Teen jailed for 3 years and then released with no charges committed suicide

ClosedCaption

Diamond Member
Sep 15, 2010
53,233
6,719
The Death Of Kalief Browder Is An 'American Tragedy Almost Beyond Words'

n-KALIEF-BROWDER-large570.jpg


Heres the original story from the New Yorker: Three Years on Rikers Without Trial - The New Yorker

The Death Of Kalief Browder Is An American Tragedy Almost Beyond Words

Kalief Browder, a young man from New York City who had gained national renown in recent years as a symbol of America's broken criminal justice system, took his own life this weekend, according to a report from The New Yorker. He was 22.

Browder was just 16 years old in 2010 when he was sent to New York's notorious Rikers Island jail on a robbery charge that would ultimately be dismissed. He ended up spending three years at the facility, despite not having been convicted of a crime. When he wasn’t in solitary confinement -- where he spent an accumulated two years -- he faced unspeakable violence at the hands of guards and fellow inmates.

His long, tortuous ordeal -- as documented last year in a widely read New Yorker article by Jennifer Gonnerman -- came to a tragic end Saturday. Gonnerman reported that Browder hanged himself with an air conditioning cord at his family’s home in the Bronx, New York. She told The Huffington Post Monday that Browder’s family was in a “state of shock.”

“They were angry and confused about why Kalief was gone,” she said.

Gonnerman, who'd spent a great deal of time with Browder, remembered him as an “intelligent, perceptive young man who was trying to do the right thing. All he wanted to do was have a normal life... but he never really got that chance.”

What happened to Browder and his family, said Gonnerman, is an “American tragedy almost beyond words.


snip

“When you go over the three years that [Browder] spent [in jail] and all the horrific details he endured, it’s unbelievable that this could happen to a teen-ager in New York City,” Prestia said hours after Browder's death, according to The New Yorker. “He didn’t get tortured in some prison camp in another country. It was right here!”

snip

A horrifying report from the U.S. Department of Justice last year described the "rampant use of unnecessary and excessive force" by guards against teenage inmates on Rikers. The report also detailed how the adolescent inmate facility, where Browder was kept, was “more inspired" by the William Golding novel Lord of the Flies than by "any legitimate philosophy of humane detention

Check out the video at the bottom of the page from inside Rikers.


 
He had recently thrown out his brand-new television, he explained, “because it was watching me.”

Two empty bottles of Browder’s antipsychotic drug sat on a table. Was it possible that taking the drug had caused him to commit suicide? Or could he have stopped taking it and become suicidal as a result?

They spoke about his paranoia, about how he often suspected that the cops or some other authority figures were after him.

Excerpts from,
Kalief Browder 1993 2015 - The New Yorker

Little more to it. Wasn't just someone got lost in the system, or some normal angel got screwed by the police.
 
He had recently thrown out his brand-new television, he explained, “because it was watching me.”

Two empty bottles of Browder’s antipsychotic drug sat on a table. Was it possible that taking the drug had caused him to commit suicide? Or could he have stopped taking it and become suicidal as a result?

They spoke about his paranoia, about how he often suspected that the cops or some other authority figures were after him.

Excerpts from,
Kalief Browder 1993 2015 - The New Yorker

Little more to it. Wasn't just someone got lost in the system, or some normal angel got screwed by the police.


Uh yes it was, he had no record (is that an "angel"? or is being an angel possible?") he was locked in solitary for 3 years without charges and was abused for the entire time.

So you speak about his paranoia AFTER the 3 years in Solitary as if the jail time never happened. Theres always "a little more to it" but he was "lost in the system" and a "normal angel (whatever that is) who got screwed by the police.
 
Robin Steinberg, of the legal group the Bronx Defenders, which documents inmates' stories of solitary confinement, told HuffPost that "Kalief Browder's death is a tragic and painful reminder that the nightmares of incarceration and solitary confinement do not end upon release. It underscores the urgent need not only to reform the city's jails but also to end the unconstitutional, inefficient, and -- at worst -- deadly delays in case processing."

And Jen Carnig, spokeswoman at the New York Civil Liberties Union, said Browder’s death highlights the fact that New York “is one of only two states that prosecutes children as adults when they turn 16 and sends them to adult prisons.”
 
He had recently thrown out his brand-new television, he explained, “because it was watching me.”

Two empty bottles of Browder’s antipsychotic drug sat on a table. Was it possible that taking the drug had caused him to commit suicide? Or could he have stopped taking it and become suicidal as a result?

They spoke about his paranoia, about how he often suspected that the cops or some other authority figures were after him.

Excerpts from,
Kalief Browder 1993 2015 - The New Yorker

Little more to it. Wasn't just someone got lost in the system, or some normal angel got screwed by the police.


Uh yes it was, he had no record (is that an "angel"? or is being an angel possible?") he was locked in solitary for 3 years without charges and was abused for the entire time.

So you speak about his paranoia AFTER the 3 years in Solitary as if the jail time never happened. Theres always "a little more to it" but he was "lost in the system" and a "normal angel (whatever that is) who got screwed by the police.

He was dangerously mentally ill. You don't become mentally ill because of incarceration. Your mental illness might get exaccerbated because of it becomming more acute, but it doesn't spontaneously occur because you're behind bars. You were ill already, just not symptomatic yet.

Just as well he killed himself than gone on to become another James Holmes.
 
He had recently thrown out his brand-new television, he explained, “because it was watching me.”

Two empty bottles of Browder’s antipsychotic drug sat on a table. Was it possible that taking the drug had caused him to commit suicide? Or could he have stopped taking it and become suicidal as a result?

They spoke about his paranoia, about how he often suspected that the cops or some other authority figures were after him.

Excerpts from,
Kalief Browder 1993 2015 - The New Yorker

Little more to it. Wasn't just someone got lost in the system, or some normal angel got screwed by the police.


Uh yes it was, he had no record (is that an "angel"? or is being an angel possible?") he was locked in solitary for 3 years without charges and was abused for the entire time.

So you speak about his paranoia AFTER the 3 years in Solitary as if the jail time never happened. Theres always "a little more to it" but he was "lost in the system" and a "normal angel (whatever that is) who got screwed by the police.

He was dangerously mentally ill. You don't become mentally ill because of incarceration. Your mental illness might get exaccerbated because of it becomming more acute, but it doesn't spontaneously occur because you're behind bars. You were ill already, just not symptomatic yet.

Just as well he killed himself than gone on to become another James Holmes.


He wasnt mentally prior to being incarcerated at all
 
You'd think you were reading a story about an event in the soviet union.

Of course democrooks run New Yuck state, so more and more of it is sounding like the soviet union everyday.


 
You'd think you were reading a story about an event in the soviet union.

Of course democrooks run New Yuck state, so more and more of it is sounding like the soviet union everyday.



Here I thought Republicans were racist. Here's one defending the downtrodden who happened to be black. And mentally ill. Guess Republicans want dangerously mentally ill blacks out on the streets?

You sure you're a Republican?
 
Enhance the story if you want to but since you brought up the "unspeakable violence" allegedly committed by Rikers Is. Guards you need to justify the statement with indictments. Officers at Rikers Island are mostly Black with a lot of women even in a man's correctional facility. Granted the clown faces who post this stuff probably watch way too many movies depicting cruel Guards but Hollywood fiction ain't real life. Maligning employees of a facility and assuming that they are capable of "unspeakable violence" because they are Black and wear a uniform might make a good story but it is treading on racist ground. The kid was most likely placed in solitary for his own protection.Blame Bloomie's bureaucracy if you want to.
 
Last edited:
Im confused.

1- Why didnt his family bond him out? EVERYONE can get bond these days.
2- Why didnt his defense attorney go to trial? He has a right to a speedy trial. The ONLY reason it would last 3 years is if the defense agreed to it.

I agree...waiting 3 years for a trial is absurd. But...all a defense attorney has to do is demand a trial and it usually hits the docket in a month or so.

As for bond...his family should be asked that.
 
three years. I've watched shows where they innocent jailed for 20 years

came out angry, but decided to live their lives while they can

for crying out loud. you pick ONE story out of 360 million people in this country

what do you want what us on here to DO about it?
 
You'd think you were reading a story about an event in the soviet union.

Of course democrooks run New Yuck state, so more and more of it is sounding like the soviet union everyday.


This unfortunately happens whether their D's or R's because both like that prison money
 
Im confused.

1- Why didnt his family bond him out? EVERYONE can get bond these days.
2- Why didnt his defense attorney go to trial? He has a right to a speedy trial. The ONLY reason it would last 3 years is if the defense agreed to it.

I agree...waiting 3 years for a trial is absurd. But...all a defense attorney has to do is demand a trial and it usually hits the docket in a month or so.

As for bond...his family should be asked that.


The reason for your confusion is your lack of curiosity. Its all covered in the story
 
Im confused.

1- Why didnt his family bond him out? EVERYONE can get bond these days.
2- Why didnt his defense attorney go to trial? He has a right to a speedy trial. The ONLY reason it would last 3 years is if the defense agreed to it.

I agree...waiting 3 years for a trial is absurd. But...all a defense attorney has to do is demand a trial and it usually hits the docket in a month or so.

As for bond...his family should be asked that.


The reason for your confusion is your lack of curiosity. Its all covered in the story

Well...i dont give a fuck enough to watch it. So how about you sum it up.

Family didnt bother bonding him out. Defense attorney allowed it to drag on for years. Why and why?
 
three years. I've watched shows where they innocent jailed for 20 years

came out angry, but decided to live their lives while they can

for crying out loud. you pick ONE story out of 360 million people in this country

what do you want what us on here to DO about it?

You?.... the most I'd want from you is to finish your spaghetti-o's without making a dam mess on the walls.
 
Im confused.

1- Why didnt his family bond him out? EVERYONE can get bond these days.
2- Why didnt his defense attorney go to trial? He has a right to a speedy trial. The ONLY reason it would last 3 years is if the defense agreed to it.

I agree...waiting 3 years for a trial is absurd. But...all a defense attorney has to do is demand a trial and it usually hits the docket in a month or so.

As for bond...his family should be asked that.


The reason for your confusion is your lack of curiosity. Its all covered in the story

Well...i dont give a fuck enough to watch it. So how about you sum it up.

Family didnt bother bonding him out. Defense attorney allowed it to drag on for years. Why and why?

Bond = 2 much
Public Defender = in on it or didnt care
 
Im confused.

1- Why didnt his family bond him out? EVERYONE can get bond these days.
2- Why didnt his defense attorney go to trial? He has a right to a speedy trial. The ONLY reason it would last 3 years is if the defense agreed to it.

I agree...waiting 3 years for a trial is absurd. But...all a defense attorney has to do is demand a trial and it usually hits the docket in a month or so.

As for bond...his family should be asked that.


The reason for your confusion is your lack of curiosity. Its all covered in the story

Well...i dont give a fuck enough to watch it. So how about you sum it up.

Family didnt bother bonding him out. Defense attorney allowed it to drag on for years. Why and why?

Bond = 2 much
Public Defender = in on it or didnt care

So its the public defenders fault. Only he could consent to the constant delays...OR...he was the one requesting them.

This whole story boild down to a shitty public defender. And a family that is apparently large and in a caring community. ..but couldnt pool up enough for bond? Hmmm.
 
He had recently thrown out his brand-new television, he explained, “because it was watching me.”

Two empty bottles of Browder’s antipsychotic drug sat on a table. Was it possible that taking the drug had caused him to commit suicide? Or could he have stopped taking it and become suicidal as a result?

They spoke about his paranoia, about how he often suspected that the cops or some other authority figures were after him.

Excerpts from,
Kalief Browder 1993 2015 - The New Yorker

Little more to it. Wasn't just someone got lost in the system, or some normal angel got screwed by the police.
Are you really this stupid????
 
Im confused.

1- Why didnt his family bond him out? EVERYONE can get bond these days.
2- Why didnt his defense attorney go to trial? He has a right to a speedy trial. The ONLY reason it would last 3 years is if the defense agreed to it.

I agree...waiting 3 years for a trial is absurd. But...all a defense attorney has to do is demand a trial and it usually hits the docket in a month or so.

As for bond...his family should be asked that.


The reason for your confusion is your lack of curiosity. Its all covered in the story

Well...i dont give a fuck enough to watch it. So how about you sum it up.

Family didnt bother bonding him out. Defense attorney allowed it to drag on for years. Why and why?

Bond = 2 much
Public Defender = in on it or didnt care

So its the public defenders fault. Only he could consent to the constant delays...OR...he was the one requesting them.

This whole story boild down to a shitty public defender. And a family that is apparently large and in a caring community. ..but couldnt pool up enough for bond? Hmmm.

Sure, its a lot of peoples fault. Our system is broken when a guy can be jailed for 3 years without a charge. The PD is just a cog in the wheel of fucked upness
 

Forum List

Back
Top