The Invention of the Land of Israel

[eots]

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=du0OLvaFkmo]Israel Has NO Rights To Palestine, Says Jewish Historian - YouTube[/ame]

 

[Roudy]

did anybody click on that bullshit clip? Not moi.

 

[eots]

did anybody click on that bullshit clip? Not moi.

no of course you didn't you don't want to hear an Israeli historian state the fact the only claim Jews have to Israel is made up bible stories from thousands of years ago..

 

[proudveteran06]

You can thank your Nazi friends for providing an "historic precedence" for a Jewish state.

That is true. Palestine has always been inhabited by many different people. There is no historic precedence for an exclusive Jewish state.

I don't have any Nazi friends.

When the PLO defined who was a Palestinian they did not exclude anyone.

They even specifically stated that the native Jews were citizens.

You mean they don't object to JEWS living in " Palestine?" lol Another Pro Palestinian Lie. Abbas has made it quite clear he will not tolerate ANY Israeli ( That means Jewish or Arab)

 

[proudveteran06]

Israel Has NO Rights To Palestine, Says Jewish Historian - YouTube

Translation; Israel has no right to exist. It does and always will. Deal with it

 

[eots]

israel has no rights to palestine, says jewish historian - youtube

translation; israel has no right to exist. It does and always will. Deal with it

well it had no right to exist but that's another story..but it does and and yes that fact needs to be dealt with...and a peaceful solution found...which starts with dispelling the myth there is some exclusive god given right to the land

 

[MHunterB]

did anybody click on that bullshit clip? Not moi.

I never click on links left by Nazi-suckers: they've got cooties.

 

[MHunterB]

israel has no rights to palestine, says jewish historian - youtube

translation; israel has no right to exist. It does and always will. Deal with it

well it had no right to exist but that's another story..but it does and and yes that fact needs to be dealt with...and a peaceful solution found...which starts with dispelling the myth there is some exclusive god given right to the land

Jews and Zionists do not have the 'myth' that it is exclusive - at least not the vast mainstream.

 

[Roudy]

did anybody click on that bullshit clip? Not moi.

no of course you didn't you don't want to hear an Israeli historian state the fact the only claim Jews have to Israel is made up bible stories from thousands of years ago..

Really? Then all the tens of thousands of archeological sites and artifacts in Israel with Hebrew on them proving conclusively the existence of a Jewish state and people are all fake?

Just wondering, did you make it past third grade?

Thanks again for the info, tube brain. Ha ha ha.

 

[SherriMunnerlyn]

In 2009, Shlomo Sand published The Invention of the Jewish People, in which he claimed that Jews have little in common with each other. They had no common "ethnic" lineage owing to the high level of conversion in antiquity. They had no common language, since Hebrew was used only for prayer and was not even spoken at the time of Jesus. Yiddish was, at most, the language of Ashkenazi Jews. So what is left to unite them? Religion? But religion does not make a people – think of Muslims and Catholics. And most Jews are not religious. Zionism? But that is a political position: one can be a Scot and not a Scottish nationalist. Besides, the majority of Jews, including many Zionists, have not the slightest intention of going "back" to the Holy Land, much preferring, and who can blame them, to stay put in north London, or Brooklyn or wherever. In other words, "Jewish People" is a political construct, an invention. Now Sand tells us, in this second volume of what will be a trilogy, that even the "Land of Israel" was invented.

The Invention of the Land*of*Israel by Shlomo Sand ? review | Books | The Guardian

THANKS for posting about this new book!

 

[SherriMunnerlyn]

The PLO is a terrorist organization

I interesting opinion.

Shared by a number of governments, including our own.

So, will you now attempt to justify the deliberate murders of our fellow American aboard the cruise ship, and the Israeli athletes at Munich?

T"he*Palestine Liberation Organization*(PLO) (Arabic:*منظمة التحرير الفلسطينية*;**Munaẓẓamat at-Taḥrīr al-Filasṭīniyyah*(help·info)) is an organization created in 1964 with the purpose of creating an independent*State of Palestine. It is recognized as the "sole legitimate representative of thePalestinian people" by the United Nations and over 100 states with which it holds diplomatic relations,[4]*and has enjoyed observer status at the United Nations since 1974.[5]*The PLO was considered by the United States and Israel to be a terrorist organization until the*Madrid Conference*in 1991. In 1993, PLO recognized Israel's*right to exist*in peace, accepted*UN Security Council resolutions*242*and*338, and rejected "violence and terrorism"; in response, Israel officially recognized the PLO as the representative of the*Palestinian people." THE PLO is not classified by the US as a terrorist organization.

 

[SherriMunnerlyn]

I interesting opinion.

Shared by a number of governments, including our own.

So, will you now attempt to justify the deliberate murders of our fellow American aboard the cruise ship, and the Israeli athletes at Munich?

T"he*Palestine Liberation Organization*(PLO) (Arabic:*منظمة التحرير الفلسطينية*;**Munaẓẓamat at-Taḥrīr al-Filasṭīniyyah*(help·info)) is an organization created in 1964 with the purpose of creating an independent*State of Palestine. It is recognized as the "sole legitimate representative of thePalestinian people" by the United Nations and over 100 states with which it holds diplomatic relations,[4]*and has enjoyed observer status at the United Nations since 1974.[5]*The PLO was considered by the United States and Israel to be a terrorist organization until the*Madrid Conference*in 1991. In 1993, PLO recognized Israel's*right to exist*in peace, accepted*UN Security Council resolutions*242*and*338, and rejected "violence and terrorism"; in response, Israel officially recognized the PLO as the representative of the*Palestinian people." THE PLO is not classified by the US as a terrorist organization.[/QUOTE Palestine Liberation Organization - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[SherriMunnerlyn]

 

[member]

did anybody click on that bullshit clip? Not moi.

no of course you didn't you don't want to hear an Israeli historian state the fact the only claim Jews have to Israel is made up bible stories from thousands of years ago...

OMG...the Bible has mind-blowing stories. the accounts of the past....unbelievable...and "wisdom" that can only come from God. whew.

 

[eots]

did anybody click on that bullshit clip? Not moi.

no of course you didn't you don't want to hear an Israeli historian state the fact the only claim Jews have to Israel is made up bible stories from thousands of years ago...

OMG...the Bible has mind-blowing stories. the accounts of the past....unbelievable...and "wisdom" that can only come from God. whew.

The bible is full of horrid stories ,myths and fictional characters that have been disproved and has been written and re-written by men

 

[member]

no of course you didn't you don't want to hear an Israeli historian state the fact the only claim Jews have to Israel is made up bible stories from thousands of years ago...

OMG...the Bible has mind-blowing stories. the accounts of the past....unbelievable...and "wisdom" that can only come from God. whew.

"The bible is full of horrid stories ,myths and fictional characters that have been disproved and has been written and re-written by men..."

...speaking of fictional characters, here comes sherri,





... why don't you ask her what she reads in the Bible... ) = (probably the horrid stories you mention - those are fascinating too -the Bible is fascinating)........

 

[proudveteran06]

israel has no rights to palestine, says jewish historian - youtube

translation; israel has no right to exist. It does and always will. Deal with it

well it had no right to exist but that's another story..but it does and and yes that fact needs to be dealt with...and a peaceful solution found...which starts with dispelling the myth there is some exclusive god given right to the land

Notice how the Pro Palestinian posters are paranoid? Who here is claiming that GOD gave them the land? Who initiated all the Wars since 1948? The Palestinians were offered almost everything they wanted and it was rejected Israel is not;

Going to go back to the 67 Borders that were never recognized

Give up rights to E. Jerusalem

Allow " Right of Return"


Get it now? Of course not

 

[SherriMunnerlyn]

 

[eots]

translation; israel has no right to exist. It does and always will. Deal with it

well it had no right to exist but that's another story..but it does and and yes that fact needs to be dealt with...and a peaceful solution found...which starts with dispelling the myth there is some exclusive god given right to the land

notice how the pro palestinian posters are paranoid? Who here is claiming that god gave them the land? Who initiated all the wars since 1948? The palestinians were offered almost everything they wanted and it was rejected israel is not;

going to go back to the 67 borders that were never recognized

give up rights to e. Jerusalem

allow " right of return"


get it now? Of course not

I fully support the jews right to return to europe..

 

[MHunterB]

Speaking of myths: over half the Jewish Israelis are Sephardim or Mizrachim - they don't hail from 'Europe' most recently, but the Middle East.

And they were stripped of their possessions, their lands, their citizenship and ejected from those ME countries simply because they were Jews.