The Right To Bear Arms

[westwall]

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

As has been told, and PROVEN to you on multiple occasions, it is an INDIVIDUAL RIGHT (that means it is a Right that individual PEOPLE are born with). Now go away.

 

[Frankeneinstein]

More: Is the Second Amendment obsolete? - The Week

Jakestarkey, a poster here and admitted left wing communist himself claims that no one wants to do away with the second amendment, how do you explain the hypocrisy between your propaganda and his?

 

[sakinago]

The People = The Militia.

Only the right wing never gets it.

Well regulated militia of the People may not be Infringed when keeping and bearing Arms for their State or the Union.

Again why were the founders so scared of a standing army?

 

[danielpalos]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

You have nothing but diversion.

The People are the militia. You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

 

[Frankeneinstein]

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

our constitution is national/federal

 

[danielpalos]

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

As has been told, and PROVEN to you on multiple occasions, it is an INDIVIDUAL RIGHT (that means it is a Right that individual PEOPLE are born with). Now go away.

Nothing but fallacy.

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

It says so in the first clause.

 

[westwall]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

You have nothing but diversion.

The People are the militia. You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

You have nothing but lies. The meaning of Well Regulated has been shown to you multiple times. The meaning of the Militia, and who is IN the militia has likewise been shown to you multiple times. You ignore all that has been shown to you before to spread your lies. Lying is all you seem to be capable of doing.

 

[danielpalos]

The People = The Militia.

Only the right wing never gets it.

Well regulated militia of the People may not be Infringed when keeping and bearing Arms for their State or the Union.

Again why were the founders so scared of a standing army?

The People are the militia.

 

[danielpalos]

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

our constitution is national/federal

Individual rights aren't?

 

[danielpalos]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

You have nothing but diversion.

The People are the militia. You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

You have nothing but lies. The meaning of Well Regulated has been shown to you multiple times. The meaning of the Militia, and who is IN the militia has likewise been shown to you multiple times. You ignore all that has been shown to you before to spread your lies. Lying is all you seem to be capable of doing.

Projecting much?

Well regulated must be prescribed by Congress for the militia of the United States.

It is in Article 1,Section 8.

 

[Natural Citizen]

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

No. It's an Individual right. Though, the States protect the Individual's right.

 

[Frankeneinstein]

The People are the militia.

and everyone else is their enemy

You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

but in either case legally allowed to arm yourself

 

[Frankeneinstein]

Individual rights aren't?

are you pretending this has anything at all to do with my post?

 

[westwall]

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

As has been told, and PROVEN to you on multiple occasions, it is an INDIVIDUAL RIGHT (that means it is a Right that individual PEOPLE are born with). Now go away.

Nothing but fallacy.

Our Second Amendment is a States right.

It says so in the first clause.

Yes, you are indeed a lying sack of poo. The ONLY people who claim that the 2nd is not an individual Right are socialist groups, and their members. Go figure, they can't control the population the way they like when the population can defend itself.

Progressives like to insist that the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects a collective, rather than an individual, right to “keep and bear arms.” Or, put another way, they say that the only right Americans have to the ownership of lethal weaponry exists within the context of state-sanctioned military service. As a result, progressives conclude that there is nothing in place to stop the federal government from prohibiting the private ownership of firearms and allowing access to weapons only to those who belong to the National Guard — the modern descendant of early-American state and local militia forces.

Read more at: Of Course the Second Amendment Protects an Individual Right to Keep and Bear Arms

In 2008 the U.S. Supreme Court recognized what numerous historians and legal scholars have been saying for many decades: Namely, that the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution secures an individual right—not a collective one—to keep and bear arms. Yet despite this widespread legal and academic consensus, certain gun control advocates still insist on behaving as if the Second Amendment does not mean what it says.

Yes, the Second Amendment Protects Individual Rights

 

[Natural Citizen]

Projecting much?

Well regulated must be prescribed by Congress for the militia of the United States.

It is in Article 1,Section 8.

Do you know what Federalism means?

 

[sakinago]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

You have nothing but diversion.

The People are the militia. You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

Yes the people are the militia, militia being decentralized and not under government control...if a federal statue or state statute could make laws to severely limit the capabilities of the people forming their milita (regulation the way you want to see it)...well then the militia/people have no teeth to defend themselves against the government. So if regulated meant the same thing you think you mean in these modern times, as it did back then...then the second amendment both gave the ability to arm and disarm the militia at the same time...does that make sense to you????Ho w can you not put this together? Stop repeating the same damn lines, it doesn’t make them true. You have two lines, one is “blah blah blah, if we got rid of the war on drugs, we’d blah blah blah.” Or it’s this one “you’re either well regulated or not”

 

[westwall]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

You have nothing but diversion.

The People are the militia. You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

You have nothing but lies. The meaning of Well Regulated has been shown to you multiple times. The meaning of the Militia, and who is IN the militia has likewise been shown to you multiple times. You ignore all that has been shown to you before to spread your lies. Lying is all you seem to be capable of doing.

Projecting much?

Well regulated must be prescribed by Congress for the militia of the United States.

It is in Article 1,Section 8.

Well regulated means "IN GOOD WORKING ORDER".
verb (used with object), regulated, regulating.
1.
to control or direct by a rule, principle, method, etc.:
to regulate household expenses.
2.
to adjust to some standard or requirement, as amount, degree, etc.:
to regulate the temperature.
3.
to adjust so as to ensure accuracy of operation:
to regulate a watch.
4.
to put in good order:
to regulate the digestion.


the definition of well-regulated

 

[danielpalos]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

The People are the militia. Any questions?

 

[danielpalos]

The People = The Militia.

Only the right wing never gets it.

Well regulated militia of the People may not be Infringed when keeping and bearing Arms for their State or the Union.

Again why were the founders so scared of a standing army?

Why is the right wing for socialism on a national basis?

 

[danielpalos]

Only well regulated militia of the People are necessary and shall not be Infringed.

The unorganized militia is not and may be infringed.

Go back and read my post right and in the tenor which it was offered.

And read Federalist numbers 28 and 46 twice while you're there.

You have nothing but diversion.

The People are the militia. You are either well regulated and necessary or unorganized and unnecessary.

You have nothing but lies. The meaning of Well Regulated has been shown to you multiple times. The meaning of the Militia, and who is IN the militia has likewise been shown to you multiple times. You ignore all that has been shown to you before to spread your lies. Lying is all you seem to be capable of doing.

Projecting much?

Well regulated must be prescribed by Congress for the militia of the United States.

It is in Article 1,Section 8.

Well regulated means "IN GOOD WORKING ORDER".
verb (used with object), regulated, regulating.
1.
to control or direct by a rule, principle, method, etc.:
to regulate household expenses.
2.
to adjust to some standard or requirement, as amount, degree, etc.:
to regulate the temperature.
3.
to adjust so as to ensure accuracy of operation:
to regulate a watch.
4.
to put in good order:
to regulate the digestion.


the definition of well-regulated

So what. All you have is an appeal to ignorance.

Congress must prescribe wellness of regulation for the militia of the United States.