Oldandtired
Rookie
- Banned
- #181
That's the issue in the United States, nobody earns what they get, and laborers, those who actually earn more than the get get kicked into poverty. I'm closing in on a civil engineering degree and is it fair that I'll never make as much as a congressman does without their interest group bonuses? No. Relatively few people earn their right to be rich these days. "The sooner we shed our illusion that people end up financially where they deserve to, the faster well fix the economy." -Matt Miller
A childish view perpetuated by a dearth of understanding of human nature.
"Here is what would happen in reality if someone ever did create such a society:
Within a year, some people would be wealthy. Some would be penniless. There would be a lot of resentment from the ones who frittered their money away towards the ones that managed to use their natural good thinking, instincts, and sheer determination to parlay their start-up funds into fortunes.
Within five years, there would be an upper class, a middle class, and a lower class. The rich would continue to get richer, and the poor would continue to get poorer.
Some people would find loopholes enabling them to cheat the cheatable. Some people would be so gullible they would find themselves easy targets for those who would take advantage of them. Some people would have scruples, others would not.
Some people would begin to steal, and murder, and whatever else they think will allow them to circumvent the legal process to success.
You see, Utopia isn't possible this side of Heaven. There is too much diversity in people.
Some people are ambitious, some are not. Some people are industrious, some are not. Some people are inventive, some are not. Some people take pride in good workmanship, others are just content to get the job done, whether it is done well or not. Some people are workaholics, some are just plain lazy.
Some people buy anything, Some people buy nothing. Some buy what they want. Some buy only what they need. Some people are foolish with money, some are miserly.
It takes all kinds to make a world. It takes one kind to make a Utopia."
Casting Pearls Before Swine: Why Communism Can't Work
That makes sense. So are you saying it is a cyclical system of economies? If it is theoretically true that the ultimate result of a capitalist society is a communistic one (when the masses of poor overtake the rich) and then theoretically that people will naturally turn it into a capitalistic society again.... Sounds interesting. I guess socialism is the red headed stepchild of economic schemes?
I certainly can see how jealousy and greed work together turning a capitalistic society into a communistic one.
I can not see as easy a transition from communistic to capitalistic. When people become dependent, it is difficult to let go.