martybegan
Diamond Member
- Apr 5, 2010
- 83,628
- 34,648
I wouldn't agree to a national registration, and it isn't needed. All that is needed is 1) show ID, 2) ID is run in computer 3) ID comes up clean 4) get your gun.
exactly....but of course the anti gunners don't want that.....they want the guns....and if they can they want to punish the gun owners...
That is the end goal for the true believer gun grabbers, yes. The issue is they get to sound reasonable about background checks, and our side looks bad trying to fight them all the time. We need to fight what they are proposing of course, but the discussion has to be changed to reflect what the grabbers actually want.
The first issue is to debate an issue honestly. Claiming you know what gun "grabbers actually want" is both ridiculous, dishonest. and illogical:
The pro gun alliance argues that gun control is unconstitutional, they believe the verbiage of the 2nd A. is clear. Plato in The Republic described the control of weapons in this way:
- Ridiculous sense there are more guns in America than there are people;
- Dishonest sense only a few extremists actually want to grab guns from sane, sober and honest citizens;
- Illogical in terms of a slippery slope fallacy
" Socrates then concludes that justice may be defined as telling the truth and paying one's debts. But, he says, what if a friend in a reasonable state of mind were to lend you a sword or a knife and later, in a crazed state, should ask for the repayment of the debt? Ought one to remind a friend who is in a crazed state that he is mad, and ought one to return a sword to a crazy person? The answer is plain: No."
Scalia's written decision in Heller is no different than the thinking of Socrates, so for over two thousand years restrictions / infringements on the possession of weapons has been on the radar of all civilized societies.
NYC's rules are proof that the people in power do not want normal citizens to have guns. They want to make it as difficult and as time consuming as possible, not to make sure the wrong people don't get their hands on them, but to discourage law abiding citizens from even trying. If you can't even admit that simple fact, then there is no point in continuing this conversation.
And it is a small next step to go from discouragement to prohibition, and from prohibition to confiscation.
Slippery slope arguments are not logical, nor instructive.
NYC's rules are not proof that those in power do not want normal citizens to have guns!
The theory behind background checks is to be as sure as possible that the perspective gun owner is "normal", not crazed and therefore allowing him or her to own or possess a gun presents a clear danger to others.
Then what else could be the reason for a 3-6 month wait, a long, drawn out application process, and over $1000 in fees?????
A background check can be done in minutes, as is done in the rest of the country.
Please don't be this dense.