Fort Fun Indiana
Diamond Member
- Mar 10, 2017
- 96,134
- 71,654
"And if you can't find a way to interpret a fantastical story like the bodily ascension of Jesus into heaven, in a way that conforms to reality doesn't mean that there isn't a way. it makes you feel better to say its all bullshit than to admit that you haven't figured it out, ""Reality is a reliable and constant constraint on any possible interpretation. "Yes, but you forgot the rest: You can avoid all of these intellectual, real world challenges, if you simply wrap yourself in fantasy, lobotomize yourself, and hide in a bubble made of gawd stuff.
Terrible lesson. It glorifies ignorance and fantasy, while eschewing intellectualism and knowledge. Completely backwards, intellectually, morally , and ethically.
lol...I agree that that is a terrible lesson but, if you think a little more deeply about it, its not based on whats actually written or the intended teaching.
Sounds more like the dogma and specious falsehoods of talking serpents that misrepresent the stories in the Bible, OT and NT ( depending on the species) in order to deceive the gullible to their advantage.
Just like that ever deceitful talking serpent of old.....
And how do we know they are "misrepresenting" the stories, and not just lookong at them differently? That's a problem with religious literature. It's one thing to debate what a story means to you; it's quite another to debate how it is supposed to dictate our lives. I never entered into a debate of the moral undercurrents of a Twain story with the pretense that my eternal well-being depended on the outcome of the debate!
How do we know they are misrepresenting the stories? Reality is a reliable and constant constraint on any possible interpretation. So far much of our differences have been inconsequential. At least we agree on the nature of reality, the value of scientific study and discoveries , and the absurdity of professing a belief in supernatural or magical gobbledygook..
When the waters of contention are stirred, the truth is brought out. I have no problem being proven wrong if the truth is brought out. Everybody would benefit.
so far you have learned that the creation of Heaven and Earth according to the book of Genesis is not about the creation of the solar system, the earth, the first plants, animals, or human beings whether you like it or not.
You have also been given the basis, firmament, upon which to build an understanding about what the subjects of Heaven and Earth in the story are actually about.
Now put on your thinking cap and get to work.
Thanks for playing along...
On fantastic Biblical tales? Haha....no it isn't .....what a completely ridiculous thing to say. No, sorry, the correct answer is that there is absolutely no way whatsoever to be able to tell who is interpreting some bit of religious bullshit correctly and who isn't. Sectarian strife will never, ever go away, because there is absolutely no way, real or imagined, to tell who is correct about any of it.
Yes, reality is a reliable and constant constraint on any possible interpretation of any fantastical story.
Metaphors, allegories,parables, homonyms, hyperbole, etc., are all well known literary techniques and teaching tools.
The OT is called the Torah,meaning instruction not history. The gospels mean good news not bullshit.
And if you can't find a way to interpret a fantastical story like the bodily ascension of Jesus into heaven, in a way that conforms to reality doesn't mean that there isn't a way. If it makes you feel better to say its all bullshit than to admit that you haven't figured it out, you might as well stop disputing with me and go and play golf or something...it will certainly mess up your day when the truth comes to light..
Reality itself inescapably limits the possibilities of what the story could possibly be about. It is impossible that the ascension is about Jesus bodily floating up into the sky literally after he had risen from the dead and Acts 1:11 describing the ascension explicitly says in no uncertain terms that Jesus did not float up into the sky.
Would you like to see how although the disciples were watching and they lost sight of Jesus after he was obscured behind a cloud has nothing whatever to do with clouds in the sky or altitude?
There is something of great value buried and hidden there.
"The kingdom of Heaven is like treasure lying buried in a field. The man who found it buried it again,"
can you dig it?
Surely the sweat of your brow can produce more than just thorns and thistles.
Maybe? Maybe not.
Of course I can conform any of those stories to reality....precisely by calling them bullshit. Man came back from the dead and rose to heaven? Bullshit. There, conformed. Otherwise, no, you are not going to reconcile magical resurrection to reality, without introducing magic. And once you do, then anything can be true. So, magic or no, any story can be "conformed to reality". Man claims to talk to houseplants? He's delusional or lying. There, I just conformed his story to reality.
Man put animals on boat and saved the global fauna from great flood? Bullshit....conformed.
That's my point. Of course we can extract all manner of allegory and metaphor to suit ourselves and our own realities. That's my other point. It seems more that we are in agreement than in disagreement.
Last edited: