

[Ralph Norton]

I think the Red States and a vast majority of Conservatives detest the Constitution.

You should stop thinking.

 

[SavannahMann]

You should stop thinking.

Tell me why the Cops can’t search apartments when they know drugs are inside?

 

[Ralph Norton]

Tell me why the Cops can’t search apartments when they know drugs are inside?

OK, I'll play. They need a search warrant. What the hell does that have to do with your statement
"Red States and a vast majority of Conservatives detest the Constitution."

 

[Independent thinker]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

Democrats don't need a Constitution at all. Popular vote determines everything. The hell with laws.

 

[scruffy]

Should the U.S. have two Constitutions? For Red States, the Constitution would be the original document, plus Amendments, which could be judicially interpreted only in accordance with the plain meaning of its actual wording. For Blue States, it would be a "living" document which could be judicially interpreted in accordance with personal political opinions and/or ignored by the President if he so chooses.

I think Red States would welcome this distinction, while Blue States would oppose it. What is your opinion?

Interesting idea.

Switzerland has 7 presidents.

They rotate, annually.

 

[g5000]

Both parties shredded the Constitution when they allowed warrantless wiretaps on every American.

 

[g5000]

Democrats don't need a Constitution at all. Popular vote determines everything. The hell with laws.

Republicans don't even respect the Electoral College. They throw an insurrection instead.

 

[Votto]

Both parties shredded the Constitution when they allowed warrantless wiretaps on every American.

Yes, but Orange man bad

Besides, January 6th.

 

[g5000]

Yes, but Orange man bad

Besides, January 6th.

Yes, the megalomaniacal dictator wannabe is very bad.

More and more people are waking up to this fact every day.

 

[Independent thinker]

Republicans don't even respect the Electoral College. They throw an insurrection instead.

Ummmmmmmmmm, Republicans did not throw an insurrection. Maybe you could list one Republican politician who has been arrested for insurrection.