Classic Rock battle. Disturbed vs Simon & Garfunkel

[Remodeling Maidiac]

Vs




Which do you like more? Obviously nostalgia will play a bias role but for me the emotions that are drawn out with the "raspy vocals" by Disturbed make this one of the few covers where I think the new artist has surpassed the original. What say you? And please don't vote until actually listening to both.

 

[petro]

I will roll Simon and Garfunkel. As I get older, my tolerance of loud heavy music has disappeared. Not a fan of the remake.

 

[Remodeling Maidiac]

I will roll Simon and Garfunkel. As I get older, my tolerance of loud heavy music has disappeared. Not a fan of the remake.

Did you listen to it? Its neither loud nor heavy. And it has an orchestra type accompaniment ffs lol

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Vs




Which do you like more? Obviously nostalgia will play a bias role but for me the emotions that are drawn out with the "raspy vocals" by Disturbed make this one of the few covers where I think the new artist has surpassed the original. What say you? And please don't vote until actually listening to both.

I don't consider the original to be Rock.

 

[Remodeling Maidiac]

Vs




Which do you like more? Obviously nostalgia will play a bias role but for me the emotions that are drawn out with the "raspy vocals" by Disturbed make this one of the few covers where I think the new artist has surpassed the original. What say you? And please don't vote until actually listening to both.

I don't consider the original to be Rock.

What would you consider it?

 

[Remodeling Maidiac]

Wiki lists them as folk rock

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Vs




Which do you like more? Obviously nostalgia will play a bias role but for me the emotions that are drawn out with the "raspy vocals" by Disturbed make this one of the few covers where I think the new artist has surpassed the original. What say you? And please don't vote until actually listening to both.

I don't consider the original to be Rock.

What would you consider it?

Folk sounds right.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

Wiki lists them as folk rock

Rock? Meh......

 

[petro]

I will roll Simon and Garfunkel. As I get older, my tolerance of loud heavy music has disappeared. Not a fan of the remake.

Did you listen to it? Its neither loud nor heavy. And it has an orchestra type accompaniment ffs lol

I have heard it many times. Simply don't care for it.

 

[Remodeling Maidiac]

I will roll Simon and Garfunkel. As I get older, my tolerance of loud heavy music has disappeared. Not a fan of the remake.

Did you listen to it? Its neither loud nor heavy. And it has an orchestra type accompaniment ffs lol

I have heard it many times. Simply don't care for it.

Fair enough

 

[petro]

Latest new rock song I like is Shame by the Foo Fighters. Tool has a new release I like also.

 

[Remodeling Maidiac]

Latest new rock song I like is Shame by the Foo Fighters. Tool has a new release I like also.

Evanescence has a new album in the works.
She took about 10 years off doing orchestral/stage type music. Saw her a couple years ago with Lindsey Sterling. Lindsey was amazing, Amy Lee not so much.

 

[MarathonMike]

David Draiman turned it into a totally different song which I think is awesome. I like them both.