itfitzme
VIP Member
Oh god, you are still running with this old left piece
Really, the radical left needs to update their talking points
This is up there with the extreme left's other favorite talking point
that the Soviet Union was not really communism.
Nice try but
Your "spending" includes things like SS payments, military pay and payments for resources/services
Let's see....
Using your analysis, we should them tell
Seniors- that Earned Benefit you were forced to pay for by the gov't, your whole life- guess what- you are just a taker
Military-- that is not Pay for your work- but a handout
Resources/Services- that is really not a market exchange for product- but a handout.
Unlike welfare, these are exchanges for productive services.
Well, to be fair, welfare does buy Democrat votes
Considering that Seniors will retire, companies will open and military bases will stay open in states
due to being or any combination of low tax, friendly to the Military, right to work states,
it should be no surprise that these players move to these states.
The fact remains, the biggest Welfare states are still Democratic ones.
Really, if paid for retirement benefits concern the left so much, easy solution..
We can just return all the monies they paid in, with real interest, and they
can stop being such a "burden" to the federal gov't
Right wing CNBC
Biggest Welfare states
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Michigan
Rhode Island
Indiana
New Mexico
Washington
Minnesota
New York
District of Columbia
Vermont
Massachusetts
Tennessee
Maine
California
How many of these voted for Papa Obama and the rest of the radical left
Truth is hard for the left
In fact, it is their worst enemy
"Your "spending" includes things like SS payments, military pay and payments for resources/services"
You are wrong there. You simply decided you don't like the way it turns out, then made up bullshit about why it must be wrong. It is exactly the behavior I've come to expect from you. You don't follow through on actually research.
The data I am using does not include direct payments, military pay, or whatever. It is monies to the states and local governments. We can add in federal monies going to the military and OASDI. That's a good idea. It is, after all, still Federal dollars that ends up in the local economy.
Regardless, the conservative states take larger proportion of money from the federal government than they put in in tax revenues. You can make all the excuses you want, but it doesn't change the facts. It doesn't change the fact that the red state economies are substantially bolstered by Federal dollars.
And there is a reason that the states that vote Democrat put it more money in tax revenues, because they produce more in real dollar gross state product.
![](/proxy.php?image=http%3A%2F%2Fi776.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fyy42%2Fthefitz3%2FNewPicture-14.png&hash=108ecbba7f8b513bff1805f013b64143)
Producing more value results in paying more in federal taxes. $ is a numerical measure that is what it is. You can't change it by using emotional bullshit like "socialism", "communism", and on and on. Nobody gives a crap about your retarded fixation with the Soviet Union. The cold war ended along time ago. Try and catch up. You are living in a fantasy land.
And, none of that has anything to do with where seniors retire either. We should add them it. It is, after all, money into the economy.
You are just desperately trying to manipulation the facts to fit what you want to be true. The facts don't make someone a liberal or conservative, they are just the facts. Ignoring the facts does make you stupid.
You can squirm wildly all you want, but the reality is that you are wrong. I'm not making a case for Blue states. I'm just proving that you are wrong.
You keep claiming you have facts, yet present nothing. I get that it is a bitter pill for you to swallow. But getting all whiny about it won't change anything.
All you have is emotional bullshit that means nothing. That the Democratic states made more money does. You can cherry pick all day long, but this won't change.
They make more money, they pay more taxes, they support themselves and Republican states. California just slipped to only the 9th largest economy in the world.
(you do understand what "real dollars" and "per capita" mean, right?)
Last edited: